DOI : 10.17577/IJERTCONV14IS120043- Open Access

- Authors : Pratik Salunkhe, Prof. Shrirang Sajanapwar, Dr. Sanjay Asati
- Paper ID : IJERTCONV14IS120043
- Volume & Issue : Volume 14, Issue 12, UCBO – 2026
- Published (First Online) : 21-11-2026
- ISSN (Online) : 2278-0181
- Publisher Name : IJERT
- License:
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License
Lean Six Sigma Implementation for Reducing Defects and Improving Productivity on the Cross Car Beam W610 Product Line: An On-the-Job Training Study at Belrise Industries Pvt. Ltd., Chakan, Pune
Pratik Salunkhe
Student, MBA- Operations and Supply Chain Management,
School of Business, Indira University,
Pune, India 41103 pragalbhasarve@gmail.com
Prof. Shrirang Sajanapwar
Professor of Practice MBA, School of Business, Indira University,
Pune, India 411033 shrirang.sajanpwar@indirauniversity.ed u.in
Dr. Sanjay Asati
Assistant Professor, School of Business, Indira University,
Pune, India 411033 Sanjay.asati@indirauniversity.edu.in
Abstract – Tier 1 automotive component suppliers operate under sustained OEM pressure for near-zero-defect delivery, and rework that is absorbed inside the process quietly erodes yield, capacity and cost. Contemporary literature positions Lean Manufacturing, Six Sigma and the DMAIC cycle as complementary approaches for exposing such hidden losses. This applied industrial study examined the Cross Car Beam (CCB) Assembly Line W610 at Plant B-39, Chakan, Pune, of Belrise Industries Pvt. Ltd., a line that integrates eight robotic welding cells, an AutoGauge station and a Firewall rework station. The primary objectives were to establish a quantitative First Time Yield (FTY) baseline, prioritise defect categories, assess error- proofing health through a Poka-Yoke audit, identify the cycle-time bottleneck, diagnose root causes, estimate the Cost of Poor Quality (CoPQ) and develop a DMAIC-based corrective-action and control plan. Conducted during an on-the-job training (OJT) assignment from 15 May to 15 July 2026, the methodology combined shop-floor observation, discussions with Quality, Production Engineering and Maintenance personnel, and analysis of daily FTY tally sheets (2,385 parts over 24 working days of May 2026), the Firewall rework register (46 events in 17 categories), stopwatch cycle-time observations and a 95- checkpoint Poka-Yoke audit.
Of the 2,385 parts inspected, 926 passed first time and 1,459 were not OK, giving a pooled FTY of 38.83% against a target of at least 95%. Pooled FTY was 54.17% over the 13 working days to 19 May but fell to 14.44% over the 11 working days from 21 May, a collapse the plant attributed to a gauge calibration failure. Four of 17 defect categories accounted for 56.52% of rework events, and Shift B contributed 26 of 46 events (56.5%). The Poka-Yoke audit
recorded 87.1% compliance, with 8 of 62 applicable checkpoints non-functional and 5 of them in Robotic Cell 2 (68.8% compliance). Robotic cell R3-A ran at 193 seconds
against a line average of 174 seconds, driven by a 117-second welding phase. Estimated CoPQ was approximately 8.78 lakh per month. In conclusion, line performance is constrained by error-proofing reliability, gauge calibration discipline, weld-process stability and shift-level capability rather than by a single dominant defect. A ten-action corrective plan was developed; the gauge Standard Operating Procedure (SOP) and pre-shift checklist were completed during the OJT, while the remaining actions are proposals. It is recommended that management restore and interlock all Poka-Yoke sensors, enforce gauge calibration control, retrain Shift B on the leading defect categories, optimise the R3-A weld programme and institutionalise a daily FTY dashboard.
Keywords – Lean Six Sigma, DMAIC, First Time Yield, Poka-Yoke, Pareto Analysis, Cross Car Beam, Automotive Manufacturing
-
INTRODUCTION
The Indian automotive sector contributes approximately 7.1% of the national gross domestic product and about 49% of manufacturing GDP, and the auto-component industry was valued at roughly USD 69.7 billion in FY2023 [1], [2]. Within this ecosystem, Tier 1 suppliers deliver complete systems and modules directly to vehicle manufacturers and are expected to hold quality-management certification such as IATF 16949 [12]. One such module is the Cross Car Beam (CCB), a structural member that spans the cabin between the A-pillars and carries the dashboard, steering column, HVAC unit and airbag modules. Because the CCB is safety-relevant and is welded from many small brackets, dimensional accuracy, weld position and the presence of every nut and locator pin are critical to quality.
