DOI : 10.17577/IJERTCONV14IS120017- Open Access

- Authors : Ved Bhalerao, Dr. Nitin Joshi, Dr. Hetal Bhinde
- Paper ID : IJERTCONV14IS120017
- Volume & Issue : Volume 14, Issue 12, UCBO – 2026
- Published (First Online) : 21-11-2026
- ISSN (Online) : 2278-0181
- Publisher Name : IJERT
- License:
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License
Value Stream Mapping and Waste Reduction Study of Pressure Cooker Body Manufacturing Across Aluminium, Stainless Steel, and Tri-Ply Lines
Ved Bhalerao
MBA, School of Business, Indira University,
Pune, India 411033 vedbhalerao237@gmail.com
Dr. Nitin Joshi
Associate Professor and Area Chair – MBA, School of Business,
Indira University,
Pune, India 411033 nitin.joshi@indirauniversity.edu.in
Dr. Hetal Bhinde
Associate Dean Ph.D. Programs, School of Business, Indira University,
Pune, India-411033 hetalb19@gmail.com
ORCID: https://orcid.org/0000-0002- 6435-5113
Abstract – In this competitive household equipment manufacturing sector, to have a good manufacturing excellent product it depends on eliminating waste, material streamlined flow, and strong delivery of quality. From decades of literature underscores Lean Manufacturing and Value Stream Mapping (VSM) as foundations of understanding and analyzing bottlenecks on shop-floor, improving throughput time, and driving methodological continuous improvement. This industrial study investigates the cooker-body manufacturing operations at ABC Cookers Limited across three primary product streams: ANODISED COOKERS Aluminum, Stainless Steel, and Tri-Ply. The primary objectives were to document upstream to downstream manufacturing workflows through VSM, segregate and analyze wastes using the TIMWOODS framework, evaluate material and information flows along with traceability which is QR based, diagnose quality rejections and process bottlenecks, and propose low-cost, practical and low-capital improvement solutions. Executed over an eight-week period from 15 June 2026 to 15 August 2026, the study methodology combined extensive operator interactions, Gemba walk, recording of cycle time, ERP transaction audits, and quality benchmarking against IS 2500 Part 1 acceptance sampling standards.
Investigation revealed that Non-value-added activities were predominate in logistics and administrative areas, with significant divergences around all product lines. The Tri-Ply line had transportation waste due to outsourcing from vendors located around 1,300 km away, whereas the ANODISED COOKERS and Stainless Steel lines experienced multi-processes and hoping, subcontract finishing delays. Across all lines, operations were carried by single-forklift unloading dependencies, paper-intensive four-copy challans for delievery, and untracked in process trolleys. Furthermore, In-house press operations contributed 3-4% out of a 5-6% combined plant rejection rate, high-volume circles lacked QR traceability which were not integrated to ERP. In conclusion plant productivity is
lacking because of space constraints, lack of material handling solution and loads of manual work .
To cut down lead times and tighten floor-level oversight, operations should prioritize several quick, cost-effective digital upgrades:
-
Automate Dispatch Paperwork: Link the ERP directly via API to generate digital delivery challans and e-way bills automatically, cutting manual administrative bottlenecks.
-
Instant First-Off Escalation: Set up digital Andon notifications to immediately alert supervisors when initial sample approvals stall, preventing line idling.
-
Mobile-Based Quality Audits: Move IS 2500 sampling protocols onto floor tablets or handhelds so inspectors log acceptance runs straight into the central database.
-
Traceable Packaging Assets: Tag heavy circles and returnable transport crates with scannable QR codes, establishing a closed-loop system that tracks transit cycles and eliminates missing inventory.
Targeting these high-friction handoffs with off-the-shelf digital tools delivers measurable inventory turnaround and process traceability without committing to a heavy, high- capex overhaul.
Keywords – Value Stream Mapping (VSM), Lean Manufacturing, TIMWOODS Waste Analysis, Pressure Cooker Manufacturing, QR Traceability
-
INTRODUCTION
This manufacturing landscape is defined by rapid shifts in technology, volatile costs of raw-materials, and intense competition across globe. To have an edge, house-hold equipment manufacturing organizations must aggressively pursue operational excellency, optimization of processes, and
implementation of lean manufacturing. Pressure cooker manufacturing has a complex, multi-stage production system that integrates précised metal formingsuch as deep drawing, spinning, trimming, and lippingwith specialized subcontracted metal surface finishing, direct material component assembly, rigorous safety and quality testing, and multi-tier logistics. Because each operation compounds to overall cycle times and directly dictates consumer safety, eliminating non-value-added activities across the production lifecycle has become vital to have a long-term sustenance, reduce operational overhead, and preserve rigorous and must needed quality standards.
Within the Indian cookers sector, ABC Cookers Limited represents an established benchmarking of product integrity, brand equity, and strict protocols of manufacturing. However, even within highly governed manufacturing atmosphere, operational friction and obstacles often emerge across informational and physical workflows. At the shop-floor, distinct multi-material product linesprincipally Aluminium (ANODISED COOKERS), Stainless Steel, and Tri-Ply variantsexperience various operational bottlenecks. This includes uncontrolled material handling, accumulation of excessive inventory , documentation which is paper-intensive, and uneven inspection quality frequencies. Furthermore, distinguished surface treatment subcontracting and the uneven adoption of direct material QR traceability create prominent visibility gaps between final dispatch, material dispatch and raw- material receiving.
