Comparative Effects of ZnO and TiO₂ Nanoparticles on the Electrical, Electro-Optical, and Sensing Properties of High-Birefringence Nematic Liquid Crystals: A Critical Review

Comparative Effects of ZnO and TiO Nanoparticles on the Electrical, Electro-Optical, and Sensing Properties of High-Birefringence Nematic Liquid Crystals: A Critical Review

K.V.S.N. Raju (1)*, K. SivaRam (2), M.V.V.K Srinivasa Prasad (3), B.L.V Ramana (4), G. Satyannarayana (1) and Shaik Salma Begum (5)*

(1) Department of Physics, AdiKavi Nannaya University, Tadepalligudem Campus, A.P-534101, India

(2) Department of Basic Sciences and Humanities, YJR DMS College of Engineering, Affiliated to JNTUK, Machilipatnam-521001, Krishna Dt., A.P.

(3) Department of Physics, Koneru Lakshmaiah Education Foundation, Green Fields, Vaddeswaram, 522502, A.P,India

(4) Department of Chemistry, AdiKavi Nannaya University, Tadepalligudem Campus, A.P-534101, India

(5) Department of Physics, Krishna University College of Engineering and Technology, Machilipatnam 521004, India

Abstract – This critical review provides a comprehensive comparative evaluation of zinc oxide (ZnO) and titanium dioxide (TiO) nanoparticles (NPs) dispersed within modern high-birefringence (n) nematic liquid crystal (LC) hosts, marking a substantial paradigm shift from traditional low-birefringence matrices like EBCA. We evaluate how the intrinsic electronic configuration, spatial morphology, and surface charge properties of ZnO and TiO nano-dopants differentially modulate the host’s long-range orientational order, dielectric anisotropy, rotational viscosity, and threshold voltages. Crucially, this work integrates rigorous multi-spectroscopic and optical characterization methodologiesspecifically Fourier-Transform Infrared (FT-IR) spectroscopy for order parameter determination, Ultraviolet-Visible (UV-Vis) spectrophotometry for band-gap and transmittance profiling, and Polarizing Optical Microscopy (POM) for phase transition kinetics and texture morphology mapping. Finally, the state-of-the-art applications of these hybrid colloidal suspensions are scrutinized across electrical modulation, advanced electro-optical shutters, broadband optical sensors, and emergent biomedical/interfacial diagnostic platforms.

Key Words: Zinc oxide (ZnO), Titanium dioxide (TiO), High-birefringence (n) nematic liquid crystals, Dielectric anisotropy, Rotational viscosity, Threshold voltages, Orientational order parameter, FT-IR spectroscopy, UV-Vis, Polarizing Optical Microscopy.

1. INTRODUCTION

   The coupling of nanotechnology with soft-matter physics has opened groundbreaking avenues for developing adaptive optical and photonic media. Among these, nanoparticle-doped liquid crystals (NPLCs) represent a prominent class of self-assembled hybrid materials [1]. By introducing metallic, semiconducting, or ferroelectric nanoparticles into a liquid crystalline matrix, researchers can dramatically alter the macroscopic electrical, optical, and thermodynamic parameters of the mesophase without losing its fluid-like responsiveness. Historically, p-ethoxy benzylidene-p-cyano aniline (EBCA) or alternative legacy Schiff-base matrices served as critical baseline models for establishing fundamental concepts in liquid crystal physics, including molecular ordering, dielectric relaxation, and basic electrohydrodynamic instabilities [2].

   However, modern technological demands for ultra-fast displays, high-speed optical modulators, and high-frequency communication devices operating in the microwave, terahertz, and millimetre-wave bands require a transition to advanced, high- birefringence (n 0.2 to 0.7 in the near-infrared and microwave bands) nematic liquid crystal systems [3]. These modern hosts typically utilize rigid aromatic cores containing multiple conjugated -electron systems, often linked via ethynyl bridges and

   terminated with highly polar groups such as isothiocyanates (-NCS), cyanides (-CN), or fluorinated elements. These formulations exhibit massive optical anisotropy and significantly modified dielectric configurations compared to traditional frameworks. When transition metal oxide nanoparticles such as zinc oxide (ZnO) and titanium dioxide (TiO) are introduced into these state-of-the-art high-birefringence systems, they induce complex, non-linear electro-optic phenomena that are fundamentally distinct from those observed in classical matrices like EBCA [4].

