✨
Verified Scholarly Platform
Serving Researchers Since 2012

Investment Preferences : A Comparative Study of Mutual Funds and Fixed Deposits

DOI : 10.17577/IJERTCONV14IS110142
Download Full-Text PDF Cite this Publication

Text Only Version

Investment Preferences : A Comparative Study of Mutual Funds and Fixed Deposits

Mr. Sharath

Assistant Professor, Department of Management Shreyas M.

BBA, 5th Semester

Research Paper

This paper examines individual investment preferences between mutual funds and fixed deposits, with particular attention to risk tolerance, financial goals, perceived stability, return orientation and demographic considerations. The empirical component is based on the 152-response survey reported in the authors' original draft.

Abstract

Investment decisions increasingly require individuals to balance capital safety, liquidity, return potential and tolerance for uncertainty. Mutual funds and fixed deposits represent two contrasting investment avenues: mutual funds are market-linked and diversified, while fixed deposits are generally perceived as more stable and predictable. This study investigates the investment preferences of individuals between these two avenues and examines the relationship between risk tolerance and investment preference. A descriptive and analytical research design was adopted using primary data from 152 respondents collected through a structured questionnaire and convenience sampling. The analysis reported in the study includes percentage analysis, correlation, regression, factor analysis and Cronbach's alpha. The descriptive results show that 44.1% of respondents prefer fixed deposits only, 30.9% use both fixed deposits and mutual funds, 23.7% reported neither option, and 1.3% reported mutual funds only. Most respondents (54.6%) reported moderate risk-taking ability. Risk tolerance shows a positive relationship with investment preference (r = 0.262), while the regression model is statistically significant (p = 0.002) and explains 6.9% of the variation in the reported investment-preference measure. The findings indicate that risk tolerance is relevant to investment preference, but the relatively low R2 suggests that other factors also contribute to investment decisions. The study contributes to understanding the coexistence of traditional and market-linked investment choices and highlights the importance of aligning investment decisions with individual goals, risk capacity and financial awareness.

Keywords: Investment preference; Mutual funds; Fixed deposits; Risk tolerance; Investor behaviour; Risk-return trade-off; Financial goals.

  1. Introduction

    Investment is an important component of personal financial planning because individuals must decide how to allocate available savings across alternatives with different levels of risk, return, liquidity and stability. In the Indian context, fixed deposits have traditionally been associated with capital preservation and predictable returns, whereas mutual funds provide professionally managed, diversified exposure to market-linked securities. The choice between these avenues therefore reflects more than a simple comparison of returns; it is also influenced by an investor's financial objectives, risk tolerance, time horizon, liquidity requirements and level of financial awareness.

    The present study focuses on the preference of common investors between mutual funds and fixed deposits. The original study describes these instruments as representing relatively different approaches to wealth creation and capital safety. The research is particularly relevant because the coexistence of

    both instruments allows investors to adopt either a conservative approach, a market-linked approach, or a combination of the two.

    Prior research supports the importance of return, risk and liquidity in investment decisions. Kumar and Elahi's study of investors in Lucknow found return to be a major investment consideration and reported a preference for mutual funds over equity shares among their respondents. cite turn0search0 turn0search2 More recent comparative work has also examined mutual funds and fixed deposits through risk-return measures, while other studies have explored the movement between

    fixed deposits and debt mutual funds. cite turn0search42 turn1search0

  2. Statement of the Problem

    Individuals face a continuing choice between instruments that emphasize stability and instruments that offer market-linked growth potential. Although mutual funds have become an important investment avenue, fixed deposits continue to be used by investors who place greater emphasis on predictability and capital protection. The problem addressed in this study is therefore to identify the investment preference of respondents and determine whether risk tolerance is significantly associated with that preference.

  3. Objectives of the Study

    1. To determine the relationship between investors' financial goals, such as short-term liquidity needs and long-term wealth creation, and their preferred investment avenue.

