🌏
International Research Press
Serving Researchers Since 2012

Footprint Mapping and Line Loss Analysis of a Mixed-Model Tractor Assembly Line: A Lean Manufacturing Study at Mahindra & Mahindra, Nagpur Plant

DOI : 10.17577/IJERTCONV14IS120018
Download Full-Text PDF Cite this Publication

Text Only Version

Footprint Mapping and Line Loss Analysis of a Mixed-Model Tractor Assembly Line: A Lean Manufacturing Study at Mahindra & Mahindra, Nagpur Plant

Vedant Avinash Dodke MBA, School of Business, Indira University,

Pune, India 411033

Dr. Nitin Joshi

Associate Professor and Area Chair – MBA, School of Business,

Indira University,

Pune, India 411033 nitin.joshi@indirauniversity.edu.in

Mr. Nisar Jamadar

General Manager (Material Logistics) and External Guide, Mahindra & Mahindra Ltd., Farm Equipment Sector, Nagpur, Maharashtra, India

Dr. Sanjay Asati

Assistant Professor – MBA, School of Business, Indira University,

Pune, India 411033 sanjay.asati@indirauniversity.edu.in

Abstract – In the competitive agricultural equipment sector, assembly-line stability depends on synchronized sub- assembly supply, disciplined kitting, and rapid recovery from production interruptions. Contemporary literature positions Lean Manufacturing, Value Stream Mapping (VSM), and Kaizen as foundational approaches for exposing hidden losses and sustaining continuous improvement. This applied industrial study examined the mixed-model tractor assembly operations of Mahindra & Mahindra Ltd., Farm Equipment Sector (FES), Nagpur Plant, covering a Pre-Assembly Line (Stages 122) and a Post-Assembly Line (Stages 5190). The primary objectives were to develop a complete footprint map of the production facility, quantify line losses by department and day, evaluate production performance and manpower availability, identify root causes through cause-and-effect analysis, and design a practical Lean-based aid for material identification. Conducted during an eight-week summer internship, the methodology combined shop-floor observation, discussions with logistics officers, supervisors, and quality managers, and a census analysis of the plants Daily Loss Analysis Register, Daily Production Graph, and Absenteeism Register for April and May 2026.

The plant recorded 909 loss incidents (2,898.5 minutes) in April and 728 incidents (4,352.0 minutes) in May 2026. Transmission sub-assembly supply was the largest source of April downtime (775.0 minutes; 26.7%), while Planned Stoppages, frequently triggered by transmission shortages and NOVO model sequencing, became the largest May category (1,889.0 minutes). Material Logistics generated the most incidents (363 and 248) yet averaged only 1.1 minutes each, and Sheet Metal losses rose by 79% between the two months. Schedule adherence fell from 91.6% to 80.0% and Overall Line Efficiency (OLE) from 92.05% to 70.98%,

with the decline concentrated in the first and second shifts, even as manpower adequacy improved from 85.8% to 92.5%. In conclusion, plant performance is constrained by upstream sub-assembly supply and production synchronisation rather than by workforce availability. A standardised Plant Inventory Bin Sticker (BIN-0042) was designed and piloted. It is recommended that management establish a transmission buffer supermarket, institute daily TransmissionAssembly coordination, stabilise Sheet Metal supply, expand bin stickers and kitting checklists, correct NOVO sequencing, and maintain trained standby operators.

Keywords – Lean Manufacturing, Footprint Mapping, Line Loss Analysis, TIMWOOD Waste Analysis, Tractor Assembly, Overall Line Efficiency (OLE)

  1. INTRODUCTION

    The Indian tractor industry is one of the largest in the world, accounting for roughly one-third of global tractor production and serving as a critical enabler of agricultural mechanisation and rural income growth [1]. Within this market, Mahindra & Mahindra holds a leadership position with an approximate 40% domestic share, built on a broad portfolio that spans compact 15 HP tractors to 75 HP models [2]. Serving such diverse demand requires mixed-model assembly, in which several variants with different transmission, drive, and cabin configurations are sequenced on a single line. Because every station depends on the timely arrival of the correct sub-assemblies and kitted parts, a delay in one area quickly propagates to the entire line, making the elimination of production losses central to maintaining throughput, cost competitiveness, and delivery reliability.

    The Nagpur plant of Mahindra & Mahindras Farm Equipment Sector assembles the Arjun, Yuvostar, NOVO, NST, Garuda, H1, and JIVO series on a common line comprising a

    Pre-Assembly Line (Stages 122, from skid loading to pre-paint masking) and a Post-Assembly Line (Stages 5190, from propeller shaft fitment to Vehicle Testing Unit inspection and roll-out). These lines are supported by kitting zones, storage areas, docking stations, sub-assembly sections, quality offices, and a paint testing line. Despite this structure, the plants Daily Loss Analysis Register shows that disruptions are spread across several departments rather than a single cause: during April 2026 the plant produced 9,841 tractors against a plan of 10,743, and during May 2026 (to 25 May) it produced 7,257 against a plan of 9,072, leaving shortfalls of 902 and 1,815 tractors.