2. FUNDAMENTAL MATERIAL CHARACTERISTICS: ZNO VS. TIO

   To comprehend the distinct macroscopic alterations observed in NPLC mixtures, one must examine the localized structural and electronic attributes of zinc oxide and titanium dioxide. ZnO is an intrinsic n-type semiconductor crystallizing predominantly in the hexagonal wurtzite structure at ambient conditions, exhibiting a direct wide bandgap of approximately 3.37 eV. A defining feature of ZnO nanoparticles is their substantial spontaneous polarization and high exciton binding energy (60 meV), which induces strong localized electrostatic fields [5]. These fields interact aggressively with the permanent and induced dipoles of the surrounding liquid crystal molecules, profoundly influencing the surrounding molecular anchoring.

   Conversely, TiO typically manifests in three primary polymorphic configurations: anatase, rutile, and brookite, with anatase and rutile being the primary focuses in soft matter dopant research. Anatase TiO exhibits an indirect bandgap of ~3.23 eV, whereas rutile presents a narrower direct/indirect transitional gap of ~3.02 eV. TiO nanoparticles are highly regarded for their exceptionally high static dielectric constant (reaching up to 180 for rutile), which far surpasses that of ZnO [6-8]. Consequently, when TiO nanoparticles are dispersed into a liquid crystal matrix, they distort the local permittivity landscape much more severely than ZnO. This induces localized variations in the internal electric field distribution when an external bias is applied, modifying the collective switching behavior of the host.

   Fig 1:(a) Crystal lattice diagrams showing the three primary polymorphs of titanium dioxide TiO: Anatase (tetragonal),

   Brookite (orthorhombic), and Rutile (tetragonal).

   Fig 1:(b) A mechanism schematic illustrating the process of photoreforming plastic waste over the semiconductor catalyst to simultaneously degrade the plastic into value-added chemicals (like acetate/acetic acid and terephthalate) while generating hydrogen gas H2

   Beyond their distinctive static dielectric properties, a critical yet frequently overlooked parameter when deploying these transition metal oxides is their active behavior under actinic electromagnetic radiation. Anatase and rutile polymorphs of TiO exhibit highly potent photocatalytic activity when exposed to near-UV probing radiation or ambient lighting during multi-hour UV-Vis and optical characterization loops [9-10]. In the presence of ambient moisture or trace oxygen, unpassivated TiO cores undergo rapid photo-induced electron-hole separation, generating highly reactive radical pathways and reactive oxygen species (ROS). These volatile species aggressively attack the chemically vulnerable linkages within advanced high-birefringence hosts, such as ethynyl bridges (-CC-) or highly conjugated terphenyl/tolane ring structures, leading to irreversible photochemical degradation, phase separation, and rapid clearing point (T_NI) depression [11]. Consequently, mitigating this degradative aging pathway mandates rigorous encapsulation protocols or the synthesis of core-shell architectures (e.g., TiO@SiO) that isolate the catalytic core while maintaining the desired macroscopic dielectric alterations.

3. ANALYTICAL CHARACTERIZATION METHODOLOGIES

   1. Fourier-Transform Infrared (FT-IR) Spectroscopy

      Fourier-Transform Infrared (FT-IR) spectroscopy provides invaluable insight into the intermolecular interactions and the degree of orientational order within the hybrid system. To quantitatively map the influence of metal oxide nano-inclusions on the long- range orientational architecture of the host, the microscopic scalar order parameter (S) must be strictly evaluated using polarized infrared absorption spectra [12-13]. For contemporary high-birefringence nematic systems, this is achieved by isolating the highly localized terminal stretching vibrationsspecifically the prominent isothiocyanate (-NCS) band appearing between 20502150 cm¹ or the sharp cyano (-CN) nitrile mode localized at ~2226 cm¹. By collecting absorbance profiles parallel (A) and perpendicular (A) to the rubbing-induced director axis (n), the experimental dichroic ratio (R = A / A) is calculated. Assuming the transition dipole moment of the target functional vibration is aligned parallel to the long molecular core of the mesogen, the scalar order parameter is explicitly defined via the foundational expression [14]:

      =

      +

      Fig 2: optimally oriented geometries and conformational metrics

      High-precision FT-IR auditing reveals that ultra-low loading regimes (< 0.5 wt.%) of wurtzite ZnO nanoparticles systematically elevate S. This structural optimization is driven by strong dipole-dipole coupling between the permanent molecular dipoles of the conjugated liquid crystal rings and the intense intrinsic spontaneous polarization of the ZnO crystal facets [15]. Conversely, the introduction of TiO particles, particularly at elevated mass fractions, induces local steric constraints and spatial microdomain distortions, manifested spectroscopically as asymmetric broadening and attenuation of these terminal vibrational modes, signaling a localized breakdown of the long-range nematic matrix order.