Belrise Industries Pvt. Ltd. is a Tier 1 automotive component manufacturer supplying OEMs including Maruti Suzuki, Tata Motors, Mahindra, Bajaj and Honda. At Plant B-39, Chakan, Pune, CCB Assembly Line W610 combines 24 sub-operations spanning sub-assembly, eight robotic welding cells (R1-A to R4-
B), an AutoGauge inspection station and a Firewall rework station. Despite this structure, the lines First Time Yield records show that most parts do not pass first time: during May 2026, Shift A inspected 2,385 parts, of which 926 passed without rework and 1,459 were recorded as not OK, against an FTY target of at least 95%. Rework of this scale forms a hidden factory that consumes labour, inspection time and capacity without appearing in final-yield figures.
To address this problem, this study presents an applied Lean Six Sigma investigation of Line W610 using the DMAIC framework in three stages. First, a quantitative baseline was established from daily FTY records, the Firewall rework register, a robotic-cell cycle-time study and a Poka-Yoke audit. Second, the data were analysed through Pareto analysis, shift stratification, SPC interpretation and a 4M cause-and-effect analysis to identify the dominant sources of loss. Third, the findings were converted into a ten-action corrective plan, projected targets and a control framework. As the authors role during the OJT was diagnostic and advisory, implementation ownership remained with the plants Quality, Maintenance, Production Engineering and HR functions.
-
LITERATURE REVIEW AND THEORETICAL BACKGROUND
-
Literature Review
Womack et al. [3] introduced Lean Production by examining the Toyota Production System, arguing that performance improves when activities that add no value are systematically removed, and Womack and Jones [4] later distilled Lean into the principles of value, value stream, flow, pull and perfection. Harry and Schroeder [5] presented Six Sigma as a data-driven management strategy for reducing process variation and defects, while Antony et al. [6] documented a Six Sigma case study in manufacturing quality improvement and drew guidance for managers from it. Shingo [7] contributed the Poka-Yoke concept of source inspection and mistake-proofing, Ishikawa [9] introduced the cause-and-effect diagram for structured root- cause analysis, and Montgomery [8] provides the statistical basis for control charts, including attribute charts suited to pass/fail data. Imai [10] framed continuous improvement as Kaizen, and Liker [11] described the Toyota practice of stopping to fix problems at source. IATF 16949 [12] embeds several of these tools, including SPC, FMEA and measurement system analysis, in automotive quality-system requirements. These sources are largely foundational and conceptual; this study applies them jointly, through FTY measurement, Pareto prioritisation, Poka- Yoke auditing and cycle-time analysis, on a live robotic welding and assembly line.
-
Theoretical Background
This study combines Lean waste elimination with Six Sigma variation reduction. Lean classifies non-value-adding activity into eight wastes (TIMWOODS): Transportation, Inventory, Motion, Waiting, Over-production, Over-processing, Defects and Skills under-utilisation [3], [4]. On Line W610 the dominant wasts are Defects, visible as rework, and Waiting, visible as downstream idle time behind the slowest welding cell. Six Sigma contributes the DMAIC cycle (Define, Measure, Analyse, Improve, Control), which structures the project from problem definition through to a sustaining control plan [5], [6].
The primary performance metric is First Time Yield, defined as the number of units passing a process step without rework,
scrap or repair divided by the number of units entering that step, expressed as a percentage. FTY is preferred to final yield because it exposes the hidden factory: a process can ship every part and still consume significant labour and capacity in rework. Error-proofing is assessed through Poka-Yoke, which either prevents a defect (prevention type) or detects it immediately (detection type), using contact, fixed-value or motion-sequence methods [7]. A non-functional detection sensor therefore allows defects to pass undetected. Process stability is interpreted with Statistical Process Control, which separates common-cause variation, inherent to the process, from special-cause variation that demands investigation; a p-chart monitors the proportion of non-conforming units directly [8]. Root causes are organised with the Ishikawa diagram on the 4M basis (Man, Machine, Material, Method) [9], and defects are prioritised with Pareto analysis, one of the seven basic quality-control tools. Finally, Cost of Poor Quality expresses internal failure costs such as rework labour, re-inspection and lost capacity in monetary terms.