    To address these challenges, this study presents an empirical investigation of line losses at the Nagpur plant using a three- stage approach. First, a footprint map of the entire facility was developed to understand layout, material flow, and the interaction between production areas. Second, the April and May 2026 loss registers, production records, and manpower records were analysed to identify the dominant contributors to loss and their root causes. Third, a Lean-based improvement, a standardised Plant Inventory Bin Sticker, was designed and piloted to reduce kitting-related interruptions. Together, these steps provide a data-driven diagnostic framework and practical, low-cost recommendations to stabilise production and improve Overall Line Efficiency.

  2. LITERATURE REVIEW AND THEORETICAL BACKGROUND

    1. Literature Review

      Womack et al. [3] introduced Lean Production by examining the Toyota Production System, arguing that productivity improves when activities that add no value are systematically removed, while Ohno [4] described the seven wastes and the logic of just-in-time flow on which that system rests. Imai [5] established Kaizen as a philosophy of small, sustained improvements involving employees at every level. Rother and Shook [6] presented Value Stream Mapping as a method for visualising the movement of material and information, and Liker

      [7] distilled the management principles of Toyota, notably continuous process flow to expose problems and pull systems to limit unnecessary inventory. Baudin [8] adapted Lean principles to mixed-model assembly, emphasising organised workstations, point-of-use storage, standardised labelling, and efficient kitting, whereas Monden [9] detailed just-in-time and Kanban-based control, including line-side supermarkets and controlled buffer stocks. Shingo [10] contributed the poka-yoke concept of mistake-proofing, and Ishikawa [11] introduced the cause-and- effect diagram used for structured root-cause analysis. These sources are largely foundational and conceptual; this study applies them jointly, through footprint mapping, register-level loss analysis, and a kitting aid, in a live mixed-model tractor assembly environment.

    2. Theoretical Background

    This study is grounded in Lean Manufacturing, a production philosophy derived from the Toyota Production System (TPS) that prioritises customer value by eliminating operational waste. Only a small fraction of activities on an assembly line add value in the customers eyes, suchas engine mounting, axle fitment, hydraulic integration, tyre fitment, and testing; all other activities, including waiting for sub-assemblies, searching for missing parts, and unplanned stoppages, are non-value-adding. These are classified using the TIMWOOD framework:

    Transport, Inventory, Motion, Waiting, Overproduction, Overprocessing, and Defects [4].

    Footprint mapping complements Value Stream Mapping by focusing on the physical space of the facility, namely the location of stations, storage areas, aisles, and the routes travelled by materials and people. It exposes long travel distances, poorly located storage, and zone conflicts that are invisible in tabular data. Root causes are examined using the Ishikawa (fishbone) diagram organised around the 4M framework (Man, Machine, Material, Method), and continuous improvement follows the Kaizen principle of targeted, low-cost changes implemented at the shop floor.

    Finally, the study draws on material-flow concepts for mixed-model assembly. Kitting delivers every part required for an operation to the station in a single, pre-organised set, and a bin sticker system provides standardised visual identification at each bin or rack. Line-side supermarkets and buffer stocks decouple the main line from fluctuations in upstream sub- assembly supply, and poka-yoke devices and checklists prevent errors at source. Line performance is expressed through Overall Line Efficiency (OLE), computed shift-wise as Actual Production divided by Revised Target.

  3. MATERIALS AND METHODS

    1. Research Objectives

      This study evaluates line losses at the Mahindra & Mahindra Nagpur tractor assembly plant to achieve six core objectives: (1) develop a comprehensive footprint map of the Pre-Assembly (Stages 122) and Post-Assembly (Stages 5190) lines and their supporting zones; (2) conduct an incident-level analysis of the Daily Loss Analysis Register for April and May 2026 by department, category, and day; (3) analyse production performance and manpower availability to corroborate the loss findings; (4) identify root causes of recurring losses through structured cause-and-effect analysis; (5) design and pilot a standardised Plant Inventory Bin Sticker for the kitting process; and (6) formulate practical, Lean-based recommendations to reduce the frequency and severity of line losses.

