Experimental Study on Flexural Behavior of Concrete Filled Steel Tube Beam

Download Full-Text PDF Cite this Publication

Text Only Version

Experimental Study on Flexural Behavior of Concrete Filled Steel Tube Beam

Mr. Kunal Uttam Chavan

  1. G. Student, Civil Engineering,

    SKN Sinhgad College of Engineering, Korti, Pandharpur, Maharashtra

    Mr. S. S. Kadam

    Project Guide, Civil Engineering,

    SKN Sinhgad College of Engineering, Korti, Pandharpur, Maharashtra

    Abstract Concrete filled steel tubes (CFST) member have many advantages compared with the ordinary structural member made of steel or reinforced concrete. One of the main advantages is the interaction between the steel tube and concrete. Concrete delays the steel tubes local buckling, whereas the steel tube confines the concrete and thereby increases the concretes strength. CFSTs are economical and permit rapid construction because the steel tube serves as formwork and reinforcement to the concrete fill, negating the need for either. The deformation capacity of the system is increased by the combined action of the concrete fill with the thin, ductile steel tube. The concrete fill significantly increases inelastic deformation capacity and the compressive stiffness and load capacity of the CFST member. In building construction concrete filled steel tubes are very widely used for columns in combination with steel or reinforced concrete beam. In this work totally 9 specimens will tested out of which 3 specimens were empty steel tubes and remaining 6 specimens were concrete filled with different bonding techniques. Comparison of experimental flexural stiffness with existing codes, such as AIJ- 1997, BS5400-1979, EC4-1994, and LRFD-AISC-1999.

    Keywords Concrete fill Steel Section, flexural Behavior, different bonding techniques.)

    1. INTRODUCTION

      Concrete-filled steel hollow section (CFSHS) columns are widely used in the construction industry for the past few years owing to advantages of combining two constituent materials. The steel hollow section in-filled with concrete has higher strength and larger stiffness than the conventional structural steel section and reinforced concrete. It can be more economical to use CFSHS columns for the construction of building structures because of the ease of fabrication and lightweight [1]. Concrete-filed steel tubes -CFSTs are used in many structural applications including columns, supporting platforms of offshore structures, roofs of storage tanks, bridge piers, piles, and columns in seismic zones. Concrete-filed steel box columns offer excellent structural performance, such as high strength, high ductility and large energy absorption capacity and have been widely used as primary axial load carrying members in high-rise buildings, bridges and offshore structures. Application of the CFST concept can lead to overall savings of steel in comparison with conventional structural steel systems. In CFST composite construction steel tubes are also used as permanent formwork and to provide well-distributed reinforcement [2] Composite members consisting of circular steel tubes filled with concrete are extensively used in structures involving very large applied moments, particularly in zones of high seismicity. Composite circular concrete filled tubes (CFT) have been used

      increasingly as columns and beam-columns in braced and unbraced frame structures. Their use worldwide has ranged from compression members in low-rise, open floor plan construction using cold-formed steel circular or rectangular tubes filled with precast or cast-in-place concrete, to large diameter cast-in-place members used as the primary lateral resistance columns in multi-story buildings. In addition, concrete filling is widely used in retrofitting of damaged steel bridge piers after the earthquake in Japan and the Northridge earthquake in the USA. The CFT structural members have a number of distinctive advantages over conventional steel reinforced concrete members. CFT members provide excellent seismic resistance in two orthogonal directions as well as good damping characteristics. These members also have excellent hysteresis behavior under cyclic loading, compared with hollow tubes [5]

    2. OBJECTIVES The objectives of present study are:

      To find out the ultimate flexural strengths of empty and concrete filled steel tube beam.

      To check effect of different bonding technique on flexural strength of concrete filled steel tube beam.

      To check the behavior, failure and crack pattern of in filled concrete.

      Validate experiment result with AIJ-1997, BS5400-1979, EC4-1994, LRFD-AISC-1999.

    3. LITERATURE REVIEW 1] wie-Min Gho et.al. (2004) :-

      Wie-Min Gho et.al. (2004) presented Flexural behavior of high-strength rectangular concrete-filled steel hollow sections. In this experimental work the behavior of concrete filled steel tubes under pure bending was studied. Twelve rectangular hollow tubes with different sizes 150×150; 200×150 and 250×150 mm were used. High strength concrete (56.3MPa to 90.9MPa) was used as infill for the hollow tubes for composite action. Yield stresses of hollow tubes were 438Mpa, 495Mpa and 409Mpa respectively. They concluded that the post yielding behaviour was good enough with ductility performance. A comparison of the experimental values and values calculated from design formulas in EC4, ACI and AISC were made. The codes underrated moment capacities of the specimens considered. EC4 provides better moment carrying capacity than ACI and AISC and the difference is about 11%. THE ACI and AISC codes

      underrated the flexural strength of the specimens by 15 and 18%, respectively. On evaluating the codes with the collected data, test results show an increase in flexural strengths by 9, 12 and 15%, respectively.