-
-
MATERIALS AND METHODS
-
Research Objectives
This study evaluates quality and productivity losses on CCB Assembly Line W610 at Belrise Industries to achieve six core objectives: (1) establish a quantitative baseline of FTY and defect incidence from the daily records of May 2026; (2) identify and prioritise the major defect categories through Pareto analysis and shift stratification; (3) assess error-proofing health through an audit of 95 Poka-Yoke checkpoints; (4) perform a cycle-time study across the eight robotic welding cells to locate the bottleneck; (5) diagnose root causes through 4M cause-and- effect analysis and SPC interpretation, and estimate the CoPQ; and (6) develop a DMAIC-based corrective-action plan with targets and a control framework.
-
Research Design and Data Collection
An applied, descriptive-diagnostic, non-experimental industrial case study was carried out during an OJT assignment (15 May to 15 July 2026). In the Define phase a project charter and a SIPOC (SuppliersInputsProcessOutputsCustomers) map of the line were prepared. In the Measure phase, quantitative data were drawn from plant records [13]: daily FTY tally sheets from the Shift A log books (2,385 parts over 24 working days of May 2026); the Firewall rework register covering all available shifts (46 rework events across 17 defect categories); direct stopwatch measurement of loading, welding and unloading times in all eight robotic cells (five observations per cell per phase); and a Poka-Yoke audit checklist completed with the maintenance team for 95 checkpoints. Qualitative data came from floor observation and discussions with operators and shift supervisors. Secondary material included monthly quality reports, gauge calibration records and IATF audit reports. All data were cross-checked against the W610 shop-floor records held by the Quality Supervisor. The Analyse, Improve and Control phases are reported in the following sections.
-
Analytical Framework and Limitations
Data were tabulated and analysed in Microsoft Excel using descriptive statistics, Pareto analysis, shift stratification, cycle- time comparison against the line average and p-chart interpretation. Wastes were classified with the TIMWOODS framework, and root causes were analysed with an Ishikawa diagram on the 4M basis. The study has limitations: detailed
FTY was available only for Shift A, with Shifts B and C represented by rework-event counts; FTY is recorded in parts whereas the rework register counts events, so the two datasets cannot be reconciled directly; only one month of data was analysed, which cannot capture seasonal or model-change effects; the SPC interpretation relies on binary pass/fail data rather than raw measurements; the Poka-Yoke audit reports no checkpoints for Robotic Cell 4; CoPQ rests on assumed labour and capacity rates; and, as the authors role was advisory, implementation decisions rest with plant management.
-
-
DATA ANALYSIS AND DISCUSSION
Document the Production Process Through SIPOC Mapping
TABLE I.
rocess Map of CCB Assembly Line W610 and Poka-Yoke Audit Coverage
Process Segment
Cells / Stations
Output
PY Points Audited
Sub- assembly
Tunnel Bkt,
IP Bkt, End Bkts
CCB sub- assembly
Not itemised
Robotic Welding Cell 1
R1-A, R1-B
Welded CCB frame
43
Robotic Welding Cell 2
R2-A, R2-B
Intermediate assembly
24
Robotic Welding Cell 3
R3-A, R3-B
Welded assembly
26
Robotic Welding Cell
4
R4-A, R4-B
Complete CCB
Not reported
AutoGauge and Firewall
Rework
AutoGauge; Firewall
station
OK /
rework- tagged CCB
2
(AutoGauge)
Table 1 summarises the SIPOC map of Line W610. Steel, fastener, coated and in-house stamped inputs feed a sub- assembly stage (Tunnel Bracket, IP Bracket and End Brackets), after which the CCB passes through four robotic welding stations, each with an A and a B cell, before AutoGauge inspection and the Firewall rework station, where parts are tagged OK or for rework. The finished CCB is supplied to Maruti Suzuki platforms. The Firewall register is therefore the single point at which defects are recorded by category, which is why it underpins the Pareto and shift analyses below. The audited Poka-Yoke checkpoints total 95 (43 + 24 + 26 + 2), and the audit does not itemise checkpoints for Robotic Cell 4, a coverage gap that should be closed in the next audit.
Establish the Baseline First Time Yield
TABLE II.
aseline Quality Performance of Shift A, May 2026
Metric
Value
Working days observed
24
Parts inspected
2,385
Parts OK first time
926
Parts not OK
1,459
Pooled FTY (926 ÷ 2,385)*
38.83%
Mean of daily FTY*
36.77%
Not-OK rate P
61.17%
Best daily FTY
83.33% (09 May)
Worst daily FTY
3.75% (23 May)
Days meeting target
0 of 24
Target FTY
95%
*The OJT working report states a headline FTY of 28.47%. Recomputation from the daily totals gives 38.83% (pooled) and 36.77% (mean of daily values); the recomputed figures are used here pending reconciliation with plant records.