    2. Research Design and Data Collection

      A mixed-method, observational, plant-based case study was carried out during an eight-week summer internship. Quantitative data were drawn in full (census sampling) from the plant records [12]: the Daily Loss Analysis Register (909 incidents over 24 working days in April 2026 and 728 incidents over 20 reported working days in May 2026), the Daily Production Graph (planned versus actual tractors), the OLE tracking sheet, and the Absenteeism Register (shift-wise availability against basic requirement; 25 days in April and 22 days in May). Qualitative data came from structured shop-floor observation, discussions with Material Logistics officers, assembly supervisors, and quality managers, and from the hands-on development of the footprint map covering all 57 assembly stages. The bin sticker assessment used purposive sampling of 15 active bin records in the Post-Paint Kitting Area.

    3. Analytical Framework and Limitations

    The footprint map was built in Microsoft Excel as a colour- coded, approximately scaled layout. Loss data were analysed using descriptive statistics, frequency analysis, and department- wise and daily trend analysis, after normalising inconsistent department labels in the manually maintained register (for

    example, MAINT and MAINTENANCE). Wastes were classified with the TIMWOOD framework and root causes were analysed with an Ishikawa diagram on the 4M basis. The study has limitations: May data extend only to 25 May; planned stoppages are included in total loss on the plants own reporting convention; the map reflects the layout observed during the internship; and the bin sticker pilot covered a single part number (BIN-0042), so validation across all active SKUs remains for the plant team.

  4. DATA ANALYSIS AND DISCUSSION

    Document the Production Line Through Footprint Mapping

    TABLE I.

    one-wise Footprint Summary of the Nagpur Tractor Assembly Plant

    Zone / Segment

    Footprint Attributes

    Stages

    Primary Material / Sub-assembly

    Source

    Loss Risk

    Pre- Assembly Line

    122 (S1 S19)

    Pre-Paint Kitting Area, HD Racks, Sub-Assembly

    Areas

    Medium

    Post- Assembly Zone A

    5169 (S51 S68)

    Post-Paint Kitting Area, Transmission Shop, Battery and

    Tyre Storage

    High

    Post- Assembly Zone B

    7379 (S73 S78)

    Post-Paint Skid Store, Radiator

    Sub-Assembly, Sheet Metal

    High

    Post-

    Assembly Zone C

    8090

    (S79 S90)

    Floor Storage,

    Direct Delivery, Post-Paint Kitting

    Medium

    Transmission Supply Interface

    5156

    Transmission Shop (upstream in-plant sub-assembly feed)

    Critical

    Post-Paint Kitting Area

    HD Racks, Dock 1, Dock 2, Store

    Critical

    Sheet Metal

    Supply Interface

    59, 74

    76

    Fender, Hood, and

    Bonnet Sub- Assembly Areas

    High

    Storage and Docking Areas

    HD Racks, Dock 1, Dock 2, Floor Storage, Battery

    and Tyre Storage

    Medium

    Quality Offices and Paint Testing

    Line

    Part QA office, Paint Testing Line, Vehicle Testing

    Unit

    Low

    Na l

    Table 1 summarises the footprint map developed for the gpur plant. Built in Microsoft Exce through repeated shop- floor walkthroughs, it covers all 22 Pre-Assembly stages, the 35 manually staffed Post-Assembly stages, and supporting areas including kitting zones, HD Racks, docks, sub-assembly areas, storage zones, and offices. Conveyor-transfer sections were mapped but not treated as manually staffed assembly stages. Overlaying the loss data on the map showed that the interface between the Transmission shop and Stages 5156 is the most loss-prone material path in the plant. The Post-Paint Kitting

    Area, located at some physical distance from several high-loss stations, is the second critical zone, which is consistent with Material Logistics being the most frequent source of incidents.

    Evaluate Production Performance and Overall Line Efficiency

    TABLE II.

    roduction Performance and Shift-wise OLE, April and

    MAY 2026

    Parameter

    April 2026

    May 2026 (to 25th)

    Working days recorded

    24

    Z

    20

    Planned production (tractors)

    10,743

    9,072

    Actual production (tractors)

    9,841

    7,257

    Shortfall against plan (tractors)

    902

    1,815

    Schedule adherence

    91.6%

    80.0%

    Average daily actual (tractors)

    ~410

    ~363

    OLE 1st shift

    94.86%

    69.28%

    OLE 2nd sift

    92.45%

    71.00%

    OLE 3rd shift

    97.75%

    96.57%

    OLE total (all shifts)

    92.05%

    70.98%

    Table 2 shows a clear deterioration in plant performance. Planned daily output was similar in the two months (about 448 454 tractors per day), yet actual output fell from roughly 410 to 363 tractors per day, reducing schedule adherence from 91.6% to 80.0%. As reported on the plants OLE tracking sheet, total OLE fell by 21.1 percentage points, from 92.05% to 70.98%. The collapse was not evenly distributed: the first and second shifts fell by 25.6 and 21.4 points respectively, while the third shift fell by only 1.2 points. Since the first two shifts are most exposed to hand-offs from Transmission and Sheet Metal sub- assembly departments, this shift-wise pattern points to upstream supply, rather than kitting or staffing, as the main driver. Total logged incidents fell from 909 to 728 while loss minutes rose from 2,898.5 to 4,352.0, so the average severity per incident increased markedly.