    2. To identify which investment instrument respondents prefer and the reasons associated with that preference.

    3. To assess how investors perceive the risk-return trade-off between market-linked mutual funds and relatively predictable fixed deposits.

    4. To examine the relationship between risk tolerance and investment preference.

    5. To identify broader factors that may influence investment decisions, including return orientation, safety, liquidity and risk perception.

  4. Research Questions

    1. Which of the two investment avenues is preferred by the respondents?

    2. What level of risk tolerance characterizes the respondent group?

    3. Is risk tolerance significantly related to investment preference?

    4. What investment-related factors emerge as important in the reported factor analysis?

    5. What do the findings imply about the coexistence of fixed deposits and mutual funds in personal investment decisions?

  5. Hypotheses

    H0: There is no significant relationship between risk tolerance and investment preference. H1: There is a significant relationship between risk tolerance and investment preference.

  6. Review of Literature

    Author(s) & Year

    Focus

    Relevant finding / contribution

    Kumar & Elahi (2018)

    Investor preference in Lucknow

    Return was identified as an important investment consideration; the study reported a preference for mutual funds over equity shares and observed differences in risk orientation across age groups.

    cite turn0search1 turn0search2

    Author(s) & Year

    Focus

    Relevant finding / contribution

    Maheswari (2020)

    Performance of selected mutual funds

    Evaluated mutual-fund performance using measures including beta, standard deviation, Sharpe ratio and Treynor's measure, highlighting the importance of risk-adjusted evaluation. cite turn1search5

    Singh & Singh (2025)

    Mutual funds vs fixed deposits

    Compared historical risk-return characteristics for 2019-2024 using CAGR, standard deviation and Sharpe ratio; reported the growth potential of mutual funds alongside the stability of fixed deposits.

    cite turn0search42

    Marvaniya & Kansara (2025)

    FD/RD vs mutual funds

    Examined traditional deposits against mutual-fund routes including lump-sum and SIP investments, focusing on risk-return trade-offs and investor preferences. cite turn1search37

    Paikat (2025)

    Debt mutual funds vs fixed deposits

    Examined factors behind movement from FDs toward debt mutual funds, including liquidity, tax treatment and risk-return considerations, using survey and case-study evidence.

    cite turn1search0 turn1search2

    Literature gap. Existing studies have examined mutual-fund performance, investor preferences and comparisons between market-linked and traditional instruments. However, the present study adds a direct empirical examination of the relationship between reported risk tolerance and investment preference using a 152-respondent survey. It also combines descriptive evidence with correlation, regression, reliability and factor-oriented analysis.

  7. Conceptual Framework

    The study conceptualizes investment preference as the outcome variable and risk tolerance as the principal explanatory variable. Financial goals, return orientation, safety preference, liquidity considerations, risk perception, age and income are treated as contextual factors that may shape investment decisions.

    Independent / explanatory factors

    Decision process

    Outcome

    Risk tolerance

    Risk-return evaluation

    Investment preference

    Financial goals

    Liquidity and time-horizon assessment

    Mutual funds / Fixed deposits / Both / Neither

    Return orientation

    Expected wealth-creation assessment

    Preference intensity

    Safety preference

    Capital-stability assessment

    Preference for relatively stable instruments

    Liquidity considerations

    Access-to-funds assessment

    Instrument selection

    Demographic factors

    Individual financial context

    Investment behaviour

  8. Research Methodology

    1. Research Design

      The study follows a descriptive and analytical research design. The descriptive component summarizes investment preferences and risk-taking ability, while the analytical component examines the relationship between risk tolerance and investment preference.

    2. Data Source and Sample

      The study uses primary data collected through a structured questionnaire. The reported sample consists of 152 respondents selected using convenience sampling from individuals with different demographic backgrounds.

    3. Variables

      Risk tolerance: categorized in the reported data as low, moderate and high. Investment preference: represented through the reported categories of fixed deposits only, both, neither and mutual funds only. The analysis also considers factors such as return orientation, safety, liquidity and risk perception.