FTY Before and After the 21 May Gauge Calibration Failure
Parameter
0219 May
2131 May
Working days
13
11
Parts inspected
1,464
/td>
921
Parts OK
793
133
Parts not OK
671
788
Average parts per day
~113
~84
Pooled FTY
54.17%
14.44%
Lowest daily FTY
34.72%
3.75%
Highest daily FTY
83.33%
35.00%
Tables 2 and 3 show that FTY is the primary quality gap. Of 24 working days, none reached the 95% target, and the best day (83.33% on 9 May) still fell short. Splitting the series at 21 May shows a sharp structural break: pooled FTY fell from 54.17% to 14.44%, a drop of 39.7 percentage points, while average daily inspection volume fell by about 26%. Interpreting the series as a p-chart on the not-OK fraction, with a pooled centre line of 0.612 and day-specific three-sigma limits (recomputed for this paper from the daily data), 17 of 24 days fall outside the limits: the seven days below the lower limit all precede 21 May, and 10 of the 11 days from 21 May exceed the upper limit, with 27 May the only exception. This pattern is a classic special-cause signal, consistent with the plants finding that a gauge calibration failure was responsible, and the appropriate response was gauge withdrawal and recalibration rather than process overhaul. However, FTY before the failure was still 54.17%, about 41 points below target, so the gauge failure aggravated an already chronic problem rather than creating it.
Prioritise Defects Using Pareto Analysis
Pareto Analysis of Firewall Rework Events (46 Events, 17 Categories)
Rank
Defect Type
Events
Share
Cum. %
1
BIW M8 Nut
Weld Shift / Missing
9
19.57%
19.57%
2
Tunnel Bkt Welding Shift / Mismatch
7
15.22%
34.78%
3
IP Bkt Broken / Shift
5
10.87%
45.65%
4
Channel Support Defects
5
10.87%
56.52%
5
HVAC Weld Shift
3
6.52%
63.04%
6
End Bkt Locater Pin Weld Miss
3
6.52%
69.57%
7
Fuse Box Welding Shift
2
4.35%
73.91%
8
Steering M8 Nut Missing
2
4.35%
78.26%
917
Other 9 defect types
10
21.74%
100.00%
Total
46
100%
Table 4 confirms a concentrated defect profile. The top four categories (BIW M8 Nut Weld Shift/Missing, Tunnel Bracket Welding Shift/Mismatch, IP Bracket Broken/Shift and Channel Support Defects) account for 56.52% of the 46 rework events, and the top eight account for 78.26%, which supports a vital- few strategy in which resources are directed first at the leading categories. Notably, six of the eight leading categories (BIW M8 nut, Tunnel Bracket, HVAC, End Bracket locator pin, Fuse Box and Steering M8 nut) describe weld-position, missing-weld or missing-nut defects, totalling 26 events (56.5%). These are the failure modes that the lines Poka-Yoke sensors are meant to detect, which suggests, although the data do not prove, a link between non-functional sensors and the defects that escape to the Firewall station.
Stratify Rework by Shift
Shift-wise Rework Stratification
Shift
Rework Events
Share
Data Available
Shift A
7
15.2%
Daily FTY tally (2,385 parts)
Shift B
26
56.5%
Rework count only
Shift C
13
28.3%
Rework count only
Total
46
100%
Table 5 identifies Shift B as the largest contributor, with 26 of 46 rework events (56.5%), which is 3.7 times the count of Shift A and twice that of Shift C. An equal split across three shifts would be about 33%. The shift-level pattern is consistent with the fishbone finding that Shift B suffers absenteeism and replacement by less-trained operators. Two cautions apply: the counts are not normalised by shift output, so part of Shift Bs share could reflect volume, and Shift A holds the only FTY
series, so a full shift-wise FTY comparison remains outstanding.