To address these challenges, this study presents an in-depth investigation into the cooker-body manufacturing value streams across ABC Cookers Limiteds primary product lines. Utilizing Value Stream Mapping (VSM) as the core investigating methodology, the research systematically tracks start to end information and material flows, separates value-added processes from the classic TIMWOODS wastes, and quality assurance audits checkpoints against standardized sampling frameworks. By alternating the workflow configurations, handling constraints, and cycle times of aluminium, stainless steel, and composite tri-ply bodies, this paper establishes a data-driven diagnosis. Ultimately, it provides actionable, practical, low-cost lean solutions and digital tracking enhancements designed to shorten production lead times, streamline plant logistics, and reinforce control on shop-floor operations.
-
LITERATURE REVIEW AND THEORITICAL BACKGROUND
-
Literature Review
Infanteri (2018) analyses lean waste reduction in an aluminium cookware SME WIP, defects, motion, inventory, VSM, 5S, and Six Sigma. D. S. (2025) researched 5S, JIT, Kanban, and Kaizen in an Indian kitchen appliances manufacturer. Kaneku-Orbegozo et al. (2019) conducted a kitchen equipment production analysis, pointing out the presence of cutting and bending wastes, and achieving 13% cost savings; the second indexed record refers to the same study. Luan et al. (2021) assessed polishing tools for the improvement of aluminium cookware surface; Ealias et al. (2025) specified quality attributes of aluminium pots. Abdennadher et al. (2024) investigated coated-aluminium deep drawin and formability. Salsabila and Rochmoeljati (2021) and Arnando (2015) addressed lean waste reduction and quality improvement in stainless-steel processing. Karim et al. (2012) studied VSM in
metal stamping, and Damsiar and Tjprc (2020) combined work study with lean methods in a metal-press line. Nivya (2016) examined forging VSM, while Murugananthan et al. (2014) mapped foundry flow. The research by Ravichandran (2015) optimized value ratio in pressure vessel forming process. VSM application in pumps manufacturing was reported by Dighe & Kakirde (2014). Jaiswal & Soni (2017) discussed VSM in small scale industries. The study in steel industry conducted in 2020 was based on non-value added activities. Inventory and delay management were the focus of the study carried out by Dewa & Lusiba (2018).
-
Theoritical Background
The research is rooted in Lean Manufacturing a production system approach based on Toyota Production System (TPS). Its key feature is the emphasis on creating customer value via eliminating all kinds of non-value adding activities. The analytical basis is made by Value Stream Mapping (VSM) visualization of material and informational flows from receipt to shipment. This process cycle times, changeovers and materials buffers distinguishing necessary transformations from operational inefficiency.
Operational inefficiency in manufacturing lines is analysed according to the framework of the types of waste called TIMWOODS (Transportation, Inventory, Motion, Waiting, Overproduction, Overprocessing, Defects, and Underutilized Skills). Thus, transportation inefficiency is associated with delays, such as forklift dependence, manual transportation, unnecessary QR codes and excessive paperwork. Continuous improvements follow the scheme of the Plan-Do-Check-Act (PDCA) cycle and Kaizen approach, including low cost incremental shop floor improvements. In addition to this, workplace management issues are analysed using 5S (Sort, Set in Order, Shine, Standardize, and Sustain) method in order to deal with poor allocation and storage of subcontracted parts. Diagnostic tools, such as 5-Why technique and Ishikawa (Fishbone) analysis help to identify the root causes behind observed process inefficiencies.
Lastly, the research combines Quality Management and the idea of a digital supply chain. The evaluation of process capability and quality management occurs using the acceptance sampling criterion (IS 2500 Part 1). The concept is further strengthened using ideas surrounding digital traceability, where the use of QR codes in minimizing errors associated with manual data logging and enhancing material visibility within the production process cycle is evaluated.
-
-
MATERIALS AND METHODS
-
Research Objectives
This study evaluates cooker-body manufacturing across ABC Cookers Limiteds primary material lines to achieve five core objectives:
-
Using Value Stream Mapping (VSM document the start- to-end manufacturing process from raw material receiving to final dispatch of product
-
Identify value-added and non-value-added activities while classifying wastes using Lean Methodology (TIMWOODS)
-
Analyse material, information flows, quality inspection processes, and QR-based traceability at all manufacturing stages
-
Evaluate process bottlenecks, delays, quality issues, and operational challenges affecting efficiency
-
Formulate feasible process improvement solutions aimed at enhancing throughput, eliminating waste, standardize quality, and strengthen overall performance of operations.
-
-
Research Design and Data Collection
The application of the industrial case study was performed by conducting this on the shop floor for a duration of eight weeks between 15 June 2026 and 15 August 2026. Primary data collection was done via the performance of the Gemba walk, process tracking, time studies involving the use of calibrated stopwatches to measure the cycles of operations, and semi- structured interviews with line operators, supervisors, and process engineers. The secondary data were collected from plant layouts, standard operating procedures, ERP transaction history, QR-Goods Receipt Record (GRR), and quality control logbooks. The study traced the full product transformation process from the receipt of raw materials, store staging, press shop processing (forming, deep drawing, trimming, spinning, lipping, and laser cutting), subcontracted finishing (buffing, anodizing, and sunray), incoming inspection, assembly, pressure testing, and dispatch packing.
-
Analytical Framework and Quality Evaluation
Value Stream Maps for the current state were developed for the ANODISED COOKERS Aluminium, Stainless Steel, and Tri-Ply product lines, which helped to identify the movement of materials, cycle time, manning, and flow of information. Inefficiencies in operations were identified using the TIMWOODS method of waste identification, and root cause analysis was done using Ishikawa and 5 Why methods to find out delays caused by internal movements, paperwork, and staging. Quality control activities were analysed against the standard of IS 2500 Part 1 acceptance sampling procedure, resulting in the development of check sheet to check dimensions, surface imperfections, and drawing defects.