    4. Statistical Tools

      Percentage analysis was used for descriptive interpretation. Correlation analysis was used to examine the relationship between risk tolerance and investment preference. Regression analysis was used to estimate the explanatory contribution of risk tolerance. Factor analysis was reported to organize investment-related factors, and Cronbach's alpha was used to assess internal reliability.

      Methodological note: The present manuscript is based on the statistics reported in the supplied draft. The raw respondent-level dataset, questionnaire and full factor-analysis output were not supplied; therefore, the reported statistics have not been independently recomputed. Before journal submission, the authors should verify the statistical output against the original dataset and retain the questionnaire and analysis file as research records.

  9. Data Analysis and Interpretation

    1. Investment Preference

      Investment option

      Frequency

      Percentage

      Fixed deposits only

      67

      44.1%

      Both fixed deposits and mutual funds

      47

      30.9%

      Neither

      36

      23.7%

      Mutual funds only

      2

      1.3%

      Total

      152

      100.0%

      The largest reported group consists of respondents who prefer fixed deposits only (44.1%). A further 30.9% use both fixed deposits and mutual funds. Only 1.3% reported mutual funds alone, while 23.7% reported neither. The distribution therefore indicates that fixed deposits have a substantial role in the respondent group and that a mixed approach is also common.

    2. Risk-Taking Ability

      Risk level

      Frequency

      Percentage

      Moderate

      83

      54.6%

      Low

      55

      36.2%

      High

      14

      9.2%

      Total

      152

      100.0%

      Most respondents (54.6%) report moderate risk-taking ability, followed by 36.2% with low risk tolerance and 9.2% with high risk tolerance. This distribution is consistent with a respondent group in which a cautious or balanced approach to investment risk is common.

    3. Correlation Analysis

      Variables

      Risk tolerance

      Investment preference

      Risk tolerance

      1.000

      0.262

      Investment preference

      0.262

      1.000

      The reported correlation coefficient of r = 0.262 indicates a positive relationship between risk tolerance and investment preference. In substantive terms, respondents with higher reported risk tolerance tend to show greater movement toward market-linked investment preference. The magnitude is modest, so risk tolerance alone does not explain investment choice.

    4. Regression Analysis

      Model statistic

      Reported value

      R

      0.263

      R2

      0.069

      Adjusted R2

      0.062

      Model statistic

      Reported value

      F

      10.34

      p-value

      0.002

      The reported regression model is statistically significant at the 5% level (p = 0.002). The R2 of 0.069 indicates that risk tolerance accounts for 6.9% of the variation in the reported investment-preference measure. This relatively small explanatory proportion is important: it indicates that investment preference is likely shaped by several additional variables beyond risk tolerance.

    5. Regression Coefficients

      Variable

      Coefficient ()

      t-value

      p-value

      Constant

      0.365

      3.213

      0.002

      Risk tolerance

      0.206

      3.215

      0.002

      The reported coefficient for risk tolerance is positive (W = 0.206) and statistically significant (p = 0.002). Within the reported model, higher risk tolerance is associated with a higher value of the investment-preference measure. The result supports rejection of H0 in favour of H1, subject to verification of the original coding and regression specification.

    6. Factor-Oriented Analysis

      Factor area

      Variables / dimensions reported

      Relative importance in draft

      Risk perception

      Market fluctuations; risk awareness

      High

      Return orientation

      Wealth creation; higher returns

      Very high

      Safety preference

      Stability; liquidity

      Moderate

      The draft identifies return orientation and risk perception as dominant areas influencing investment decisions. Because the supplied manuscript does not contain KMO, Bartlett's test, eigenvalues, communalities or factor loadings, the factor-analysis section is retained as a descriptive factor-oriented summary rather than presented as a fully reproducible exploratory factor analysis.