Identify the Cycle-Time Bottleneck
Robotic Cell Cycle-Time Study (Seconds, Stopwatch Observations)
Cell
Load
Weld
Unload
Total
vs Average
R1-A
78
82
16
176
+2 s
R1-B
80
79
29
188
+14 s
R2-A
66
102
17
185
+11 s
R2-B
61
98
10
169
5 s
R3-A
52
117
24
193
+19 s
R3-B
71
76
16
163
11 s
R4-A
52
112
11
175
+1 s
R4-B
74
56
16
146
28 s
Average
67
90
17
174
Baseline
Table 6 shows that R3-A is the bottleneck at 193 seconds, 19 seconds (about 11%) above the 174-second line average and 47 seconds slower than the fastest cell, R4-B (146 seconds). The phase breakdown locates the cause: R3-As welding phase of
117 seconds is 27 seconds above the 90-second average, whereas its loading time of 52 seconds is among the shortest. The delay is therefore in the weld programme and robot motion rather than in material handling, which supports reviewing the weld programme and loading/unloading balance before adding capacity. R1-B (188 s, rated High) and R2-A (185 s, rated High) form a second tier, and the 29-second unloading time of R1-B is well above the 17-second average. The project estimated the resulting lost capacity at about 1.85 lakh per month.
Audit Poka-Yoke Error-Proofing Health Poka-Yoke Audit Summary by Station
Station
Total
OK
Failed
N/A
Compliance
Robotic Cell 1
43
31
1
11
96.9%
Robotic Cell 2
24
11
5
8
68.8%
Robotic Cell 3
26
10
2
14
83.3%
AutoGauge Station
2
2
0
0
100.0%
Total W610
95
54
8
33
87.1%
OK = functional; Failed = not working. Compliance = OK ÷ (OK + Failed); N/A checkpoints are excluded.
Table 7 shows overall Poka-Yoke compliance of 87.1%, with 8 of 62 applicable checkpoints non-functional (overall risk rated Medium in the audit). Robotic Cell 2 is the weakest station and the only one rated High risk: it holds 5 of the 8 failures (62.5%), and 31% of its applicable checkpoints are not working, giving the lowest compliance (68.8%). Each non-functional sensor is a point at which a defect can pass undetected, and the line has no PLC-level interlock to stop operation when error-proofing is unavailable. A further observation is that 33 of 95 checkpoints
(34.7%) were marked N/A, including 14 of 26 in Robotic Cell 3, and that Cell 4 is absent from the audit; these classifications should be validated so that unavailable error-proofing is not hidden inside the N/A category.
Classify Wastes Using the TIMWOODS Framework TIMWOODS Waste Classification and Shop-Floor Evidence
Waste
Observed Manifestation
Plant Evidence
(May 2026)
Process Location
Defects
Parts failing first-time inspection and requiring
rework
1,459 of 2,385
parts not OK;
46 rework events
AutoGauge; Firewall rework station
Waiting
Downstream idle time
behind the slowest cell
R3-A at 193 s against a 174 s average
Robotic Cell 3 (R3- A)
Over- processing
Re- inspection, repeat rework and gauge re- testing
1,459 parts re- inspected at
15 min each;
~100 parts a day re-tested for 10 days
after 21 May
Firewall station; AutoGauge
Skills under- utilisation
Untrained operators at critical stations; less- trained
replacements
Shift B: 26 of
46 rework events (56.5%)
Critical welding and assembly stations
Others
Transport, Inventory, Motion and Over- production
not assessed
No data collected
Table 8 shows that Defects and Waiting dominate the observed waste on Line W610, with Over-processing as a direct consequence of rework and re-inspection. The re-inspection and gauge re-testing figures are assumptions used in the CoPQ estimate rather than measured values. Transport, Inventory, Motion and Over-production were outside the data collected, so no conclusion is drawn on them.