   2. Ultraviolet-Visible (UV-Vis) Spectrophotometry

      Ultraviolet-Visible (UV-Vis) spectrophotometry serves as the primary mechanism for auditing the optical transmission window and assessing the electronic band-edge shifts of the NPLC complex. Neat high-birefringence liquid crystals with highly conjugated aromatic structures possess inherent absorption bands in the near-UV spectrum. Dispersing ZnO nanoparticles introduces a distinct, sharp excitonic absorption peak around 360380 nm, which can be leveraged to compute the optical bandgap using Tauc plot formulations [16-17].

      Fig 3: Tauc plot of (a) ZnO-D and ZnO-D-CNT, (b) ZnO-D-PEDOT: PSS, (c) ZnO-A and ZnO-A-CNT, and (d) ZnO-A- PEDOT: PSS.

      UV-Vis profiling is essential for evaluating scattering losses; aggregation of either ZnO or TiO leads to Rayleigh and Mie scattering, which manifests as a broad baseline elevation in the absorbance spectrum across the visible spectrum (400700 nm). Furthermore, TiO incorporation shifts the optical absorption edge deeper into the visible range, facilitating photo-responsive applications by engineering light-harvesting thresholds [18].

   3. Polarizing Optical Microscopy (POM)

      Polarizing Optical Microscopy (POM) enables real-time visual mapping of the liquid crystal mesomorphic textures, phase transition temperatures, and defect nucleation. Pure high-birefringence nematic mixtures exhibit highly characteristic schlieren or threaded textures under crossed polarizers. When ZnO nanoparticles are cleanly dispersed, they maintain texture uniformity while causing shifts in the isotropic-nematic clearing temperature (TNI), indicating changes in the thermal stability of the mesophase. However, beyond a critical concentration threshold, POM clearly resolves the appearance of dark, non-birefringent colloidal aggregates that act as anchoring defects [19-20]. TiO nanoparticles often induce localized pseudoisotropic domains or surface- mediated homeotropic alignment regimes, visible under POM as a darkening of the optical field that dynamically recovers its nematic birefringence upon the application of a threshold voltage.

      Fig 4: Effect of shape of ZnO nanoparticle on electro-optic and dielectric properties of nematic liquid crystal

4. PHYSICAL PROPERTY MODIFICATIONS & PROPOSED MECHANISMS

   1. Electrical and Dielectric Properties

      The modifications of dielectric anisotropy and ionic conductivity represent the primary mechanisms by which nanoparticles change liquid crystal functionality. In traditional hosts, ion accumulation at the alignment layers frequently causes screening effects, resulting in image sticking and slow relaxation. Dispersing ZnO nanoparticles significantly alters this dynamic. Due to their surface charge properties, ZnO particles act as efficient ion scavengers, trapping free mobile ions within the bulk fluid [21-

      22]. This ion scavenging reduces the total ion density, leading to a suppressed low-frequency dielectric relaxation peak and a dramatic reduction in unintended electrical conductivity.

      TiO nanoparticles follow an entirely different mechanism dominated by their high internal permittivity. When an external electric field is applied, the large dielectric constant of TiO nanoparticles induces massive local electric field enhancement in the surrounding LC medium. This amplifies the effective torque acting on the molecular directors, leading to a substantial increase in the net dielectric anisotropy of the composite system [23]. However, TiO nanoparticles can also increase the baseline rotational viscosity if the concentration exceeds optimal levels, causing a trade-off between electrical sensitivity and structural fluid drag.

   2. Electro-Optical Response and Switching Kinetics

      The threshold voltage required to initiate the Freedericksz transition is governed by the classic relationship balancing elastic forces and dielectric torque. In a conventional planar-aligned nematic configuration subjected to a perpendicular electric field, this electro-mechanical threshold is quantitatively isolated through the continuum expression [24]:

      Vth=

      where Kii represents the specific governing elastic constant (K11 for splay or K33 for bend deformations), 0 is the vacuum permittivity, and is the macroscopic dielectric anisotropy of the composite fluid.