    7. Reliability Analysis

      Measure

      Value

      Interpretation

      Cronbach's alpha

      0.80

      Indicates good internal consistency for the reported instrument.

      The reported Cronbach's alpha of 0.80 exceeds the commonly used 0.70 benchmark for internal consistency, indicating that the questionnaire items included in the reliability calculation have satisfactory internal consistency. The exact item set used for this calculation should be documented in the final submission.

  10. Discussion

    The empirical evidence presents a nuanced picture of investment preference. Fixed deposits are the single most selected stand-alone option in the reported sample, while nearly one-third of respondents use both fixed deposits and mutual funds. This suggests that investors need not view the two instruments as mutually exclusive. A combination may reflect different financial goals, time horizons and risk capacities.

    The positive correlation and significant regression coefficient indicate that risk tolerance is associated with investment preference. However, the R2 of 6.9% shows that risk tolerance explains only a limited portion of the variation. This is consistent with the broader investment-behaviour literature, where return expectations, liquidity, financial knowledge, tax considerations, family influence, age, income and investment objectives can also shape decisions.

    The findings can be read alongside earlier research without assuming that all samples will produce the same preference. For example, Kumar and Elahi reported mutual-fund preference over equity shares in Lucknow, while Singh and Singh compared mutual funds and fixed deposits from a risk-return perspective. cite turn0search1 turn0search42 Paikat's later study examined movement from fixed deposits toward debt mutual funds and highlighted liquidity and tax-related considerations. cite turn1search0 The differences across studies reinforce the importance of population, instrument

    type, time period and research design when interpreting investment-preference findings.

  11. Key Findings

    1. Among the reported categories, fixed deposits only constitute the largest preference group at 44.1%.

    2. 30.9% of respondents report using both fixed deposits and mutual funds, indicating a meaningful mixed-investment approach.

    3. Only 1.3% report mutual funds as their sole investment preference within the categories measured.

    4. 54.6% of respondents report moderate risk-taking ability, while 36.2% report low and 9.2% high risk tolerance.

    5. Risk tolerance has a positive reported correlation with investment preference (r = 0.262).

    6. The regression model is statistically significant (p = 0.002), with risk tolerance showing a positive coefficient of 0.206.

    7. The R2 of 6.9% indicates that risk tolerance is relevant but is not sufficient to explain investment preference on its own.

    8. Return orientation and risk perception are identified in the draft as important factor areas influencing investment decisions.

    9. The reported Cronbach's alpha of 0.80 indicates good internal consistency for the measured instrument.

  12. Implications of the Study

    1. Implications for Investors

      Investment decisions should be aligned with individual financial goals, liquidity requirements and risk capacity rather than being based solely on general market trends. Investors may benefit from understanding the differences between market-linked and relatively predictable investment avenues before allocating savings.

    2. Implications for Financial Education

      The findings suggest a need for stronger investor education around risk, return, liquidity, diversification and the characteristics of different mutual-fund categories. Financial literacy initiatives can help individuals understand that risk tolerance and financial capacity are not necessarily identical.

    3. Implications for Researchers

      Future studies can extend this work by using larger probability-based samples and by modelling additional explanatory variables such as financial literacy, income, age, investment horizon, tax awareness, liquidity needs and perceived safety.

  13. Suggestions

    1. Investors should improve their understanding of mutual-fund categories and the risk associated with market-linked investments.

    2. Investment choices should be matched to personal financial goals, time horizon and risk-taking capacity.

    3. Investors can evaluate whether a combination of investment avenues is appropriate for their individual objectives.

    4. Financial education programs should emphasize risk-return trade-offs, liquidity and diversification rather than focusing only on expected returns.

    5. Researchers should use validated scales and clearly document questionnaire items and coding procedures in future studies.

  14. Limitations of the Study

    1. The study uses convenience sampling, which limits the generalizability of the results to the wider investor population.