Diagnose Root Causes Using Cause-and-Effect Analysis Cause-and-Effect Matrix (4M Framework) for Recurring Defects PART-1
4M
Root-Cause Analysis
Root Cause Identified
Supporting Evidence
Man
Untrained operators at critical stations
Shift B: 26 of 46
rework events (56.5%)
Man
Shift B absenteeism
and replacement by less-trained operators
Shift B share against a
33% equal-load benchmark
Machine
Eight non-functional Poka-Yoke sensors,
concentrated in Robotic Cell 2
87.1% compliance;
Cell 2 at 68.8%
4M
Root-Cause Analysis
Root Cause Identified
Supporting Evidence
Machine
R3-A weld cycle
exceeds the line average
193 s against 174 s;
welding 117 s against 90 s
Machine
No PLC-level interlock for critical Poka-Yoke sensors
Noted during the audit
Method
Gauge inspection not consistently
mandatory; gauge calibration failure
Pooled FTY 54.17%
to 14.44% from 21 May
Method
Pre-shift fixture
checkpoints not documented
Weld-position defects
in six of the top eight categories
Material
BIW bracket variation beyond stated tolerance
Related category: BIW M8 nut weld
shift / missing (9 events)
Material
Tunnel Bracket
supplier change and qualification activity
Tunnel Bkt welding
shift / mismatch (7 events)
Cause-and-Effect Matrix (4M Framework) for Recurring Defects PART-2
4M
Root-Cause Analysis
Operational Impact
Recommended Countermeasure
Man
Defects escape at critical stations
Shift B supervisor training and standard- work audit (Action 5)
Man
Capability gaps during absenteeism
Multi-skilling programme and
absenteeism buffer plan (Action 8)
Machine
Defects can pass undetected
Restore all eight sensors; recommission PY at BIW M8 nut station
(Actions 1, 3)
Machine
Bottleneck and lost capacity
Weld programme
optimisation at R3-A (Action 6)
Machine
Operation continues
without error- proofing
PLC interlock for critical sensors (Action 1)
Method
Special-cause FTY
collapse and re- testing
Gauge SOP and pre-shift
checklist (Action 2, completed)
Method
Undetected fixture drift
Fixture check at Tunnel Bracket station; daily
FTY dashboard (Actions 4, 7)
Material
Weld-position and nut defects
Weld audit at BIW M8 nut station (Action 3)
Material
Mismatch rework
Incoming Tunnel
Bracket supplier qualification (Action 9)
Table 9 (Parts 1 and 2) points to four interconnected root causes: unreliable error-proofing, weak gauge-calibration discipline, a slow weld programme at R3-A, and capability gaps
concentrated in Shift B. The causes are mutually reinforcing: a non-functional sensor removes the defect-detection barrier, an uncalibrated gauge removes the inspection barrier, and untrained replacement operators increase the rate at which defects are created. The material causes, bracket variation and a supplier change, are supported by observation but not yet by incoming-inspection data.
Estimate the Cost of Poor Quality Estimated Monthly Cost of Poor Quality
CoPQ
Category
Basis
Cost ()
Share
Internal
rework labour
46 events × 2.5 h ×
150/h × 26 days
4,49,500*
51.2%
Re- inspection
1,459 parts × 15 min ×
120/h
43,770
5.0%
Lost capacity
(R3-A)
19 s/unit × 2,385 units
× capacity rate
1,85,000
21.1%
Gauge failure impact (post 21
May)
10 days × ~100 parts re-tested × 200
2,00,000
22.8%
Total
8,78,270
100%
*s stated in the OJT report; the printed formula evaluates to
4,48,500 (total 8,77,270). The basis multiplies the 46 recorded events by 26 days; if the 46 events are a monthly rather than a daily count, this category would be substantially lower. Labour and capacity rates are assumed, so the figures should be validated against ERP data.
Table 11 puts the estimated CoPQ at about 8.78 lakh per month. Internal rework labour is the largest component (about 51%), and the single gauge-calibration failure accounts for a further 22.8%, showing that one special cause can cost almost as much as the lost capacity at the bottleneck and the re- inspection effort combined. Because the estimate rests on assumed rates and an unverified event basis, it is a decision- support figure rather than an audited financial value.
Develop the DMAIC Corrective Action Plan Corrective and Preventive Action Plan PART-1
Corrective Action
Root Cause
Priority
1. Restore 8 non-functional PY sensors; add PLC interlock
Machine
High
2. Gauge SOP and pre-shift gauge inspection checklist
Method
High
3. Weld audit and PY
recommissioning at BIW M8 nut station
Machine
High
4. Fixture check at Tunnel Bracket station
Machine
High
5. Shift B supervisor training and standard-work audit
Man
High
6. Optimise R3-A weld programme (bottleneck)
Machine
Medium
Corrective Action
Root Cause
Priority
7. Daily FTY dashboard as mandatory Shift A KPI
Method
High
8. Multi-skilling programme and absenteeism buffer plan
Man
Medium
9. Incoming Tunnel Bracket supplier qualification
Material
Medium
10. Rework-threshold alert system (real-time containment)
Method
Low
Corrective and Preventive Action Plan PART-2
Action
Owner
Target
Status
1. PY sensors
and PLC interlock
QA Manager + Maintenance
Jun-26
In Progress
2. Gauge SOP and checklist
QA Supervisor
Jun-26
Completed
3. BIW M8 nut weld audit
Production Engineer
Jul-26
Open
4. Tunnel
Bracket fixture check
QA Supervisor
Jul-26
Open
5. Shift B training
QA Manager
Jul-26
Open
6. R3-A weld programme
Process Engineer
Aug-26
Planned
7. Daily FTY dashboard
QA Manager
Ongoing
In Progress
8. Multi- skilling
programme
HR + Production Manager
Aug-26
Planned
9. Tunnel Bracket
supplier
SQA Engineer
Sep-26
Planned
10. Rework alert system
QA Manager
Oct-26
Planned
Status as recorded in the OJT working report; to be updated against current plant records.