-
-
DATA ANALYSIS AND DISCUSSION
Document Existing Manufacturing Process Using Value Stream Mapping (VSM)
TABLE I.
End-to-End Comparative Value Stream Mapping Across Product Lines
Parameter / Operational Metric
SKUs
ANODISE D COOKERS
(Aluminium
) Line
Stainless Steel (SS) Line
Tri-Ply Cooker Line
Total Major
Process Stages Mapped
10 stages
11 stages
11 stages
Body Forming Strategy
100% In-
house Press
Shop operations
Hybrid In- house (4 key
forming steps)
Fully outsource
d forming operations
In-House
Press Shop Operations
Deep
drawing, stretching,
Laser
cutting, cladding,
None
(Drawing, spinning,
Parameter / Operational Metric
SKUs
ANODISE D COOKERS
(Aluminium
) Line
Stainless Steel (SS) Line
Tri-Ply Cooker Line
trimming, forming, spinning, lipping, MHB
holing, oval cutting
dishing, and trimming
and lipping handled externally
; optional in-house oval
cutting)
Critical In- House Cycle Times
Pressing: 1014 s;
Deep draw: 1012 s
(Parkash Mechanical Press)
Laser cutting: 30
35 s;
Cladding: 2530 s
(Electrother m Press)
Oval cutting: 7590 s
(when processed in-house)
Subcontract Surface Finishing Hops
3 sequential hops (Buffing, Anodizing, Glossing)
1 combined vendor (Chamfering
, Buffing, and Sunray finishing)
Multi- vendor network (Drawing/ Spinning/ Lipping, Buffing, Vendor
Oval Cutting)
External Transit Distances
Local: 45
km; Outer
tier: 100
200 km
Regional cluster: 80
275 km
High dispersion
: 80
1,300 km(Palghar, Surat,
Delhi)
Longest External Dwell Time
13 days per hop (cumulative 39 days)
23 days cumulative dwell time
23 days forming + 2 days vendor
oval cutting
Body-to-Body Joining Method
Mechanical riveting (MHB / SHB)
Electric projection welding (MHB /
SHB)
Electric projection welding (MHB /
SHB)
Gate-Exit Dispatch
Documentatio n
4 physical Delivery
Challan copies
4 physical Delivery
Challan copies
4 physical Delivery
Challan copies
Total Major
Process Stages Mapped
10 stages
11 stages
11 stages
The diagnostic analysis of the value stream architectures of the main product lines of ABC Cookers Limited is provided in Table 1. It is clear that there are basic differences in operation determined by metal type and its forming process. While the line
of ANODISED COOKERS Aluminium involves deep forming in house with fast machine cycles (10-14 sec), it involves cumulative multi-hop delays in three sequential stages of surface finishing (buffing, anodizing, glossing). On the other hand, the line of Stainless Steel utilizes in-house laser cutting and cladding and is faster due to consolidated finishing vendors. As for the Tri-Ply line, it utilizes the outsourced production process without in-house forming, which makes the plant suffer from heavy geographic dispersion involving 1,300 km distance and long dwell time of vendors. In spite of the difference in physical factors, all the three lines have similar operational bottlenecks at administrative interfaces characterized by four-copy physical Delivery Challan process in the course of subcontracting.
Identify Value-Added and Non-Value-Added Activities and Classify Wastes (TIMWOODS)
TABLE II.
TIMWOODS Operational Waste Classification and
TIMWOO
DS Waste Category
Wastes Classification
Observed Shop- Floor Manifest ation
Process Location
/ Product Lines
Affected
Value Additi on Status
Business Impact & Operatio nal Severity
Transporta
Repeated
Raw
Non-
Extended
tion
multi-hop
Material
Value-
cumulativ
vendor
Stores,
Added
e
transits up
Subcontr
(NVA)
productio
to 1,300
act
n lead
km;
Flow;
times;
manual
All lines
vulnerabil
cart
(Severe
ity to in-
transfers
on Tri-
transit
between
Ply)
transit
internal
damages
bays
Inventory
Buffer
Job-
Non-
Elevated
accumulat
worker
Value-
working
ion of 13
locations
Added
capital
days
, Press
(NVA)
lock-in;
dwell
Shop
poor
time at
staging;
intermedi
external
ANODI
ate
job-
SED
material
workers;
COOKE
visibility
untracked
RS, SS,
and
floor WIP
Tri-Ply
staging
clutter
Motion
Non-
Subcontr
Non-
Operator
standardiz
act bay,
Value-
physical
ed travel
Press-to-
Added
fatigue,
(225 m)
Assembl
(NVA)
ergonomi
to
y
c strain,
subcontra
corridors
and
ct staging;
; All
variable
manual
product
transit
trolley
lines
times
movemen
Shop-Floor Audit
TIMWOO
DS Waste Category
Wastes Classification
Observed Shop- Floor Manifest ation
Process Location
/ Product
Lines Affected
Value Additi on Status
Business Impact & Operatio nal Severity
t across bays
across shifts
Waiting
Forklift
Gate
Non-
Truck
dependen
Entry,
Value-
idling,
cy at
Unloadi
Added
operation
unloading
ng Bay,
(NVA)
al idle
;
Press
time, and
sequential
Shop;
delayed
physical
All
line
and visual
pTroduct
feeding
checks
lines
during
during
shift
gate
handovers
entry/exit
Over-
Generatio
Dispatch
/td>
Non-
Redundan
processing
n,
, Gate
Value-
t clerical
distributio
Exit,
Added
labor,
n, and
Final
(NVA)
administr
individual
Packagin
ative
signing of
g; All
overhead,
4 physical
product
and
challan
lines
recurring
copies;
label
duplicate
waste
QR
printing
Overprodu
Regulated
Central
Necess
Controlle
ction
under
Press
ary
d risk of
plant
Shop,
Non-
obsolesce
Make-to-
Assembl
Value-
nce;
Stock
y Lines;
Added
batching
(MTS)
ANODI
(NNV
drives
batch
SED
A)
localized
schedules
COOKE
lot
(minimal
RS, SS,
staging
uncoordin
Tri-Ply
buffers
ated over-
runs)
This information is captured in Table 2 below, which illustrates the operational resistance within the product life cycle within the lean manufacturing concept of TIMWOODS. Through the analysis, it has been revealed that the production process within the factory faces tremendous operational challenges, mostly because of Transportation, Waiting, and Overprocessing. The transportation wastes tend to grow exponentially based on the geographical location of the supply chain and as a result, cause severe resistance on the Tri-Ply production line because of far job-work routes. Operation waiting resulting from single forklift and logistics coordination creates direct imbalance in the process. On the other hand, overprocessing waste is manifested in many ways including paperwork-based checks, like managing the four hardcopy delivery challans at gate exit an printing QR labels in packaging.