      2] Arivalagan et.al. (2009):-

      Arivalagan et.al. (2009) presented the study of Energy Absorption Capacity of Composite Beams Ultimate strength capacity of a square hollow section filled with fibrous foamed concrete. A brief experimental research was conducted in the experimental work, the moment capacity and the behaviour of unfilled and concrete filled hollow sections were noted down. The sections were subjected to cyclic reversible loading. Here the filler materials were of two types, normal concrete and fly ash concrete. The effect of filler materials used, slenderness of section, load vs deflection, momentstrain curve, ductility, stiffness degradation and energy absorption of concrete filled RHS beams were studied. Totally 9 specimens were considered. 3 were rectangular hollow sections, 3 were concrete filled steel tubes and the other six were fly ash filled steel tubes. The sizes of RHS section was 100x50x3.2 mm. They concluded that the increase in ultimate moment capacity was due to the filler material strength. The ultimate moment capacity for concrete-filled RHS members based on CIDECT standard was found to be in good agreement with the experimental moment capacity of Rectangular hollow steel beams filled with normal concrete and fly ash concrete. Experimental results prove that void filling increases energy absorption capacity of the section and also reduces the stiffness degradation. It also increases the ductility factor. The study showed that fly ash concrete could be used as infill material for a satisfactory mechanism.

      3] Andrew Wheeler et.al. (2015)

      Andrew Wheeler et.al. (2015) present Flexure Behavior of Concrete Filled Thin-Walled Steel Tubes with Longitudinal Reinforcement. Tests were carried on the tube specimens and the flexural stiffness of specimens were measured. Additionally in the experimental work, the change in flexural stiffness decreases with increase in diameter of the section. The concrete filled tubes wich had larger depth to span ratios, there was cracking on tension side of the specimens and multiple cracks at the mid span. This effect was noted down by Wheeler and Bridge in their work. Both the issues emphasises that size of the specimens effect on flexural behaviour of concrete filled tubular members.

      4] Manojkumar V. Chitawadagi et.al. (2009) –

      Manojkumar V. Chitawadagi et.al. (2009) – The strength deformation behaviour of circular steel tubes filled with different grades of concrete under flexure is presented. The effects of steel tube thickness, the cross sectional area of concrete, strength of in-filled concrete and the confinement of concrete on moment capacity and curvature of Concrete Filled steel Tubes (CFTs) are examined he conclude that A substantial increase in the moment of resistance and the corresponding curvature of all the hollow sections used in the experimental investigation are observed due to concrete filling and the CFT specimens exhibited a higher ductility than the hollow sections. An increase in the wall thickness of the steel tube increases the moment of resistance and ductility of both the hollow and CFT samples. An increase in strength of in- filled concrete for a given wall thickness of a CFT specimen,

      does not help in increasing the moment carrying capacity to a great extent.

      5] M. Elchalakani et.al. (2001) –

      M. Elchalakani et.al. (2001) presents an experimental investigation of the flexural behaviour of circular CFT subjected to large deformation pure bending. In general, void filling of the steel tube enhances strength, ductility and energy absorption especially for thinner sections.

      6] Lin-Hai Han et.al. (2003)

      Lin-Hai Han (2003) develop a mechanics model that can predict the behaviour of concrete-filled hollow structural section beams. To develop formulas for the calculation of the moment capacity of the concrete-filled HSS beams, such formulas should be suitable for incorporation into building codes.

      7] Naveena Treesa et.al. (2016)

      Naveena Treesa (2016) From the studies conducted on three different beams it can be seen that a concrete filled steel tubular section with reinforcement resists tension, bending moments and also increases load carrying capacity when compared to a normal reinforced concrete and steel section of similar dimensions.

    4. MATERIALS AND METHODS

      This experimental work was conducted to check the flexural behaviour of empty steel tube and concrete filled steel tube beams. Main objective was to find out the ultimate flexural strengths of empty and concrete filled steel tube beams. All specimens were of uniform cross section 96mmx48mm of thickness 3.2mm and of length 1000mm. Steel tubes were confirming to Indian Standard code IS 4923 : 1997. All specimens were tested under two point loading with simple supports in Universal Testing Machine (UTM) of capacity 200 tonnes.

      The material required for concrete are tested in laboratory before use it for making concrete. In this experiment work M25 grade concrete is used.