Projected Improvement Targets (Proposals, Not Achieved Results)
Metric
Current (May 2026)
6-Month Target
12-Month Target
First Time Yield (pooled)
38.83%
6065%
8085%
Monthly rework events
46
< 20
< 10
PY sensor compliance
87.1%
100%
100% + PLC
interlock
R3-A cycle time
193 s
180 s
174 s
Monthly CoPQ saving
45 lakh
78 lakh
Shift B rework share
56.5%
< 40%
< 33%
Tables 12 to 14 outline a low-capital improvement roadmap arranged by priority. The high-priority actions address the defect-detection and inspection barriers first: sensor restoration with an interlock, the gauge SOP and the weld audit at the BIW M8 nut station, which together target the leading Pareto
category and the special cause behind the late-May collapse. Of the ten actions, only the gauge SOP and pre-shift checklist are recorded as completed. Sustaining control rests on a daily FTY dashboard, a Poka-Yoke audit checklist, weekly R3-A cycle- time review, a daily rework register and scheduled gauge calibration, each with a named owner and reaction plan. The targets in Table 14 are proposals; actual benefits must be verified through post-implementation baselines and sustained control-chart evidence.
-
FINDINGS, CONCLUSIONS AND SUGGESTIONS
-
Findings
The investigation of CCB Assembly Line W610 at Belrise Industries produced the following findings. Of 2,385 parts inspected over 24 working days of May 2026, 926 passed first time and 1,459 were not OK, giving a pooled FTY of 38.83% against a target of at least 95%; no day met the target. FTY fell from 54.17% (13 days to 19 May) to 14.44% (11 days from 21 May), a special-cause pattern attributed to a gauge calibration failure, although pre-failure FTY was itself about 41 points below target. Four of 17 defect categories accounted for 56.52% of the 46 rework events, led by BIW M8 Nut Weld Shift/Missing (9 events) and Tunnel Bracket Welding Shift/Mismatch (7 events), and six of the eight leading categories were weld-position or missing-nut defects. Shift B contributed 26 events (56.5%). The Poka-Yoke audit found 87.1% compliance, with 8 of 62 applicable checkpoints non-
functional, 5 of them in Robotic Cell 2 (68.8%), and 33 of 95 checkpoints classified as N/A. Robotic cell R3-A was the bottleneck at 193 seconds against a 174-second average, driven by a 117-second welding phase. Estimated CoPQ was approximately 8.78 lakh per month, subject to validation. Of ten corrective actions, the gauge SOP and pre-shift checklist were completed during the OJT.
-
Conclusions
This study achieved its stated objectives. A quantified baseline, a Pareto-based defect hierarchy, a shift stratification, a cycle- time study, a Poka-Yoke audit, a 4M root-cause analysis and a CoPQ estimate together give a coherent picture of quality and productivity losses on Line W610. The analysis indicates that performance is constrained less by one dominant defect than by the reliability of the barriers that should prevent and detect defects: error-proofing sensors, gauge calibration, standard work and operator capability, together with a slow weld programme at R3-A. A single calibration failure proved as damaging as chronic process problems, which makes calibration control a critical special-cause response. By restoring and interlocking error-proofing, enforcing gauge discipline, retraining Shift B, optimising the R3-A weld programme and tracking FTY daily, the plant can reduce rework, recover capacity and build a foundation for sustained improvement. The conclusios are those of an applied OJT diagnostic study rather than a validated long-term Six Sigma implementation, and any post-OJT improvement claim should be supported by fresh production data and control-chart evidence.
-
Suggestions
To achieve tangible improvement across all stakeholders, the plant should execute a phased, collaborative roadmap:
For Quality and Plant Management: Restore all eight non- functional Poka-Yoke sensors, add a PLC-level interlock for critical sensors, maintain the Gauge Inspection SOP and pre- shift checklist as a mandatory control, and deploy the daily FTY dashboard as a visual management KPI.
For Production Engineering and Maintenance: Audit the weld process and recommission Poka-Yoke at the BIW M8 nut station, introduce documented fixture checks at the Tunnel Bracket station, and optimise the R3-A weld programme and robot motion toward the line average.