Most importantly, value-adding activity only takes place during the processes of Press forming, Finishing and Assembling..
Analyse Material Flow, Information Flow, Quality Inspection, and QR Traceability
TABLE III.
Direct Material / Component
Vendor Wise Analysis
Approved Vendor Base
Inbound Movement Mechanis m
Quality Checkpoint s & Inspection
Standard
Aluminium Circles
Vendor A
Vendor truck, Gate, Stores, Press
Visual, dimensional
, sheet thickness (IS 2500)
Stainless Steel Circles
Vendor B
Vendor truck, Gate, Stores, Press
Thickness, surface inclusions, dimensional
check
Lid Circles
Vendor C
Vendor truck, Gate, Stores, Press
Sheet thickness, diameter, drawability
inspection
Main Handle (MHB)
Vendor D
Trolley transfer, Riveting / Welding
Visual defect check, hole alignment,
fitment
Die Cast Component s
Vendor E
Inbound crates, Stores, Assembly
Visual finish, flash presence, thread
verification
Stainless Steel Discs
Vendor F
Palletized delivery, Press Shop
Thickness tolerance, surface finish,
diameter
Locking Loops
Vendor G
Boxed delivery, Assembly staging
Dimensiona l check, tension check, profile
check
Rivets
Vendor H
Bagged inventory, Hardware Stores
Material hardness, shank diameter,
head profile
Vent Tubes
Vendor I
Internal
bins, Assembly /
Thread
pitch, bore clearance,
Material Flow, Quality Governance, and QR Digital Traceability Audit- PART 1
Direct Material / Component
Vendor Wise Analysis
Approved Vendor Base
M
Inbound Movement Mechanis m
Quality Checkpoint s & Inspection
Standard
Sub- assembly
finish inspection
Cover Heads
Vendor j
Staged bins, Lid assembly line
Visual inspection, thread integrity,
plating check
Rubber Gaskets
Approved vendor tier
Sealed boxes, Final assembly
line
Elasticity, dimensional profile, flash check
Safety Valves
Approved vendor tier
Specialized trays, Final assembly
Pressure relief pop- off calibration,
threading
Semi- Finished Cooker Bodies
Internal Press & External Subcontractor s
Trolleys / Return crates, Incoming QC
13
parameters (Profile, diameter, dents,
cracks)
TABLE IV.
Material Flow, Quality Governance, and QR Digital Traceability Audit- PART 2
Direct Material / Component
Direct Material wise Traceability
ERP Auto- Challan Integration
QR Code Coverage for Purchase
GRR
Digitization & Traceability
Status
Aluminium Circles
Fully Integrated
Missing (No QR)
Critical High- Volume
Digitization Gap
Stainless Steel Circles
Fully Integrated
Missing (No QR)
Critical High- Volume Digitization
Gap
Lid Circles
Fully Integrated
Missing (No QR)
High-Volume
Raw Material Gap
Main
Handle (MHB)
Fully Integrated
Missing (No QR)
Hardware
Digitization Gap
Die Cast Components
Fully Integrated
Missing (No QR)
Hardware
Digitization Gap
Stainless Steel Discs
Fully Integrated
Missing (No QR)
Forming Substrate
Direct Material / Component
Direct Material wise Traceability
ERP Auto- Challan Integration
QR Code Coverage for
Purchase GRR
Digitization &
Traceability Status
Digitization Gap
Locking Loops
Fully Integrated
Missing (No QR)
Fastener Hardware Gap
Rivets
Fully Integrated
Partial (Modern only)
Fragmented Vendor QR Adherence
Vent Tubes
Fully Integrated
Partial (Recent lots missing)
Inconsistent Supplier QR Compliance
Cover Heads
Fully Integrated
Partial (Sadhguru
only)
Fragmented Vendor QR
Adherence
Rubber Gaskets
Fully Integrated
Fully Implemented
Complete QR Traceability
Closed-Loop
Safety Valves
Fully Integrated
Fully Implemented
Complete QR Traceability
Closed-Loop
Semi- Finished Cooker
Bodies
Challan tracked
Missing on internal trolleys
Paper-reliant inspection handoffs
Table 3 and 4 highlights a comparison between movement of materials, frameworks for quality control, and digital traceability systems. While all vendors use ERP for challans but there is significant gap between QR traceability of the materials. Only around 40% components feature end-to-end QR traceability and implementation coverage. Surprisingly, the components such as lid and aluminium do not have traceability for QR codes . Quality inspection is random and does not follow any specific standards; however, execution remains predominantly paper-bound. Lack of tagging on the trolleys on shop-floor creates significant chaos and dependence on the person supervising it causing lack of traceability and identification of material after , before metal finishing, material in WIP and what needs to go for assembly.