    Quantify Department-wise Line Losses

    TABLE III.

    epartment-wise Line Loss, April 2026 (909 Incidents)

    Department

    Loss (min)

    Incidents

    Avg.

    min / incident

    Share of loss

    Transmission

    775.0

    112

    6.9

    26.7%

    Planned Stoppage

    619.5

    8

    77.4

    21.4%

    Material Logistics

    (ML)

    415.0

    363

    1.1

    14.3%

    Sheet Metal (SM)

    294.0

    86

    3.4

    10.1%

    Department

    Loss (min)

    Incidents

    Avg. min /

    incident

    Share of loss

    Production

    Planning (PPC)

    242.0

    4

    60.5

    8.3%

    MFG-ABS

    (Absenteeism)

    155.5

    5

    31.1

    5.4%

    MFG

    101.5

    24

    4.2

    3.5%

    Part QA

    61.0

    134

    0.5

    2.1%

    Total (incl.

    other departments*)

    2,898.5

    909

    3.2

    100%

    a. *Other departments (MES, Maintenance, Process, Engine, etc.) account for the balance of the register: 235.0 minutes

    across 173 incidents.

    absorbing them as unplanned loss. Sheet Metal losses rose from

    294.0 to 525.5 minutes (+79%) and from 86 to 131 incidents (+52%), signalling a parallel deterioration in fender, hood, and bonnet supply.

    Identify the Highest-Impact Loss Incidents

    TABLE V.

    en Highest-Impact Single Incidents, April and May 2026

    Date (Shift)

    Department

    Min.

    Incident description

    01-Apr (S3)

    Planned Stoppage

    340

    Planned loss

    12-May (S2)

    Planned Stoppage

    198

    Transmission shortage

    11-May (S3)

    Planned Stoppage

    178

    Planned loss

    09-May (S3)

    Planned Stoppage

    162.5

    D

    Planned loss

    22-May (S1)

    Transmission

    150

    Transmission shortage

    13-May (S3)

    Planned Stoppage

    137

    Plan completed

    15-Apr (S3)

    MFG-ABS

    105

    Absenteeism; line speed reduced to 80 vehicles per shift

    24-Apr (S3)

    Transmission

    100

    Line stopped due to transmission shortage

    18-Apr (S3)

    Transmission

    98

    Line stopped due to transmission shortage

    30-Apr (S3)

    PPC

    98

    Line stopped as NOVO came early at post-painting

    TABLE IV.

    Department

    Loss (min)

    Incidents

    Avg. min / incident

    Share of loss

    Planned Stoppage

    1,889.0

    19

    99.4

    43.4%

    Transmission (combined)

    1,284.5

    105

    12.2

    29.5%

    Sheet Metal (SM)

    525.5

    131

    4.0

    12.1%

    Material

    Logistics (ML)

    272.5

    248

    1.1

    6.3%

    Production

    Planning (PPC)

    203.0

    4

    50.8

    4.7%

    Part QA

    43.5

    109

    0.4

    1.0%

    MFG

    40.5

    10

    4.1

    0.9%

    Maintenance (MAINT)

    34.5

    27

    1.3

    0.8%

    Total (incl. other departments*)

    4,352.0

    728

    6.0

    100%

    epartment-wise Line Loss, May 2026 (728 Incidents)

    b. *Other departments (MFG-ABS/IT, Engine, Admin, Maintenance, etc.) account for the balance of the register:

    59.0 minutes. Tables 3 and 4 reveal two distinct loss profiles. Transmission was the largest April contributor (775.0 minutes, 26.7%) despite

    only 112 incidents, because each stoppage was severe: representative entries include transmission shortages of 100 minutes on 24 April and 98 minutes on 18 April. Material Logistics, by contrast, logged the most incidents (363) but averaged just 1.1 minutes each, the classic many small cuts pattern of missing kitted parts, wrong-model parts, and absenteeism-related trolley delays. In May, Planned Stoppage surged to 1,889.0 minutes across only 19 incidents (99.4 minutes on average), and several of its largest entries, such as 198 minutes on 12 May, were explicitly caused by transmission shortages. This suggests that the plant had begun scheduling downtime around known transmission shortfalls instead of

    Table 5 confirms that the most damaging events are large, infrequent stoppages tied to Planned Stoppage and Transmission shortage, not the high-frequency kitting incidents that dominate the Material Logistics count. The 340-minute planned loss on 1 April, covering nearly a full shift, is the single largest event in either month. Daily totals reinforce the pattern: from 7 to 13 May, daily losses ranged from 326.0 to 458.5 minutes, more than double the typical April level, and this sustained multi-day severity is consistent with a systemic transmission and sheet- metal supply problem rather than isolated disturbances.