      Fig 5: a Optical retardance vs applied voltage; d = (2.9 ± 0.1) m; f = 200 kHz, square wave; 170 °C. b Rate of retardance change demonstrating a threshold at 0.24 V. c Fitting the voltage dependence of retardance ()yields = . .

      Deconvoluting the operational mechanisms reveals that ZnO and TiO act upon completely orthogonal vectors of this equation [25]. ZnO nano-dopants minimize screening fields within the bulk by acting as potent traps for mobile ionic impurities, thus stabilizing the effective voltage dropped across the active liquid crystal layer; however, they concurrently introduce elastic variations (Kii) by imposing localized micro-anchoring conditions on the surrounding director field. In sharp contrast, TiO inclusions dramatically amplify the denominator () through massive local electric field enhancements driven by the enormous static permittivity of the titania core. This localized field amplification generates a severe drop in Vth, minimizing driving voltage requirements, though a fine balance must be maintained to prevent parasitic increases in the fluid’s rotational viscosity (1).

      Table 1: Deep Comparative Matrix of ZnO and TiO Nanoparticle Effects

      Evaluated Dimension	ZnO-Doped Liquid Crystals	TiO-Doped Liquid Crystals
      Dielectric Anisotropy Modulations	Moderate enhancements. Dominated by wurtzite surface charge aignment and dipole coupling.	Massive local enhancements due to the exceptionally high static dielectric constant of rutile/anatase cores.
      Ion Transport Behavior	Acts as a highly potent ion scavenger, trapping free mobile ions and suppressing low-	Concentration-dependent ionic profile; can act as an ion scavenger at <0.2 wt.%, but promotes ion

      	frequency parasitics.	hopping at higher concentrations.
      Threshold Voltage (Vth)	Moderate reduction; primarily achieved by minimizing screening charges via ion trapping.	Drastic reduction in driving and threshold voltages due to field amplification via high particle permittivity.
      FT-IR Spectral Signatures	Sharpens terminal stretching bands (2050-2225 cm¹); systematically increases the scalar order parameter S.	Induces localized anchoring deviations; can broaden core vibrational modes at elevated weight percentages.
      UV-Vis Absorbance Profiles	Exhibits sharp wurtzite excitonic band edge (~370 nm); excellent transparency across visible spectrum.	Broad red-shifted band-edge configuration; prone to Rayleigh scattering if cluster mitigation fails.
      POM Textural Morphology	Preserves high-definition schlieren structures; slight upshift in clearing temperature.	Promotes localized homeotropic domains; generates dark pseudoisotropic spots under high load regimes.

5. STATE-OF-THE-ART APPLICATIONS

   1. Electrical and Electro-Optical Modulators

      The development of hybrid NPLC media has led to major advancements in advanced photonics. For high-birefringence nematic systems, the reduction in driving voltages translates directly to lower power consumption for large-area smart glass windows, phase modulators, and adaptive telecommunication switches. Using ZnO-doped formulations allows the fabrication of polymer- dispersed liquid crystal films that require substantially lower clear-to-opaque transition fields [26]. Meanwhile, TiO-doped high- birefringence systems are actively utilized in laser beam steering arrays and optical phase retarders, where minimizing cell thickness is critical.

   2. Optical-Sensing and Photodetectors

      The semiconducting nature of both ZnO and TiO transforms the liquid crystal cell from a passive light modulator into an active, photo-responsive detection platform. Under UV light irradiation, these nanoparticles generate electron-hole pairs, which interact with the terminal polar groups of the high-birefringence host [27]. This photo-induced charge generation alters the local electric field, triggering a visible texture change under POM without requiring an external electrical power supply. This mechanism enables the design of self-powered UV photodetectors and highly sensitive environmental light sensors.

   3. Potential Biomedical-Sensing Frameworks

      Biomedical and interfacial sensing represents a highly active frontier for NPLC applications. Liquid crystals are highly sensitive to surface anchoring perturbations; the introduction of biological analytes (such as proteins or glucose) at the aqueous-LC interface can disrupt long-range nematic ordering, causing a visible change in texture from homeotropic to planar. Incorporating biocompatible ZnO nanoparticles enhances this interfacial sensitivity by providing highly structured, functionalized docking sites for biomolecules [28]. This disruption alters the localized surface anchoring energy, which can be monitored via real-time FT-IR shift profiling or direct POM optical readout, forming a rapid, label-free diagnostic platform.