TABLE V.
Multi-Criteria Process Bottleneck and Root-Cause Diagnostic Analysis PART-1
Manufact uring Node / Process Stage
Root Cause Analysis
Primary Operational Bottleneck Root Cause (5-Why / Ishikawa Finding)Obs erved Delay /
Metric
Primary Operational Bottleneck Root Cause (5-Why / Ishikawa Finding)Obs erved Delay /
Metric
Primary Operational BottleneckR oot Cause (5-Why / Ishikawa
Finding)Obs erved Delay / Metric
Raw Material Receiving
Prolonged truck dwell
time and
Single forklift dependency;
4590 min vehicle waiting
Manufact uring Node / Process Stage
Root Cause Analysis
Primary Operational Bottleneck Root Cause (5-Why / Ishikawa Finding)Obs
erved Delay / Metric
Primary Operational Bottleneck Root Cause (5-Why / Ishikawa Finding)Obs
erved Delay / Metric
Primary Operational BottleneckR oot Cause (5-Why / Ishikawa
Finding)Obs
erved Delay / Metric
& Unloading
receiving bay congestion
absence of designated unloading berths; driver
break overlap
during peak hours
In-House Press Shop Forming
Line stagnation; staging clutter near trimming and laser cutting
Suboptimal layout; lack of buffer management; untagged intermediate
transport trolleys
1530 min batch transit and staging latency
First-Off Quality Approval
Press lines idling awaiting setup buy-off
Quality inspector unavailable on-floor; paper-based
notification procedures
2040 min setup idle time per tooling changeover
Subcontra ct Dispatch & Staging
Staging aisle congestion; dispatch delays at internal transfer
Ambiguous physical loading areas (225 m
variation); 4- copy hardcopy challan sign-
offs
3060 min gate departure latency
External Vendor Processing
Extended dwell times; multi-day processing queues
Lack of visibility into external Mbuffer stock;
geographic
dispersion up to 1,300 km
13 days dwell time per subcontract hop
Incoming Subcontra ct Inspection
Staged body backlog at receiving inspection bay
Manual data entry into logbooks; irregular application of IS 2500
sampling tables
24 hours lot clearance queue time
Final Packaging & Dispatch
Exit
Aisle blockages; carton deterioration;
Space constraints; moisture- susceptible
cardboard
1020 min dispatch verification delay per
shipment
Root Cause Analysis
Primary
Primary
Primary
Manufact uring Node / Process Stage
Operational Bottleneck Root Cause (5-Why / Ishikawa
Finding)Obs
Operational Bottleneck Root Cause (5-Why / Ishikawa
Finding)Obs
Operational BottleneckR oot Cause (5-Why / Ishikawa
Finding)Obs
erved Delay /
erved Delay /
erved Delay /
Metric
Metric
Metric
redundant
cartons;
labeling
duplicated
QR reprint
cycles
TABLE VI.
Multi-Criteria Process Bottleneck and Root-Cause Diagnostic Analysis PART-2
Manufacturing Node / Process Stage
Root Cause Analysis
Raw Material Receiving &
Unloading
Inbound transit scuffs, denting from manual
offloading
High Operational
Bottleneck
In-House Press Shop Forming
Dominates scrap: 4
5% line rejection (wrinkles, draw cracks)
Critical Quality & Flow
Bottleneck
First-Off Quality Approval
Line idling rather than defects; loss of
productive machine hours
High Availability Loss
Subcontract
Dispatch & Staging
Handling scratches,
corner denting during manual truck loading
High Logistics Overhead
External Vendor Processing
12% vendor return rejection (buffing
burns, uneven anodizing)
Critical Lead Time Inflator
Incoming
Subcontract Inspection
Risk of defective lots
entering assembly undeteced
High Quality
Assurance Bottleneck
Final Packaging & Dispatch Exit
Carton compression damage; duplicate
scanning errors at warehouse
Medium Operational Overhead
Table 5 & 6 identifies bottlenecks within the plant at operational, mechanical, and informational points. Operational data reveals that the main operational bottlenecks are due to material handing issues and administrative obstacles and not because of limits placed on the machines' primary cycle times. The raw material handling and internal transportation points have suffered immensely due to limited capacity for forklifts and poor planning in transit pathways, leading to vehicle idle times of as high as 90 minutes. In terms of quality, the Press Shop constitutes the main hub of defects, responsible for 4-5% of the cumulative rejection rate of 7-8% for the whole plant, due to metal deformation defects like wrinkles, breaking of metal when forming and tearing of metal edges. Subcontractor activities lead
to major inflations in lead times, due to dwell times for materials of up to three days alongside paper-based incoming inspections.
Recommend Feasible Lean and Digital Improvement Initiatives
TABLE VII.