    2. The sample size is 152 respondents; larger samples could provide more stable estimates.

    3. The supplied manuscript does not identiy a specific city, state or sampling frame for the 152 respondents, so the geographical scope should be stated explicitly before publication.

    4. The raw respondent-level dataset was not supplied with the draft; therefore, the reported statistical results were not independently recomputed for this manuscript.

    5. The factor-analysis section does not provide the full statistical diagnostics required for replication.

    6. Investment preference is a self-reported behavioural measure and may be affected by respondent perceptions at the time of the survey.

  15. Scope for Future Research

    Future research can develop a broader model of investment preference by incorporating financial literacy, investment experience, income, age, marital status, investment horizon, liquidity needs, tax awareness, perceived safety, return expectations and social influence. A larger and geographically stratified sample would improve external validity. Structural equation modelling could also be used if a sufficiently large dataset and validated multi-item constructs are available.

  16. Conclusion

    This study examined investment preference between mutual funds and fixed deposits using survey data from 152 respondents. The reported descriptive results show that fixed deposits are the largest stand-alone preference category, while a substantial share of respondents report using both fixed deposits and mutual funds. Risk tolerance is positively associated with investment preference and has a statistically significant coefficient in the reported regression model. At the same time, the modest R2 demonstrates that investment preference is a multidimensional decision that cannot be explained by risk tolerance alone.

    The study therefore supports a broader understanding of investment behaviour in which safety, return orientation, liquidity, financial goals and individual risk capacity interact. The findings should be interpreted within the limitations of the sample and the reported methodology. In particular, the contradiction in the original draft has been resolved in this manuscript by following the actual preference table: 44.1% selected fixed deposits only, compared with 1.3% selecting mutual funds only. Before submission to a journal or conference, the authors should verify the raw dataset, questionnaire, statistical output and geographical sampling details.

  17. References

  1. Kumar, M., & Elahi, Y. A. (2018). Study of Customers' Preference Towards Investment in Mutual Funds and Equity Shares with Special Reference to Lucknow. International Journal of Management Studies, 5(2(7)), 96-103. DOI: 10.18843/ijms/v5i2(7)/12.

    cite turn0search0 turn0search1

  2. Maheswari, Y. (2020). A Comparative Study on Performance of Selected Mutual Funds in India. SSRN Electronic Journal. DOI: 10.2139/ssrn.3615774. cite turn1search5

  3. Singh, A., & Singh, A. (2025). Comparative Analysis of Mutual Funds vs Fixed Deposits: A Risk-Return Perspective. International Journal of Innovative Research in Information Technology (IJIRT), Volume 12, Issue 1. cite turn0search42

  4. Marvaniya, M., & Kansara, H. (2025). A Comprehensive Study on Fixed Deposit (FD) / Recurring Deposit (RD) Vs. Mutual Funds (LUMPSUM/SIP). International Journal of Engineering, Management and Humanities, 6(2), 238-243. cite turn1search37

  5. Paikat, V. G. (2025). Indian Investors Prefer Debt Mutual Funds Over Fixed Deposits? International Journal of Creative Research Thoughts, 13(2), f287-f293. DOI: 10.2139/ssrn.5136163. cite turn1search0 turn1search2

Appendix A: Recommended Pre-Submission Verification

  1. Confirm the exact survey location/geographical scope and data-collection period.

  2. Retain the original questionnaire and respondent-level dataset.

  3. Verify all frequency totals and percentages against the dataset.

  4. Verify the coding of the investment-preference variable used in correlation and regression.

  5. Verify the regression model specification and whether the dependent variable is appropriately treated for the chosen model.

  6. Provide KMO, Bartlett's test, extraction method, rotation method, eigenvalues and factor loadings if formal factor analysis is retained.

  7. Add a complete author affiliation and corresponding-author email as required by the target journal/conference.

  8. Apply the target journal's exact reference style, word limit, page layout and plagiarism/AI-disclosure requirements before submission.