    Classify Wastes Using the TIMWOOD Framework

    TABLE VI.

    IMWOOD Operational Waste Classification and Shop- Floor Evidence

    TIMWOO

    D Waste

    Waste Classification

    Observed Manifestatio n

    Plant Evidence

    (AprilMay 2026)

    Process Location Affected

    Transport

    Transmission sub- assemblies and kitted

    parts travel

    from the Transmission shop and HD Racks to line-

    side

    775.0 min Transmissio n loss in April

    Transmissio n shop to Stages 51

    56; HD

    Racks

    Inventory

    Fender and

    hood sub- assembly WIP

    imbalance

    Sheet Metal loss rose from 294.0

    to 525.5 min

    Fender, hood and bonnet sub- assembly

    areas

    Motion

    Kitters and operators travel to fetch

    missing parts

    363 ML

    incidents (April); 248 (May)

    Post-Paint Kitting Area; line-

    side stations

    Waiting

    Line idle awaiting transmission and other sub-

    assemblies

    Single stoppages of 100 min (24 Apr) and 198 min (12

    May)

    Stages 51

    90 (Post- Assembly Line)

    Over- production

    NOVO units arriving early at the paint shop disrupt

    sequencing

    PPC loss of

    242.0 min (April) and

    203.0 min (May)

    Paint shop to post- painting hand-off

    Over- processing

    Re- verification and rework cycles for

    fitment and dimensional

    issues

    Documented in Part QA incident logs

    Fitment and dimensional re- verification

    Defects

    Errors and rejections requiring correction at incoming

    checks

    Part QA: 134

    incidents (April); 109 (May)

    Incoming and in-

    process checks

    Table 6 shows that all seven wastes are observable at the plant, but Waiting and Transport dominate in minutes, while Motion dominates in frequency. Waiting for transmission sub- assemblies is the most costly form of non-value-adding time, because the entire line stops. Motion waste appears as many short interruptions in which kitters leave their tasks to search for parts. The NOVO sequencing issue illustrates how flow imbalance in one area, the paint shop, transfers waste to downstream assembly.

    Assess Manpower Availability and Absenteeism

    TABLE VII.

    anpower Availability Against Requirement, April and

    MAY 2026

    Parameter

    April 2026

    May 2026

    Days recorded

    25

    22

    Basic requirement (man-shifts)

    18,167

    14,872

    Total available (man- shifts)

    15,592

    13,755

    Total shortfall (man- shifts)

    2,575

    1,117

    Average daily shortfall

    103.0

    50.8

    Staffing adequacy ratio

    85.8%

    92.5%

    Worst single day

    28-Apr (739)

    26-May (662)

    Table 7 yields a counter-intuitive result: staffing adequacy improved from 85.8% to 92.5% while line losses and the production shortfall worsened. Absenteeism is a real problem and was the proximate cause of the 155.5-minute MFG-ABS loss in April, and the worst gap days (28 April and 26 May) warrant management attention, particularly since 27 and 30 April were among the highest-loss days of the month (324.0 and 356.0 minutes). However, absenteeism is a secondary contributor; the April-to-May decline is explained mainly by Transmission, Planned Stoppage, and Sheet Metal losses, which are largely independent of line-side manpower.

    Diagnose Root Causes Using Cause-and-Effect Analysis

    TABLE VIII.

    ause-and-Effect Matrix (4M Framework) for

    4M

    Root-Cause Analysis

    Root Cause Identified

    Supporting Evidence

    Man

    Kitting trolleys not fully loaded before shift start

    363 ML incidents

    (April); 248 (May)

    Man

    Absenteeism reduces line speed and delays trolley feeding

    15-Apr: 105 min;

    gaps of 739 (28-

    Apr) and 662 (26- May)

    Machine

    Transmission sub- assembly line cannot

    match main-line takt time

    112 incidents / 775.0 min (April); 105 / 1,284.5 min (May)

    Machine

    MES and process equipment delays

    MES 41.0 min;

    Process 20.5 min (April)

    Material

    Sheet Metal sub- assembly supply

    shortfall, worsening month on month

    294.0 to 525.5 min

    (+79%)

    Material

    Transmission components not

    available in sequence

    24-Apr: 100 min; 22-

    May: 150 min

    Material

    No standard bin label for most SKUs

    Observed during

    mapping and kitting assessment

    Recurring Line Losses PART-1

    4M

    Root-Cause Analysis

    Root Cause Identified

    Supporting Evidence

    Method

    NOVO early arrival disrupts downstream

    sequencing

    PPC loss 242.0 min (April); 203.0 min

    (May)

    Method

    No formal kitting- trolley checklist or

    standard work sheet

    ML incident descriptions recur

    across both months

    Method

    Transmission shortages handled as Planned Stoppage, not resolved

    at source

    12-May: 198 min planned stoppage

    TABLE IX.

    ause-and-Effect Matrix (4M Framework) for

    Recurring Line Losses PART-2

    4M

    Root-Cause Analysis

    Operational Impact

    Recommended Countermeasure

    Man

    Kitting delays; missing parts at station

    Pre-shift trolley loading check and

    sign-off

    Man

    Reduced line speed; trolley feeding gaps

    Trained standby operator pool

    Machine

    Repeated line

    stoppages awaiting transmissions

    Transmission buffer supermarket (one shift)

    Machine

    Short stoppages

    awaiting system or process input

    Preventive

    maintenance and MES response review

    Material

    Fender, hood and bonnet shortages at

    stations

    Sheet Metal root- cause study and small

    buffer

    Material

    Stoppages of 100198 min; planned loss

    Daily Transmission Assembly

    coordination

    Material

    Search time and wrong-part picking

    Plant Inventory Bin Sticker for all SKUs

    Method

    Early arrival forces re- sequencing downstream

    Align Paint Shop and PPC sequencing

    Method

    Inconsistent kitting quality across shifts

    Standard kitting checklist per trolley type

    Method

    Shortage hidden inside planned loss figures

    Log shortages as loss at source, not as planned stoppage

    Table 8 (Parts 1 and 2) points to three interconnected root causes. First, the in-plant Transmission sub-assembly supply cannot consistently match the takt time of the main line. Second, Sheet Metal spply is deteriorating. Third, Material Logistics and kitting remain a chronic source of small losses that erode efficiency. A supplementary plant log reinforces the picture: scanning delay at the newly introduced LH/RH scuttle sticker poka-yoke station recurred at least ten times with the same stated cause and was resolved each time by operator counselling. This is a symptom-level response to a system-level problem, which a Kaizen-based standard work review is designed to correct.

    Design and Pilot a Lean Improvement: The Plant Inventory Bin Sticker

    TABLE X.

    esign Fields of the Plant Inventory Bin Sticker (Pilot: BIN-0042)

    Field

    Purpose for Kitters and Operators

    Bin Number (BIN-0042)

    Unique identifier for tracking and audit; easy reference in loss reports

    Feeding

    Frequency (2× per shift)

    Tells the kitter how often to replenish; shown prominently on the left panel

    Part Number (007543855C91)

    SAP part number for procurement reference and barcode scanning

    Description (Knob Hand

    Accelerator)

    Human-Creadable name for instant identification at line-side

    Model Number

    Links the part to a tractor variant; critical for mixed-model management

    Store Location (RACK-A / ROW-3)

    Exact source location for fast, accurate picking

    Daily Requirement (48 pcs)

    Total daily quantity across shifts to support the production plan

    Table 9 lists the fields of the bin sticker, which was designed in direct response to the high frequency of Material Logistics incidents. The existing kitting area relied on informal labels and on kitter experience, a weakness whenever replacement kitters are deployed during absenteeism. The template was developed in four steps: identifying required fields with ML officers and kitters, placing the most referenced fields prominently, adopting the gold and yellow colour convention of plant visual management, and piloting with BIN-0042. During the pilot, kitters and operators identified the correct part and its replenishment requirement without supervisor help, and the store location was judged the most time-saving field. Even a modest reduction in per-incident occurrence would yield a meaningful cumulative gain in line continuity.

    Recommend Feasible Lean Improvement Initiatives

    TABLE XI.

    rioritised Lean Interventions and Projected Business Impact PART-1

    Priority Bottleneck (Lean Waste)

    Proposed Improvement

    Intervention

    Expected Effect

    Transmission- driven stoppages (Waiting / Transport)

    Transmission buffer supermarket between the Transmission shop and Stages 51 56, sized for one full

    shift

    Line keeps running during transmission- shop delays

    Late detection of shortages (Waiting)

    Daily Transmission Assembly meeting reviewing the next 2448 hours against

    availability

    Early warning before a stoppage occurs

    Priority

    Bottleneck (Lean Waste)

    Proposed Improvement

    Intervention

    Expected Effect

    Rising Sheet

    Metal losses

    (Inventory / Waiting)

    Root-cause study; better planning,

    tighter inventory control, small buffer

    Stable fender, hood, and bonnet supply

    Frequent ML incidents (Motion

    / Defects)

    Extend bin stickers to all active parts, worst- affected first

    Faster identification,

    less search time

    Missing or wrong kitted parts (Defects)

    Checklist per trolley type with sign-off and supervisor spot-

    checks

    Fewer material- related

    stoppages

    NOVO

    sequencing (Overproduction)

    Align Paint Shop and PPC sequencing to

    the assembly plan

    Fewer planned

    stoppages

    Absenteeism spikes (Waiting)

    Trained standby pool activated above an absenteeism

    threshold

    Flexibility without permanent

    headcount

    TABLE XII.

    rioritised Lean Interventions and Projected Business Impact PART-2

    Priority Bottleneck

    Implementation Plan

    Proposed Owner

    Timeline

    KPI to Track

    Transmission

    -driven stoppages

    Plant Head;

    Transmissio n Shop

    Short term (48

    weeks)

    Transmissio

    n loss min / month

    Late detection of shortages

    Transmissio n and

    Assembly Managers

    Immediat e (12

    weeks)

    Shortage alerts raised vs. stoppages

    Rising Sheet Metal losses

    Sheet Metal Manager;

    Quality

    Medium term (23

    months)

    Sheet Metal loss min /

    month

    Frequent ML incidents

    Material

    Logistics Officer

    Short term (48

    weeks)

    ML incidents per day

    Missing or

    wrong kitted parts

    Production Supervisors

    Immediat e (12

    weeks)

    Kitting

    incidents per shift

    NOVO

    sequencing

    Paint Shop; PPC

    Medium

    term (23 months)

    PPC loss min

    / month

    Absenteeism spikes

    HR;

    Production Supervisors

    Medium term (23 months)

    Stoppage min due to absenteeism

    Tables 10 and 11 outline a low-capital improvement roadmap arranged by expected impact. The transmission buffer and the daily coordination meeting address the largest source of lost minutes, and together convert shortages from surprises into planned events. Stabilising Sheet Metal supply addresses the fastest-growing loss category. Expanding the bin sticker system and introducing kitting checklists target the high-frequency Material Logistics incidents, in keeping with the Kaizen preference for small, practical shop-floor changes. Correcting

    NOVO sequencing and building a standby workforce protect the line against planning and staffing disturbances. Because these measures rely on organisation, signage, and coordination rather than major capital, they can be phased in quickly.

  5. FINDINGS, CONCLUSIONS AND SUGGESTIONS

  1. Findings

    The empirical investigation at the Mahindra & Mahindra Nagpur plant produced the following findings. A complete footprint map covering 22 Pre-Assembly and 35 Post-Assembly stages and all supporting zones was developed, the first structured visual layout of the plant. Transmission sub- assembly supply was the largest source of production loss:

    775.0 minutes across 112 incidents in April (26.7% of total loss) and 1,284.5 minutes across 105 incidents in May, with severe single events of 100, 150, and 198 minutes. Schedule adherence fell from 91.6% to 80.0%, with shortfalls of 902 and 1,815 tractors, and OLE fell from 92.05% to 70.98%, concentrated in the first shift (94.86% to 69.28%) and second shift (92.45% to 71.00%), while the third shift remained stable. Material Logistics recorded the most incidents (363 and 248) but averaged only 1.1 minuteseach, indicating repeated small disruptions from missing parts, incorrect kitting, and poor material identification. Sheet MPetal losses rose 79% in minutes and 52% in incidents, and Planned Stoppages grew from 619.5 minutes across 8 incidents to 1,889.0 minutes across 19, often to manage known transmission shortages. Manpower adequacy improved from 85.8% to 92.5% while performance declined, so absenteeism was not the principal cause. Finally, the pilot Plant Inventory Bin Sticker (BIN-0042) allowed kitters to identify parts and replenishment needs without supervisor assistance.

  2. Conclusions

    This study achieved all of its stated objectives. A footprint map, a department-wise analysis of 909 April and 728 May 2026 incidents, a production and manpower assessment, a 4M root- cause analysis, and a piloted bin sticker together give a coherent picture of line losses at the Nagpur plant. The analysis confirms that overall performance is constrained by upstream sub- assembly supply and production synchronisation rather than by line-side manpower or machine capability. Material Logistics creates the most frequent interruptions, but Transmission produces the longest, and, together with the Planned Stoppages it triggers, the most consequential ones. Sheet Metal is an emerging concern. By deploying low-cost Lean interventions, namely a transmission buffer, daily coordination, standardised bin stickers, kitting checklists, corrected NOVO sequencing, and standby operators, the plant can reduce the frequency and severity of losses, improve schedule adherence and OLE, and build a foundation for continuous improvement.

  3. Suggestions

    To achieve tangible improvement across all stakeholders, the plant should execute a phased, collaborative roadmap:

    For Plant Management & Planning: Establish a transmission buffer supermarket sized for at least one full shift between the Transmission shop and Stages 5156, and correct NOVO sequencing between the Paint Shop and Production Planning and Control so that vehicles arrive in the order required by the assembly plan.