Actionable Lean Interventions, Digital Architecture,
and Projected Business Impact- I
Targeted Operation al Bottleneck
Actionable Lean Interventions, Digital Architecture, and Projected Business
Impact
Lean & TIMWOOD S
Classificatio n
Proposed Automatio n / Digital Solution
Practical Implementati on Roadmap
M
4-copy hardcopy delivery challan sign-off
Over- Processing
Digital Invoice & E-Sign Workflow
QR-coded digital challan, gate scan, mobile e-sign, ERP
integration
Machine idle time awaiting setup buy- off
Waiting / Motion
Digital First-Off Andon Alert System
Operator triggers "Setup Ready", QC receives instant alert,
tablet sign-off
Unloading delays and vehicle congestion
Waiting / Transportati on
Digital Vehicle Queue & Dynamic Bay
System
Pre-arrival QR booking, automated token call, dedicated
docking bay
Recurring shop-floor aisle clutter
Motion / Delay
Digital 5S Mobile Audit Framework
QR tags per zone, weekly mobile audits with photo
verification, auto-scoring
Single- operator dependency during breaks
Waiting
Digital Roster & Shift Relief Notificatio n
ERP shift roster, automated notification of relief operators
during breaks
Single- forklift handling dependency
Waiting / Transportati on
Telematics Forklift Utilization Tracking
IoT hour- meters and tracking to audit actual uptime before approving
capital assets
Unexpected forklift maintenanc
Waiting / Equipment Loss
QR-Based Preventive
Maintenan ce (TPM)
QR tag on assets,
operator daily pre-shift
Targeted Operation al Bottleneck
Actionable Lean Interventions, Digital Architecture, and Projected Business
Impact
Lean & TIMWOOD S
Classificatio n
Proposed Automatio n / Digital Solution
Practical Implementati on Roadmap
Inability to track real- time cooker WIP
Inventory / Tracking Waste
Digital Multi- Stage WIP Milestone Scan
Tablet milestone scanning at Press, Buffing, Anodizing,
and Final Assembly
Repeated duplicate QR label printing
Over- Processing
Duplicate Print Prevention Interlock
Print-server validation preventing re- printing without
supervisory override
Inconsistent AQL
sampling enforcemen t
Defects / Quality Governance
Digital IS 2500 AQL
Quality Portal
Mandatory digital check sheet logging 13 inspection points before
ERP release
Targeted Operation al Bottleneck
Actionable Lean Interventions, Digital Architecture, and Projected Business
Impact
Lean & TIMWOOD S
Classificatio n
Proposed Automatio n / Digital Solution
Practical Implementati on Roadmap
e breakdowns
mobile checks,
predictive alerts
Heavy manual exertion moving trolleys
Motion / Transportati on
Powered Electric Tug / Motorized Trolleys
Deploy electric tugs on high- frequency transit routes
(Press Shop, Assembly)
Rework stock mixed with prime inventory
Inventory / Defects
QR-Coded Dynamic Rework Quarantine
Red-tagged QR lots, software- locked ERP status, dedicated
physical cage
Untracked internal material carts
Inventory / Motion
Smart QR- Enabled Trolley Tracking
Laser-etched QR tags per cart, milestone tracking (Bay, Subcontract,
Line)
Manual e-
way bill generation overhead
Over- Processing / Redundancy
Automated ERP-to-E-
Way Bill API Bridge
Direct API bridge pushing ERP sales orders to the government e-
way portal
Disorganize d packing material staging
Storage / Motion
Visual Digital Packaging Supermark et
Fixed barcode- racked locations, automated min/max replenishment
alerts
Carton moisture damage during transit
Inventory / Quality Cost
Returnable Smart Plastic Crates
Heavy-duty foldable plastic totes with RFID/QR,
vendor closed- loop return
Aisle congestion near laser oval cutting
Delay /
Motion
Designated FIFO
Paint- Marked Lanes
Color-coded floor bays and physical roller racks ensuring strict FIFO
discipline
The roadmap of comprehensive improvement in a low capital expenditure manner has been mapped out in Table 7 in context to the operational landscape of ABC Cookers Limited. The initiatives proposed have helped address directly the problem of 17 wastage areas in the shop floor through the implementation of the Lean work place design and selected applications of digital technology under the Industry 4.0 revolution. The major interventions in the form of setting up an ERP system linked with API for e-way bill creation and digital sign-off for delivery challans help eliminate over processing and reduce turnaround time at gates. In the shop floors, implementing an inspection notification via the Andon system and QR trolley tracker systems would directly help solve the waiting problem and hidden WIP respectively. Moreover, instituting a digital IS 2500 system would eliminate wastage from the 4-5% press shop and 1-2% vendors by making the parameter checking mandatory. The aggregate capital cost of which is not very significant.
-
FINDINGS, CONCLUSIONS AND SUGGESSIONS
-
Findings
During the analysis of the empirical study at ABC Cookers Limited, it became clear that there were several operational discrepancies and lean waste generators for each of the ANODISED COOKERS Aluminium, Stainless Steel, and Tri- Ply manufacturing processes. First of all, it was found that through Value Stream Mapping, value generation occurs in only three key areas – press shop forming, subcontracted surface finishing, and assembly; however, the support processes add a lot of non-value added overhead. Secondly, it was discovered that the Tri-Ply stream suffers from an extremely vulnerable
transportation waste because of the total dependence on distant geographically dispersed third-party forming vendors operating up to 1,300 km away with multiday dwell times, unlike other ANODISED COOKERS (1014 seconds) and Stainless Steel lines. Thirdly, in the case of all three manufacturing processes, the lack of efficiency caused by logistical issues is quite obvious, since the process of passing a challan takes place with the help of four separate copies and because of excessive waiting time (4590 minutes) caused by using a single forklift during unloading. Finally, the company's pressing process is the leading cause of rejections in the plant (7-8% cumulative rate), producing 4-5% scrap of fractured or wrinkled product. Moreover, it suffers from first-off inspection delays, as well as from the lack of IS 2500 Part 1 AQL sample enforcement. An analysis of the materials traceability showed that the plant experiences digitization problems. While high-risk safety hardware (gaskets, safety valves) has QR-code coverage of 100%, raw materials and intermediate product components (such as aluminium, stainless steel, and lid circles) have no Goods Receipt (GRR) process based on QR codes at all.