      Figure 3. Bioreceptors for analyte detection: Architectural structures and key composition features.

6. CRITICAL RESEARCH GAPS AND STRATEGIC PRIORITIES

   Despite significant progress, several fundamental research gaps prevent the widespread industrial adoption of nanoparticle-doped liquid crystals. First, long-term colloidal stability remains a major challenge. Because transition metal oxide nanoparticles possess intense surface energies, they are highly prone to irreversible aggregation over extended thermal cycles, causing fatal optical scattering defects [29-30]. Mitigating this issue requires developing advanced surface functionalization protocolssuch as capping nanoparticles with mesogenic ligands or long-chain alkyl surfactants tailored specifically to mirror the molecular architecture of modern high-birefringence matrices.

   Second, there is an urgent need for standardized, systematic studies that evaluate these systems under identical experimental conditions. A critical strategic priority is the rigorous validation of photogenerated charge transport mechanisms. Future research must systematically isolate the relative contributions of ion trapping versus local electric field enhancement, establishing reliable structure-property relationships that accelerate the design of next-generation soft-matter optoelectronics.

7. CONCLUSIONS

In summary, migrating from traditional liquid crystal hosts like EBCA to advanced high-birefringence nematic matrices represents a major leap forward for nanoparticle-doped soft-matter technologies. Dispersing ZnO and TiO nanoparticles introduces distinct, highly tunable changes in physical properties: ZnO acts as a potent ion scavenger that suppresses parasitic conductivity and optimizes electrical stability, while TiO leverages its high dielectric permittivity to enhance local fields and lower operational driving voltages. Integrating complementary analytical techniquesFT-IR for order parameter mapping, UV-Vis for tracking excitonic absorption, and POM for mapping texture morphologyprovides a powerful framework for optimizing these hybrid materials. Addressing colloidal stability challenges will unlock the full potential of these advanced NPLC systems.

REFERENCES

1. Chen, C., Tan, F., Xu, D., Wang, X., & Yu, H. (2026). Liquid Crystals as Functional Ordered Media for Energy Devices: Bridging Ionics, Electronics, and Photonics. Small Methods, e71065.

2. Raju, K.V.S.N., et al. (2018). Dielectric studies of zinc oxide nanoparticles in liquid crystalline matrices. AIP Conf. Proc., 1953, 090015.

3. Aydn, G., Candan, ., Kocakoç Toprakolu, M., & San, S. E. (2026). Liquid crystal-integrated tunable metamaterials and metasurfaces: from microwave to optical frequencies. Journal of Physics: Photonics, 8(3), 032004.

4. Ding, F., Meng, C., & Bozhevolnyi, S. I. (2024). Electrically tunable optical metasurfaces. Photonics Insights, 3(3), R07.

5. Guardià, J., et al. (2024). An Up-to-Date Overview of Liquid Crystals and Liquid Crystal Polymers for Different Applications. Polymers, 16(15), 2145.

6. Khushboo, A., et al. (2025). Spectroscopic and electro-optical investigations of oxide-doped high anisotropy nematic mixtures. J. Mol. Liq., 412, 125890.

7. Ali, R. F. (2026). All-Dielectric Metasurfaces in Fundamentals, Materials, and Emerging Applications.

8. Li, Z., Li, Z., Zuo, C., & Fang, X. (2022). Application of nanostructured TiO2 in UV photodetectors: a review. Advanced Materials, 34(28), 2109083.

9. Zhou, W., Jing, Q., Li, J., Chen, Y., Hao, G., & Wang, L. N. (2023). Organic photocatalysts for solar water splitting: Molecular- and aggregate-level modifications. Acta Phys.-Chim. Sin, 39, 2211010.

10. Shi, T., Wang, J., Li, Z., Yang, Z., Xiang, H., Wang, Y., … & Kang, Z. (2025). Cyano groups and oxygen adsorption dominated efficient hydrogen and hydrogen peroxide co-production on metal-free photocatalysts. Applied Catalysis B: Environment and Energy, 125914.

11. Mane, V. A., Dake, D. V., Raskar, N. D., Sonpir, R. B., Chavan, K. M., Munde, S. S., … & Dole, B. N. (2026). MetalOrganic Frameworks as Advanced Photoelectrodes for Photoelectrochemical Water Splitting: Design, Mechanisms, and Challenges. Energy & Fuels, 40(17), 9204-9237.