For HR and Production Supervisors: Deliver targeted Shift B refresher training on the four leading defect categories using physical defect samples, and build a multi-skilling matrix with minimum qualified coverage at each critical station.
For Supplier Quality: Complete incoming-quality qualification of the new Tunnel Bracket supplier through the appropriate PPAP process, and verify bracket dimensions against tolerance.
-
Implications of the study
The implications of this study provide strategic and operational benefits across all primary stakeholders:
-
Plant Management: Restoring error-proofing and stabilising FTY protects capacity that is otherwise consumed by rework, and supports the zero-defect expectations of OEM customers.
-
Shop-Floor Operators: Standard work, a pre-shift gauge checklist and targeted training reduce dependence on individual experience and make the work easier for replacement personnel.
-
Quality and Maintenance Teams: Register-level data, the Pareto hierarchy and the Poka-Yoke audit give a factual basis for prioritising repairs and tracking whether corrective actions reduce recurring defects.
-
Other Lines and Plants: The audit and dashboard formats can be replicated on other CCB and structural- assembly lines once validated on W610.
-
-
Future Scope of the study
The baseline established in this research opens several avenues for future inquiry:
Extended Baseline and Shift-wise FTY: Collecting at least three months of FTY and dimensional data for all three shifts would permit stronger SPC and capability analysis and a full shift-wise comparison.
Measurement System Analysis: Gauge R&R studies for the critical gauges would quantify measurement-system contribution to the observed variation.
Validated Cost Model: Quantifying CoPQ from ERP and validated labour and capacity rates would replace the assumed rates used in this study and confirm the return on the proposed actions.
Post-Implementation Verification: Comparing FTY, rework events and Poka-Yoke compliance after implementation, with
control-chart evidence, would test whether the projected targets are achievable and sustained.
ACKNOWLEDGMENT
I express my sincere gratitude to Prof. Shrirang Sajanapwar, School of Business, Indira University, for his valuable guidance and encouragement, and to the industry mentor and the Quality, Production Engineering and Maintenance teams at Belrise Industries Pvt. Ltd., Plant B-39, Chakan, Pune, for their operational inputs and support during the study of CCB Assembly Line W610. I am also thankful to all those who, directly or indirectly, helped in completing this research study.
REFERENCES
-
Automotive Component Manufacturers Association of India, Annual report 202324: Indian auto component industry performance, ACMA, New Delhi, India, 2024.
-
Society of Indian Automobile Manufacturers, Automobile domestic sales statistics FY202324, SIAM, New Delhi, India, 2024.
-
J. P. Womack, D. T. Jones, and D. Roos, The Machine That Changed the World: The Story of Lean Production. New York, NY, USA: Rawson Associates, 1990.
-
J. P. Womack and D. T. Jones, Lean Thinking: Banish Waste and Create Wealth in Your Corporation. New York, NY, USA: Simon & Schuster, 1996.
-
M. Harry and R. Schroeder, Six Sigma: The Breakthrough Management Strategy Revolutionizing the Worlds Top Corporations. New York, NY, USA: Doubleday, 2000.
-
J. Antony, E. V. Gijo, and S. J. Childe, Case study in Six Sigma methodology: Manufacturing quality improvement and guidance for managers, Production Planning & Control, vol. 23, no. 8, pp. 624640, 2012.
-
S. Shingo, Zero Quality Control: Source Inspection and the Poka-Yoke System. Cambridge, MA, USA: Productivity Press, 1986.
-
D. C. Montgomery, Introduction to Statistical Quality Control, 8th ed. Hoboken, NJ, USA: John Wiley & Sons, 2019.
-
K. Ishikawa, What Is Total Quality Control? The Japanese Way. Englewood Cliffs, NJ, USA: Prentice-Hall, 1985.
-
M. Imai, Kaizen: The Key to Japans Competitive Success. New York, NY, USA: McGraw-Hill, 1986.
-
J. K. Liker, The Toyota Way: 14 Management Principles from the Worlds Greatest Manufacturer. New York, NY, USA: McGraw-Hill, 2004.
-
International Automotive Task Force, IATF 16949:2016
Quality management system requirements for automotive production and relevant service parts organizations, IATF, 2016.
-
Belrise Industries Pvt. Ltd., Plant B-39, Chakan, Pune, Line W610 daily FTY records, Firewall rework register, robotic-cell cycle-time observations and Poka-Yoke audit, May 2026, unpublished internal records, 2026.