-
Conclusions
The comparative Value Stream Mapping study of ABC Cookers Limited reveals that despite individual high efficiencies of the forming/assembly process, the main factors restricting its efficiency relate to logistics hand-offs, administration lags, and traceability issues. As the analysis revealed, the main bottlenecks limiting production efficiency relate to structural wastes not directly associated with lack of machine capacity namely, excessive transportation efforts, time-consuming waiting related to forklifts operations, and laborious challan deliveries. There was a specific strategic contradiction revealed between various lines, as ANODISED COOKERS and Stainless Steel lines use efficient in-house press but have to go through multiple transportation loops during finishing operations. At the same time, the outsourced forming operation on the part of the Tri-Ply line results in significant lead-time associated with transportation efforts. At the same time, presence of significant amounts of defects (up to 4-5 % of scrap) in the press shop and lack of Goods Receipt with QR code for bulk metals require introducing effective quality governance mechanism. With systematic introduction of capital-efficient lean techniques, such as electronic first-off Andon, standard IS 2500 sampling, smart QR tracking of trolleys and integration of ERP billing system.
-
Suggestions
A roadmap for the success of the initiatives in achieving tangible benefits should consider the following key aspects for all stakeholders:
Management and IT move away from paper four copies challenge process into an automatic digital signature ERP and e- Waybill process that will lead to minimizing administration cost and fast truck turnover time at the gate.
Plant logistics and floor workers: Introduce a digital vehicle docking schedule in order to avoid single forklift waiting times and introduce electric tugs in the main transport corridors in order to reduce the effort, use of plastic weather resistant returnable trolleys to ensure FIFO lane.
Quality assurance and operators: Introduce mobile-enabled andon and electronic inspection system (IS 2500).
Suppliers and subcontractors: Expand the use of QR code traceability to bulk metal circles and intermediate trolleys and plastic weather resistant returnable trolleys in order to close loop of inventory control and minimize transit damage and smooth material handing.
-
Implications of the study
The findings of the research bring important and tangible implications and benefit for all key primary stakeholder groups:
Executive management and shareholders minimizing the intermediate redundancy of work, reducing buffer inventory, and eliminating 7-8% of the scrap brings benefits of minimizing working capital, increasing productivity and saving operating margins.
Shop-floor operators and shop-floor supervisors moving from manual transportation by trolleys to using motorized tugs as well as introducing visual 5S control systems increases ergonomics and minimizes physical stress in the workplace. Andon in real time gives ability to make tooling buy off and eliminates the friction of stopping the line.
Quality assurance and compliance teams: Making IS 2500 AQL check sheet electronic and extending QR traceability to raw circles leads to uniform quality criteria for sampling, fast containment of defects and full traceability of batches.
Suppliers, subcontractors, and transporters introducing automatic E-Way billing, digitization of challan, and appointment based dock will significantly reduce waiting times of vehicles at plant gate bringing benefits of quick payment, minimized.
-
Future Scope of the study
The outcomes of this research and its base VSM results point to several possibilities for future work on the topic:
Dynamic Modeling: Future studies can implement a discrete event simulation (such as in AnyLogic/Arena) of machine balance, line balancing, and buffer sizes in response to fluctuating demand in advance of reconfiguring the actual physical floorplan.
Industry 4.0 & Automatic Traceability: Future research can look into the operational transition from QR code-based traceability to RFID or Internet-of-Things based smart sensors on the trolley system to enable automatic, touchless, real-time WIP tracking and cycle time monitoring at the machine level. Supply Chain Optimization: The logistics of the supply chain can be optimized in a dedicated TCO-oriented study to compare the cost implications of the current outsourcing of tri-ply pressing to the option of localizing vendor sites near the main factory site.
Green & Ergonomic Lean: Future studies implementing Sus- VSM (Sustainable Value Stream Mapping) can study the energy footprint of the process of forming, the risk indices (RULA/REBA) of manually moving the trolleys, and the life- cycle effects of plastic crate vs cardboard box substitution.
ACKNOWLEDGMENT
I express my sincere gratitude to the management, operations team, and shop-floor personnel of ABC Cookers Limited for their invaluable mentorship, technical guidance, and operational
support throughout this summer internship project. I am also deeply thankful to my academic advisors and industry mentors whose continuous encouragement made the successful completion of this research study possible.
Disclaimer: Name of the company is not mentioned due to the Non-Disclosure Agreement. Whereas, analysis done is on the true facts and figures.