12. Matin Ahmadi, S. M., Taghiloo, A., Asgharinezhad, A. A., & Larimi, A. (2026). Next-Generation Photocatalysts for Hydrogen Production: Innovations, Challenges, and Future Perspectives. Energy & Fuels, 40(21), 11174-11212.

13. Cao, H., Yang, E., Kim, Y., Zhao, Y., & Ma, W. (2024). Biomimetic chiral nanomaterials with selective catalysis activity. Advanced Science, 11(23), 2306979.

14. Eftekhari, K., Parakhonskiy, B. V., Grigoriev, D., & Skirtach, A. G. (2024). Advances in nanoarchitectonics: A review of “static” and “dynamic” particle assembly methods. Materials, 17(5), 1051.

15. Wodarska, M., & Mossety-Leszczak, B. (2021). DFT studies of selected epoxies with mesogenic unitsimpact of molecular structure on electro-optical response. International Journal of Molecular Sciences, 22(7), 3424.

16. Bappy, N. F., & Subramani, S. (2026). Structural, morphological, optical, and thermal properties of Mg-doped ZnO thin film nanostructures on Al substrates as thin film heat spreader for thermal management applications. Materials Science and Engineering: B, 323, 118898.

17. Kumar, P. (2025). Analysis on nanoparticles induced alignment stability of dye doped liquid crystal at varying temperatures. Optik, 172536.

18. Chinky, Sharma, V., Malik, P., & Kumar, P. (2026). Thermal Stability of Homeotropic Alignment of Liquid Crystals Induced by Nanoparticles for Display Applications: Chinky, Sharma, Malik, and Kumar. Journal of Electronic Materials, 55(3), 3077-3084.

19. Rastogi, A., Mishra, A., Pandey, F. P., Manohar, R., & Parmar, A. S. (2023). Enhancing physical characteristics of thermotropic nematic liquid crystals by dispersing in various nanoparticles and their potential applications. Emergent Materials, 6(1), 101-136.

20. Wong, J. (2024). Liquid Crystalline Behaviour of Semi-Flexible Polymer-Coated Nanoparticles. McGill University (Canada).

21. Pattar, J., Shyagathur, S. C., & Rao, A. H. N. (2025). Tuning the dielectric and photocatalytic properties of MgO nanomaterials through Mn doping: A Comprehensive study. Ceramics International, 51(10), 13374-13382.

22. Hwang, Gukhwa, and Donghyun Kim. “Transport and retention of positively charged zinc oxide nanoparticles in saturated porous media: effects of metal oxides and clays.” Environmental Pollution 351 (2024): 124007.

23. Yang, X., Sun, S., Ye, L., Yun, D., Liu, C., Guo, Y., … & Cui, J. (2022). One-pot integration of S-doped BiOCl and ZnO into type-II photocatalysts: simultaneously boosting bulk and surface charge separation for enhanced antibiotic removal. Separation and Purification Technology, 299, 121725

24. Caimi, F. (2023). Electro-Optical and Electro-Mechanical Response of Ferroelectric Nematic Fluids.

25. Xi, Z. (2025). Revisiting the Marcus inverted regime: modulation strategies for photogenerated ultrafast carrier transfer from semiconducting quantum dots to metal oxides. RSC advances, 15(33), 26897-26918.

26. Chou Chau, Y. F. (2025). Nanophotonic materials and devices: Recent advances and emerging applications. Micromachines, 16(8), 933.

27. Zhang, L., Liu, J., Xiong, Y., Liao, G., & Lv, Y. (2025, December). Multi-energy integrated photocatalysis for antitumor therapy. In Exploration (Vol. 5, No. 6, p. 20240188).

28. Shaheen, A., Anwar, N., Chen, F., Chan, Y., Xie, H., & Lee, S. L. (2025). Materials interface engineering: impact of interfacial molecular orientation on organic electronic devices. Advanced Functional Materials, 35(47), 2505173.

29. Kashif, M., Gul, M., Shahzad, N., Sun, H., Shezan, S. A., Ahmad, N., … & Tozan, H. (2026). Metal oxide nanoparticles: A comprehensive review of recent advances in synthesis strategies, characterization and multifunctional applications. Catalysts, 16(8), 678.

30. Elhassan, M., & Sathyamurthy, R. (2025). Impact of surface coating on freshwater generation from solar stills: a comprehensive review. Discover Applied Sciences, 7(6), 642