      1. Material Used and Material Properties

        Cement:

        The cement used in this experimental work is 53 grade Ordinary Portland Cement. No doubt the laboratory test have been done at the factory before production come from factory. But cement may go bad during transportation and storage prior to its use in Work. All properties of cement are tested by referring IS 12269 – 1987 Specification for 53 Grade Ordinary Portland Cement. List of Laboratory test conducted on cement are listed below;

        1. Fineness of cement (residue on IS sieve No. 9)

        2. Standard consistency of cement

        3. Setting time of cement (Initial & Final setting time )

        4. Compressive strength of cement ( 7 & 28 days )

        5. Specific Gravity

      Aggregate:

      Aggregates influence the properties of concrete/mortar such as water requirement, cohesiveness and workability of the concrete in plastic stage, while they influence strength, density, durability and permeability, surface finish and colour in hardened stage. Natural sand from Banganga River confirming to IS 383-1970 is used. Crushed black trap basalt rock of aggregate size 12mm down was used confirming to IS 383-1970.

      The properties of aggregate are tested by referring IS 383- 1970 Specification for Coarse and Fine Aggregates from Natural Sources for Concrete. List of test conducted on aggregate are listed below;

      1. Specific Gravity

      2. Surface Moisture Content & water Absorption

      3. Sieve Analysis

      4. Fineness Modulus Hallow Section:

      Steel hallow section of size 96mm X 48mm X 3.2mm of 1m length is used for this experimental work. Steel tube confining to Indian Standard code IS 4923 : 1997. Steel tube available in 6m length in local market. It cut into 1m piece, from retailer following data will available;

      Yield stress fy = 270 N/mm2 Ultimate stress fu = 410 N/mm2

      Modulus of Elasticity E = 2.05 × 105 N/mm2.

      1. Concrete Filled Steel Tube Beam with Sand Blasting inner surface (CFSTBWSB) – 03 Number.

      2. Concrete Filled Steel Tube Beam With 10mm HYSD bar as Diagonal Shear Connection (CFSTBWDSC) – 03 Number.

        Sand Blasting of Specimen:

        For 3 number of specimens, inner surface of tube were roughed to develop bond between bond between steel and concrete with epoxy resin araldite and sand particles of grain size retaining on 4.75mm sieve. First inner surface was cleaned for dust and corrosion particles then a layer of Araldite was applied on inner surface and then sand particles were sprinkled on that surface. Then the steel tube was left for 24 hours undisturbed.

        Welding of Shear Connectors:

        For 3 numbers of specimens, 2 numbers of 10mm diameter HYSD bars were welded at the ends of tubes diagonally as shear connector. End plugs were provided at one end of steel tubes to fill concrete from other side. Polythene sheet was used with araldite.

        Fig. 2 Welding of Shear Connection

        Concreting of Specimens:

        Totally 9 specimens were filled with M25 grade of concrete. Concrete filled tubes were cured by immersing the tube in water for 28days.

        Fig. 1 Hallow Steel Section

    5. RESULT AND DISCUSSION Preparation of Specimen & Testing:

This experimental work was conducted to check the

Test Setup:

Fig. 3 Concreting of Specimens

flexural behavior of empty steel tube and concrete filled steel tube beams. Main objective was to find out the ultimate flexural strengths of empty and concrete filled steel tube beams. Total 12 number of specimen used in this work. All specimen were of uniform cross section of size 96mm X 48mm X 3.2mm and length 1000mm are used.

The specimen detail are as follow;

    1. Empty Steel Tube (EST) – 03 Number

    2. Concrete Filled Steel Tube Beam (CFSTB) – 03 Number.

All specimens were tested under two point static loading as simply supported condition with a span of 900 mm. All specimens were tested in Universal Testing machine (UTM) of capacity 200 tonnes. The load was introduced at the rate of 2 KN/minute. Deflections were noted down at every 2 KN interval. Load was applied up to a point when the needle comes back and final load was noted down as ultimate load of the beam. To compare all specimens, ultimate load, ultimate deflection and allowable deflection is tabulated and presented graphically.

Fig. 4 Load Vs Deflection Graph of EST

Fig. 6 Load Vs Deflection Graph of CFSTWSB

Fig. 5 Load Vs Deflection Graph of CFST

Fig. 7 Load Vs Deflection Graph of CFSTWDS

Summary of results obtained from experimental investigation sown in following table;

Sr

.N

o.

Bea m type

Ultimate load

( KN)

Averag e ultimat e load ( KN)

Percen tage of strengt h incras e

( %)

Ultima te experi mental mome nt (KN- M)

Ultim ate deflec tion (mm)

1

EST

-1

100

104.67

—–

13.33

15.20

2

EST

-2

108

14.4

16.80

3

EST

-3

106

14.30

16.66

4

CFS T-1

172

172.00

64.33

22.93

14.83

5

CFS T-2

168

22.40

15.47

6

CFS T-3

176

23.46

15.94

7

CFS TW SB- 1

204

204.67

100

27.20

16.80

8

CFS TW SB- 2

200

26.67

15.52

9

CFS TW SB- 3

210

28.00

16.3

10

CFS TW DS- 1

226

226.00

115.92

30.13

15.97

11

CFS TW DS- 2

222

29.60

16.74

12

CFS TW DS- 3

230

30.67

17.2

VALIDATION OF RESULT:

The experimental flexural stiffness (Kee) determined for the tested beams are compared with the flexural stiffnesss (Ke) calculated from the expressions given in the codes and are listed.