REFERENCES
-
Abdennadher, M., Sellami, A., Stockburger, E., Mohnfeld, N., Wester, H., Behrens, B.-A., Bouguecha, A., & Elleuch,
R. (2024). Deep drawing of coated aluminium sheets: Experimental and numerical study. Materialwissenschaft und Werkstofftechnik. Advance online publication. https://www.semanticscholar.org/paper/c3d400a828a96cd 34e3cc19663a1295803949216
-
Ahmad, A. (2011). Application of value stream mapping as a method to reduce cycle time to support lean manufacturing system [Unpublished manuscript]. Semantic Scholar.
https://www.semanticscholar.org/paper/c8fffdfb41a24e4e bb6e898d8e5592707dcc23e5
-
Arnando, F. (2015). Analisa waste dan peningkatan kualitas pada proses produksi pengolahan stainless steel dengan pendekatan lean manufacturing (Studi kasus: PT. X) [Unpublished undergraduate thesis]. Semantic Scholar. https://www.semanticscholar.org/paper/eb7493933e27d03 cc494ef9a10b0b336228845ea
-
Damsiar. (2020). Waste analysis to increase productivity of metal press line in motorcycle discbrake industry using work study and lean manufacturing methods. International Journal of Mechanical and Production Engineering Research and Development, 10(3), 10471056. https://doi.org/10.24247/ijmperdjun20201047
-
Dewa, M., & Lusiba, K. P. (2018). Continuous process improvement on heat exchanger plant through value stream mapping. In Proceedings of the International Conference on Industrial Engineering and Operations Management. https://www.semanticscholar.org/paper/c0e1e4c72ecee3e 0e44baeef4b25a2670873098d
-
Dighe, S., & Kakirde, A. (2014). Lean manufacturing implementation using value stream mapping: A case study of pumps manufacturing company. International Journal of Science, Engineering and Technology Research, 3(6), 16811686.
https://www.semanticscholar.org/paper/cab80532f0e88fc8 0af72eb152c3b1b492e1ea79
-
Ealias, J., P. V., R., & Kiron, K. R. (2025). Factor impacting the quality of aluminium pot for developing customer language in FMQFD analysis. In Proceedings of the International Conference on Industrial Engineering and Operations Management (pp. 281290). IEOM Society International.
https://ieomsociety.org/proceedings/india2025/281.pdf
-
Infanteri, A. B. A. (2018). Implementasi lean manufacturing untuk mengurangi pemborosan (waste) pada proses produksi wajan super (Studi kasus di IKM WL Alumunium Umbulharjo, Yogyakarta) [Unpublished thesis]. Semantic Scholar. https://www.semanticscholar.org/paper/b1531c373e3cd76 b1d1e234061898891f91dd137
-
Jaiswal, S., & Soni, M. (2017). A review on application of value stream mapping tool in small scale industry for waste reduction. International Journal of Engineering Sciences & Research Technology, 6(6), 332338. https://www.semanticscholar.org/paper/5b6ef6adf17ab33 6d98f567a2294af07917ab1cd
-
Jawalkar, C. (2016). Improvement in product design through lean manufacturing and value stream mapping. International Journal of Management and Information Technology, 11(2), 27742782. https://www.semanticscholar.org/paper/2774d2aa0028400 4292aacae065321cfcea6bcfb
-
Kaneku-Orbegozo, J., Martinez-Palomino, J., Sotelo- Raffo, F., & Ramos-Palomino, E. (2019). Applying lean manufacturing principles to reduce waste and improve process in a manufacturer: A research study in Peru. IOP Conference Series: Materials Science and Engineering, 689(1), Article 012020. https://doi.org/10.1088/1757- 899X/689/1/012020
-
Karim, A., Jaafar, A., Abdullah, M. A., Haque, M., Ali, M., & Azline, S. A. (2012). Applying value stream mapping for productivity improvement of a metal stamping industry. Advanced Materials Research, 576, 727730. https://doi.org/10.4028/www.scientific.net/AMR.576.727
-
Luan, T. D., Doanh, N. T., & Luc, B. Q. (2021). Effect of different tool on surface roughness for aluminium cookwares polishing. Journal of Mechanical Engineering Research and Developments, 44(4), 188194. https://www.semanticscholar.org/paper/108b5bb1643526 8c31c371b1be37ade389ff2395
-
Management of non-value-added activities to minimize lead time using value stream mapping in the steel industry. (2020). Acta Montanistica Slovaca, 25(3), 328339. https://doi.org/10.46544/ams.v25i3.15
-
Murugananthan, V., Govindaraj, K., & Sakthimurugan, D. (2014). Process planning through value stream mapping in foundry. International Journal of Innovative Research in Science, Engineering and Technology, 3(2), 92959302. https://www.semanticscholar.org/paper/f322e7da370e68c 9cee7f031c17f43b55166e602
-
Nivya, M. (2016). Application of value stream mapping in a forging industry: A case study. International Journal of Mechanical Engineering and Technology, 7(4), 8591. https://www.semanticscholar.org/paper/a4dc29ddd8e1072 38c9c56c8fab45299b43e7fa4
-
Ravichandran, V. (2015). Value stream mapping to improve value ratio of subcontracting process in a pressure vessel manufacturing facility: A case study. International Journal of Applied Research, 1(9), 415420. https://www.semanticscholar.org/paper/cff193e406ba615 d8d34790bde5442081c89542c
-
S., D. (2025). A study of lean management implementation. International Journal of Scientific Research in Engineering and Management, 9(3), 19. https://ijsrem.com/download/a-study-of-lean- management-implementation/
-
Salsabila, I. R., & Rochmoeljati, R. (2021). Analisis penerapan konsep lean manufacturing pada proses produksi stainless steel coil untuk mereduksi pemborosan (waste) di PT. XYZ. Juminten: Jurnal Manajemen Industri dan Logistik, 2(2), 117128. http://juminten.upnjatim.ac.id/index.php/juminten/article/ download/235/117