    For Transmission and Sheet Metal Departments: Hold a daily meeting with the assembly line scheduling team to compare the next 2448 hours of the plan with sub-assembly availability, and conduct a root-cause study of Sheet Metal interruptions to stabilise fender, hood, and bonnet supply.

    For Material Logistics & Kitting Teams: Expand the bin sticker system to all active parts, starting with the most problematic, and introduce a standard checklist for each kitting- trolley type, signed by the kitter and spot-checked by supervisors at the start of each shift.

    For HR & Production Supervisors: Train a small standby group of operators who can be deployed whenever absenteeism crosses a defined limit, avoiding any permanent increase in headcount.

  4. Implications of the study

    The implications of this study provide strategic and operational benefits across all primary stakeholders:

    • Plant Management: Stabilising sub-assembly supply and reducing planned stoppages protects throughput, improves schedule adherence, and limits the loss of manufacturing capacity that cannot be recovered within the same production cycle.

    • Shop-Floor Operators & Kitters: Standard bin stickers and checklists remove dependence on memory and experience, shorten search time, and make the work easier for new or replacement personnel.

    • Planning & Quality Teams: Register-level data and the 4M matrix give a factual basis for sequencing decisions and for tracking whether corrective actions reduce recurring losses.

    • Upstream Departments: Early visibility of demand against availability enables the Transmission and Sheet Metal departments to plan their output to the pace of the main line.

  5. Future Scope of the study

The footprint map and loss baseline established in this research open several avenues for future inquiry:

Simulation of Buffer Sizing: Discrete-event simulation can evaluate transmission buffer size, line pacing, and recovery behaviour under varying upstream disruption before physical implementation.

Digital Loss Capture: Replacing the manually maintained register with MES-integrated, real-time loss logging and Andon alerts would remove naming inconsistencies and shorten response times.

Cost-Benefit Evaluation: A detailed financial model of lost tractors, buffer inventory cost, and improvement investment would quantify the return on the proposed interventions.

Wider Validation: Extending the footprint map with travel- distance (spaghetti) analysis, covering complete-month and multi-season data, and validating the bin sticker across all active SKUs would strengthen the generalisability of the findings.

ACKNOWLEDGMENT

I express my sincere gratitude to Dr. Nitin Joshi, Learning Facilitator (Operations and Supply Chain Management), for his valuable guidance and constant encouragement, and to Mr. Nisar Jamadar, External Guide and General Manager, and Ms. Muskan Ali, Senior Executive, at Mahindra & Mahindra Ltd., Farm Equipment Sector, Nagpur Plant, for their esteemed suggestions and operational support throughout this summer internship project. I am also thankful to all those who, directly or indirectly, helped in completing this research study.

REFERENCES

  1. Society of Indian Automobile Manufacturers, Tractor industry statistics 2024-25, SIAM, New Delhi, India, 2025. [Online]. Available: https://www.siam.in

  2. Mahindra & Mahindra Ltd., Annual report 202324, Mumbai, India, 2024. [Online]. Available: https://www.mahindra.com/investor-relations

  3. J. P. Womack, D. T. Jones, and D. Roos, The Machine That Changed the World: The Story of Lean Production. New York, NY, USA: Rawson Associates, 1990.

  4. T. Ohno, Toyota Production System: Beyond Large-Scale Production. Cambridge, MA, USA: Productivity Press, 1988.

  5. M. Imai, Kaizen: The Key to Japans Competitive Success. New York, NY, USA: McGraw-Hill, 1986.

  6. M. Rother and J. Shook, Learning to See: Value Stream Mapping to Add Value and Eliminate Muda. Cambridge, MA, USA: Lean Enterprise Inst., 1998.

  7. J. K. Liker, The Toyota Way: 14 Management Principles from the Worlds Greatest Manufacturer. New York, NY, USA: McGraw-Hill, 2004.

  8. M. Baudin, Lean Assembly: The Nuts and Bolts of Making Assembly Operations Flow. New York, NY, USA: Productivity Press, 2002.

  9. Y. Monden, Toyota Production System: An Integrated Approach to Just-In-Time, 4th ed. Boca Raton, FL, USA: CRC Press, 2012.

  10. S. Shingo, Zero Quality Control: Source Inspection and the Poka-Yoke System. Cambridge, MA, USA: Productivity Press, 1986.

  11. K. Ishikawa, Guide to Quality Control. Tokyo, Japan: Asian Productivity Organization, 1976.

  12. Mahindra & Mahindra Ltd., Farm Equipment Sector, Nagpur Plant, Daily loss analysis register, daily production graph, and absenteeism register, AprilMay 2026, unpublished internal records, 2026.