AIJ-1997

Flexural Stiffness Ke = Es. Is + 0.20 Ec. Ic

where Es = 205,800 Mpa; Ec = 21,000 (fc/19.60) 1/2 Mpa BS 5400-1979

Flexural Stiffness Ke = Es. Is + Ec. Ic

where Es = 206,000 Mpa; Ec = 450. Fcu Mpa EC 4-1994

Flexural Stiffness Ke = Es. Is + 0.60 Ec. Ic

where Es = 206,000 Mpa; Ec = 9500 (fck + 8)1/3 Mpa AISC-LRFD-1999

Flexural Stiffness Ke = Es. Is + 0.80 Ec. Ic

where Es = 199,000 Mpa; Ec = 4733 (fc ) 1/2 Mpa

CONCLUSIONS:

Flexural load carrying capacity of concrete filled steel tubes nearly doubled when compared to empty steel tubes.

Much difference between different bonding techniques was not seen in any of the specimen.

The maximum load was taken by the specimen CFSTBWDSC, it may be because of presence of diagonal shear connector inside the tube.

As concrete is confined by steel tube all around, sudden failure of beams may not occur.

REFERENCES

  1. Wie-Min Gho, Dalin Liu, Flexural Behaviour of High-Strength Rectangular Concrete-Filled Steel Hollow Sections, Journal of Constructional Steel Research, 60, (2004), 1681 1696.

  2. Arivalagan and Kandasamy,Energy Absorption Capacity of Composite Beams, Journal of Engineering Science and Technology Review, 2 (1), (2009), 145 150.

  3. Dr. Andrew Wheeler, Prof. Russell Bridge, Flexure Behaviour of Concrete Filled Thin-Walled Steel Tubes with Longitudinal Reinforcement, School of Engineering; University of Western Sydney Locked Bag (2003), 99-130.

  4. Manojkumar V. Chitawadagi, Mattur C. Narasimhan., Strength deformation behaviour of circular concrete filled steel tubes subjected to pure bending Journal of Constructional Steel Research 65 (2009) 18361845

  5. M. Elchalakani, X.L. Zhao, R.H. Grzebieta, Concrete-filled circular steel tubes subjected to pure bending Journal of Constructional Steel Research 57 (2001) 11411168

  6. Lin-Hai Han, Flexural behavior of concrete-filled steel tubes, Journal of Constructional Steel Research 60 (2004) 313337.

  7. Naveena Treesa Joseph, Flexural Performance of Concrete Filled Steel

    Tube Beams, International Journal of Engineering Research & Technology (IJERT) ISSN:2278-0181 Vol. 5 Issue 07, July-2016

  8. Bharathi.K.M, Flexural Behaviour Of Concrete Beams With Composite Reinforcement, International Journal of Science and Engineering Research (IJ0SER), Vol 3 Issue 10 October-2015 3221 5687, (P) 3221 568X

  9. E K Mohanraj, SEISMIC BEHAVIOUR OF CONCRETE FILLED STEEL TUBULAR BEAMS 35th Conference on OUR WORLD IN CONCRETE & STRUCTURES: 25 – 27 August 2010, Singapore Article Online Id: 100035039

  10. Dr. Ali I. Tayeh Flexural Behavior of Concrete-Filled Steel Hollow Sections Beams Dean of College of Applied Engineering and Urban Planning

  11. Arivalagan Soundararajan, Flexural behaviour of concrete filled steel hollow sections beams Journal of Civil Engineering and Management ISSN: 1392-3730 (Print) 1822-3605 (Online) Journal homepage: http://www.tandfonline.com/loi/tcem20

  12. IS 4923:1997 Code of Hollow steel sections for structural use Specification. Second revision.

  13. IS 456: 2000 Plain and Reinforced Concrete Code of Practice.

  14. EC4-1994 Eurocode 4-1994 Design of composite steel and concrete structures, part 1.1: general rules for buildings.

  15. AIJ-1997 Architectural Institute of Japan. Recommendations for design and construction of concrete filled steel tubular structures. October 1997.

  16. BS5400-1979 British Standard Institute: BS5400. Part 5, Concrete and composite bridges, 1979

  17. LRFD-AISC 1999 Load and Resistance Factor Design specification for structural steel buildings. Chicago: American Institute of Steel Construction 1999.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *