🌏
International Knowledge Platform
Serving Researchers Since 2012

Operational and Supply Chain Improvements During the New Product Development Phase: An On-the-Job Training Study at an Automotive Component Manufacturer

DOI : 10.17577/IJERTCONV14IS120011
Download Full-Text PDF Cite this Publication

Text Only Version

Operational and Supply Chain Improvements During the New Product Development Phase: An On-the-Job Training Study at an Automotive Component Manufacturer

Ishan Zore

Student, MBA- Operations and Supply Chain Management,

School of Business, Indira University, Pune, India 41103

Dr. Nagesh Tarte

Asssistant Professor & Guide, School of Business,

Indira University, Pune, India-411033

Dr. Hetal Bhinde

Associate Dean Ph.D. Programs, School of Business,

Indira University, Pune, India-411033 hetalb19@gmail.com

ORCID: https://orcid.org/0000-0002- 6435-5113

Abstract – Because all deficiencies in change control, part readiness, welding capability, or documentation can be a source of delay in automotive component production and appear later on as rework or warranty expenses, New Product Development (NPD) is one of the most resource- consuming processes. This study records an 8-week On-the- Job Training (OJT) that was implemented in the Operations and NPD function of a Tier-1 supplier, Belrise Industries Ltd., Chakan, which specializes in the production of fabricated and welded sheet-metal components and assemblies. The study looks through direct participation in the activities, shop floor observation, discussions with engineers and supervisors, and a daily training log, at 10 activities that lie between design release and mass production readiness: Engineering Change Notice (ECN) study, supplier coordination, part readiness verification, robot installation support, cycle time study, welding break analysis, missing weld improvement, positional shift analysis, cross car beam inspection and gauging, and sample dispatch with Production Part Approval Process (PPAP) documentation.

Results reveal that all ten activities had cross-functional communication as a common success factor. Risks of out dated revisions reaching the shop floor were minimised by controlled ECNs with defined cut-in points and cross functional sign-off and part readiness checks were most effective when carried out a few days before a trial. It was suggested that the interruptions in the welding process were small in themselves but they were numerous, and therefore their impact on output was greater than the sum of the individual interruptions. Welds were often missed at hard- to-reach locations, thus suggesting a fixture or accessibility cause with root cause analysis (RCA) to prevent recurrence, whereas rework was far superior to preventing the occurrence. The quality of a PPAP submission was as good as the discipline applied along the way in the NPD cycle.

Several cost-effective suggestions from the trainee's perspective to enhance NPD readiness are recommended:

  • Shared Supplier Issue Tracker: Instead of relying on Notes, have an Issues Tracker that is updated on a regular basis with any open issues from suppliers that may be missed between Notes.

  • Early Fixture Review Trigger: If a defect (e.g. missing weld) appears at the same location more than once, make a preemptive fixture & process design review.

  • Cross-Training within the Installation Plan: Do not have to delay the installation of new automated work- cells because the operators become skilled.

  • Lightweight Digital Data Capture: Capture cycle time and positional measurement data digitally, which helps to reduce manual compilation efforts and speed up the rate of trend detection.

By focusing on these coordination points using straightforward tracking and review processes, these simple methodologies ensure the detection of issues at an earlier stage and a smoother transition to mass production without significant investments..

Keywords New Product Development (NPD), APQP, PPAP, Engineering Change Notice (ECN), Cycle Time Analysis, Welding Quality, Automotive Component Manufacturing.

  1. INTRODUCTION

    In the automotive component manufacturing industry, one of the most expensive and crucial processes is New Product Development (NPD). The product component or sub-assembly goes through design validation, process validation, quality assurance and production readiness confirmation before it can be approved for mass production. An uncontrolled engineering change, an unqualified component, a lack of capability in the

    welding process or an incomplete Production Part Approval Process (PPAP) submission at this stage can lead to delays in the launch, warranty problems or high rework costs at full-scale production. In the past decade, the expectations of OEMs in India have increased and now, a component supplier is expected to prove not just their conformance with the design, but also prove their process conformance, traceability and readiness with documented evidence.

    Often NPD is talked about as a design and engineering activity, but a significant percentage of the work required to get to mass production is operational. Operations and supply chain activities procure parts from suppliers when needed, confirm the quality of parts made by the tools and fixtures, train operators, install and commission equipment, including robots and welding cells, and document the process and build the process documentation trail that can be trusted by a customer. Belrise Industries Ltd. is an Tier-1 supplier of sheet metal fabricated and welded assemblies, precision-machined components and allied sub-systems to passenger-car and commercial vehicle original- equipment manufacturers. OEM plants are also located in the Chakan-Talegaon auto belt, where its Chakan facility is located near Pune, close to Tier-1 and Tier-2 suppliers.

    This study seeks to explore this issue based upon a practice based investigation through an eight week On-the-Job Training (OJT) programme in the Operations and NPD function of Chakan plant. The trainee participated in and was supported by 10 activities, some of which were related to ECN studies and some to sample dispatch. The study approaches NPD from operations and supply chain perspective, examining how the coordination between engineering, quality, production and suppliers affects the smoothness or problems in a launch. The paper explores the literature, outlines the aims and technique, discusses each activity and the trends within them, and summarizes the results, recommendations and limitations.

  2. LITERATURE REVIEW AND THEORETICAL BACKGROUND

    1. Literature Review

      Carrying the idea of a stage-gate system into the automotive arena, Cooper (1990) has identified a series of stages in a new product project where a decision gate is located. The Automotive Industry Action Group (AIAG, 2008a) organises product launch under Advanced Product Quality Planning (APQP) into five phases: planning and definition, product design and development, process design and development, product and process validation, and feedback, assessment and corrective action. The Part Submission Warrant (PSW) is the final part of a supplier's documentation set which shows that the supplier's process can consistently deliver conforming parts at the required rate according to PPAP (AIAG, 2006). Assisting tools in this regard are Process Failure Mode and Effects Analysis (AIAG, 2008b) and Measurement Systems Analysis (AIAG, 2010) which verifies that gauge readings are reliable as well. These methods run within the quality management system established by the IATF 16949 standard (IATF, 2016).

      Process efficiency is provided by lean literature. Ohno (1988) and Womack and Jones (2003) focus production improvement on cycle time, takt time andelimination of waste, while Ohno popularized asking why five times about a problem's cause, the 5-Why method. The cause and effect diagram is a technique of root cause analysis, which was developed by

      Ishikawa (1985). The difference between common cause and special cause variation behind positional and dimensional monitoring is explained by Montgomery (2009) and how cost of poor quality increases as defect is detected later is discussed in Juran and Godfrey (1999). The book Groover (2015) is devoted to robotic automation and integration into production systems. Typically, these sources will work with each framework individually. This paper provides a practice-based description of how they work together, coordinated by an Operations and NPD function, in a working Tier-1 plant.

    2. Theoretical Background

    The study has been based on the structured approach method of APQP and PPAP. The automotive typical NPD cycle consists of Design Freeze and Drawing Release, Tooling and Fixture Design, Trial and/or Prototype Builds, Process Capability Studies, Dimensional and Functional Validation, Production Part Approval and Ramp-Up. Coordinate supplier coordination, verify part/process readiness, and build evidence trails for customer approval at nearly every step in OPS. The internship activities such as part readiness verification, cycle time study, welding and positional analysis map onto the process design and validation activities of APQP.

    There are two key control mechanisms. A formal document used to document, review, approve and communicate a design change to all affected functions is called an Engineering Change Notice (ECN), that includes a cut-in point of when/where/from what serial number/date/lot the change applies. PPAP then gathers design records, process flow diagrams, control plans, dimensional results, material and performance results and sample parts into a package for customer sign-off. Both mechanisms provide documentation that serves as the common memory of a cross-functional process: No one person is present throughout all the steps in such a process, so they rely on the output of another function by trusting the documentation.

    The four lenses are used to measure process efficiency and quality. Cycle time is the time needed to perform one cycle in an operation and Takt time is the pace needed to satisfy a customer's demand. Weld quality is assessed by size of nugget, strength, no spatter/burn through, no lack of weld and interruption logs/root cause techniques trace defects to fixture, parameters, electrodes/technique. Positional shift is any variation from the designed position of a feature and can be either a random (common-cause) or systematic (special-cause). Finally, the cost of fixing an error increases rapidly with each step it makes in its life, known as the rule of ten, which is the common theme in all of these activities early detection.

  3. MATERIALS AND METHODS

    1. Research Objectives

      This study examines operational activities during NPD at Belrise Industries Ltd. to achieve seven objectives:

      1. To understand the NPD process followed from design release through to production readiness.

      2. To study operational activities during NPD, including engineering change management, supplier coordination and part readiness verification.

      3. To analyse process improvement initiatives, particularly around welding quality and dimensional control.

      4. To understand the production readiness requirements of tooling, process capability and documentation that precede mass production.

      5. To identify operational challenges during NPD and note potential improvement opportunities.

      6. To gain first-hand exposure to manufacturing operations, automation deployment and quality systems.

      7. To consolidate these observations into a structured account of practice that can serve as an academic reference.

    2. Research Design and Data Collection

      The study is descriptive and observational in nature designed as single site case study at the Chakan facility for an eight week OJT. It is not a hypothesis-testing or statistically inferential design; it is a narrative of real-time, operational experience. Primary data was obtained from direct involvement in ECN review, part readiness, robot time, robot gauging, on the floor observation of robot installation, welding operation, and sample dispatch, informal briefing and discussion with the training guide, the engineers and the supervisors from Operations, Manufacturing Engineering, Quality, and Production, as well as photos taken with permission. The secondary material was general references on APQP, PPAP and automotive quality management which were utilized only to explain, but not to describe specific procedures of companies. Observations were made daily in a training diary and summarized according to the type of activity. The numbers given, e.g. cycle times and numbers of defect/s were recorded then and are reported in a generalised manner here as examples.

    3. Analytical Framework

    Each activity was analysed under a common structure: The analysis of each activity followed a common structure; background, process followed, tools/documents referred, observations, challenges that were faced, and key learning. Those patterns that emerged during all activities were then summarised in a table of interfaces and risks and a SWOT like analysis of the NPD process was prepared as seen from the trainee's point of view. The layout documentation support was done as the support activity for Manufacturing Engineering and covered in the discussion of readiness. The scope does not include proprietary information, financial, costing, strategic, which was not made available, as well as steady-state mass- production indicators over extended period of time.

  4. DATA ANALYSIS AND DISCUSSION

    1. Organisation of the NPD Function and Activity Sequence

      The organisation of the NPD function and activity sequence is analysed. The function and activity sequence of the NPD is analysed for organisation.The clearest impression gained was that the NPD is basically cross functional in nature. No department, Design, Manufacturing Engineering, Quality or Production, is capable of moving a component from design release to production. The Operations and NPD function is there to help coordinate this flow, keeping track of what has been done, what is not and what functions should be pulled in to close an open issue. The overall flow that was observed was as follows: Released component or ECN reviewed and communicated, cycle time studies to ensure output targets are met, tooling, fixtures and robotic work-cells prepared, suppliers coordinated for external components, trial parts built and inspected, defects investigated and corrected, when the process is stabilized, samples dispatched with PPAP documentation. The trainee was tasked with assisting in tracking and documenting these readiness activities, providing a cross-departmental perspective on these activities rather than from a departmental perspective.

      TABLE I.

      Activities Observed, Owning Functions and Purpose

      Activity

      Primary Owning

      Function

      Purpose

      ECN Study

      Design /

      Engineering

      Understand how design changes are approved, documented and

      communicated

      Supplier Meeting Participation

      Supply Chain / Operations

      Understand coordination

      with external suppliers during NPD

      Part Readiness Verification

      Operations / Quality

      Confirm component availability and validation

      before trials

      Robot Installation Support

      Manufacturing Engineering /

      Production

      Observe automation deployment to improve

      productivity

      Cycle Time Study

      Manufacturing Engineering

      Measure and analyse operation timing against

      target

      Welding Break Analysis

      Production / Manufacturing

      Engineering

      Study interruptions and their effect on production

      Missing Weld

      Improvement

      Quality / Production

      Identify weld defects and

      study corrective action

      Positional Shift

      Analysis

      Quality

      Study dimensional variation

      in manufacturing operations

      Inspection and

      Gauging

      Quality

      Verify dimensions and

      quality requirements

      Sample Dispatch and PPAP

      Quality / Operations

      Understand customer

      approval and documentation requirements

      Table I shows the top ten activities of a launch, and the function which owns each one. As can be seen in the ownership column, 9 of the 10 activities are spread over more than one function and the other function is also involved and the 10th activity, cycle time study, lets other functions make decisions.

    2. Engineering Change Control and Supplier Coordination

      The trainee was given an introduction to the ECN format, and followed the stages of approval from Design and Engineering to Manufacturing Engineering to Quality to implementation, as well as how the change was communicated to Production and Supply Chain, and how part configurations were compared before and after the change was made. Table II lists the fields that an ECN collects. One design change was noticed to affect tooling, fixtures, inspection gauges and supplier specifications, all of which had to be changed simultaneously. Cross-functional sign-off made the process controlled, not ad hoc, and the cut-in point was a critical factor as it ensured that old and new revisions didn't get muddled on the shop floor or in inventory. The biggest challenge for the newbies was the drawing conventions and terms in the revision-history section.

      TABLE II.

      llustrative Fields Captured in an Engineering Change Notice

      Field

      Purpose

      Part Number and Revision

      Uniquely identifies the affected component and its version

      Reason for Change

      Explains the driver: customer request, design fix, cost or feasibility, quality

      Affected Functions

      Lists departments (Design, Manufacturing

      Engineering, Quality, Supply Chain) that must act

      Cut-in Point

      Specifies the serial number, date or lot from which the change applies

      Approval Signatures

      Cross-functional sign-off before implementation on the shop floor

      In supplier meetings the trainee attended in a listening and note-taking capacity. Component readiness against project time lines, specification limits, inspection and sample submission, delayed and non-conforming components, delivery dates and quantities, and communicating to suppliers to ensure they are on schedule were discussed. The findings were clear: coordination is as much about the discipline of the communicating process (clear, timely and documented follow-up) as it is about the technical content. Unclosed issues that reoccurred near the trial date were more expensive to solve and suppliers had to have a sufficient lead time for an engineering change. The open-issues tracker was reviewed prior to every meeting, helping the trainee pick up on abbreviations, part numbers and previous conversations.

    3. Part Readiness Verification and Automation Deployment

      All components should be verified for availability, identified and validated prior to a production trial. The trainee checked part number, revision level, quantity against the trial requirement, checked batch and lot markings against accompanying documentation, checked if inspection or test certificates were available and identified any deficiencies to the Operations team and NPD team. However, the sub-assemblies are created in a definite sequence, so if one assembly is not delivered or mis- identified, the whole trial can be delayed. If there was a problem later on, traceability markings would be what enabled the batch to be traced to its production and inspection records, and verification was most effective when it was completed a few days before the trial date. Initially, it was challenging to read lot codes and the quality group was needed to direct them.

      A robotic work-cell was being installed in the internship as an effort to improve productivity. The trainee watched the robot and its control cabinet being received, unpacked and positioned, the area was barricaded, early discussions were held on the motion path and how it would integrate with the surrounding manual and semi-automated processes, and the anticipated benefits versus the manual process were considered. The installation process was found to be a multi-stage process where physical installation is not necessarily the last and safety integration, programming, and validation are the next steps. Safety fencing and interlocks were regarded as a requisite and built before the equipment was installed. On repetitive work, automation was implemented to enhance the consistency and to alleviate the fatigue of the operator; in addition, automation was also used to increase the throughput. This activity was an observational activity due to time constraints, particularly in relation to programming and motion path teaching.

    4. Process Efficiency: Cycle Time and Welding Break Analysis

      The cycle time study involved determining the cycle time of an operation with the component under development and comparing it to the desired output rate. The trainee used a stopwatch to time a few repetitions, documented load, process and unload elements individually (Table III), compared to takt time and discussed any fixtures or sequencing change needed if the target is exceeded. It was possible to see where time was being lost, the small variations in operator motion were obvious to the extent that they would affect consistency, and several repeats were required as a single repeat was not reliable. The next step in a timing exercise is to compare cycle time with takt time, making it an input to a capacity-planning exercise.

      TABLE III.

      llustrative Structure of a Cycle Time Study

      Element

      What Is Measured

      Load Time

      Time to place the component into the fixture or

      machine

      Process Time

      Time for the value-adding operation, such as

      welding or forming

      Unload Time

      Time to remove the finished or processed component

      Total Cycle

      Time

      Sum of all elements, compared against the

      target takt time

      The welding break analysis examined breaks in a welding job over several work cycles. Interruptions were classified by potential cause with welding operator and supervisor (Table IV), and time lost due to interruptions were estimated, along with discussion with production team regarding mitigation (preventive maintenance scheduling, material staging, etc.). The number of such interruptions was large, but brief and the cumulative effect of all the interruptions was greater than any single one indicated. It helped to categorise by cause and so identify an intervention be it maintenance, material planning or training that would pay off best. Consistent logging enabled patterns to be seen that were not captured by a single shift's observation. The first classification made by the trainee was generally to classify common material changes as breaks, which the shift supervisor corrected.

      TABLE IV.

      llustrative Categorisation of Welding Interruptions

      Category

      Example Cause

      Equipment-related

      Electrode wear, gun or torch malfunction, power

      fluctuation

      Material-related

      Delayed component staging, incorrect material

      batch

      Process / operator-

      related

      Parameter adjustment, minor rework, operator

      changeover

    5. Quality Validation: Missing Weld, Positional Shift and Inspection

      The missing weld improvement study began with To identify the location of missing welds, the missing weld improvement study started with records of the inspections, which were used to determine where missing welds had been documented, and then a direct examination of affected assemblies to determine if there was a missing weld or a partial weld was formed. Follow up inspection of fixture or parameter corrective action was done during a root cause discussion with quality and production personnel with regard to the fixture clamping, weld-gun access and programmed weld-point sequence. Missed welds were more likely to occur at specific locations that is more difficult to access, indicating a fixture or accessibility problem, rather than random. It was important to have a short feedback loop between quality (which could detect the defect) and production or manufacturing engineering (which could change the process if necessary) so as to avoid recurrence, even basic root cause analysis, much better than reworking defective parts.

      The drawing was used to find the nominal position and tolerance of a feature, a sample of the parts was taken on a gauge and the readings were plotted to determine if the variation was random or would indicate fixture wear. Table V shows the illustrative structure. The majority of the parts sampled were within tolerance, however borderline readings indicated that there was little room for the process to run. A directional pattern

      was a better indicator of a special cause than an isolated out-of- tolerance reading, and there was some variation from one setting to another of the gauge, emphasizing the need for a standard setting procedure. The quality engineer cross-checked the trainee's early readings prior to use.

      TABLE V.

      llustrative Data Structure for Positional Shift Analysis

      Sample No.

      Measured Position (Illustrative)

      Within Tolerance?

      1

      Nominal ± 0.2 mm

      Yes

      2

      Nominal ± 0.3 mm

      Yes

      3

      Nominal + 0.6 mm

      Borderline; flagged for review

      4

      Nominal ± 0.2 mm

      Yes

      5

      Nominal ± 0.3 mm

      Yes

      The cross car beam, which forms part of the structure beneath several vehicle sub-systems, was used for inspection and gauging, meaning it is particularly important that it is dimensionally accurate. The trainee watched the typical workflow of visual inspection to dimensional gauging, helped to place the part in the gauge, marked the pass/fail results for each inspection feature and recorded how out-of-tolerance results were followed-up and how the inspection frequency and sample size were determined. A risk-based approach was implemented with more rigorous processing of the critical structural parts than the less critical brackets. A number of features could be checked quickly and consistently using standardised gauging fixtures and a clear record enabled a drifting dimension to be captured before it became a fault. It was initially difficult to find the critical-to- quality features on such a large assembly, and it required the inspection checklist and the quality engineer.

    6. Sample Dispatch and PPAP Documentation

      The last of the readiness activities was sample dispatch. The trainee watched the samples being selected, identified and prepared, checked at a general level the documentation compiled for a PPAP submission (Table VI), and reported that dispatch was coordinated with the completion of inspection and documentation, ensuring that the samples never went away before the supporting documentation. The PSW serves as a customer's formal acceptance that the process of a supplier is ready for production. Not only was dispatch not considered a routine shipment, but these records and inspection data were treated as a controlled event, and missing information was a direct cause for delays in approval. Conceptually the most challenging activity was understanding PPAP which relies on outputs from almost all previous activities.

      TABLE VI.

      road Categories of Documentation in a PPAP Package

    7. Consolidated Interfaces and Risks

      Reviewing the 10 activities, almost all required effective and timely cross-functional communication between at least two functions. Communication was clear and early in ECN review, and thus work went well. When information was received late and informally, such as when information was received from suppliers, there was pressure neaIr the trial or dispatch date. Early issue identification, from ECN review to PPAP documentation, provided no means to cause additional delays and hence the summary of interfaces and risks in Table VII indicate where it is most important.

      TABLE VII.

      ey Interfaces and Risks Across Activities

      Activity

      Key Interface

      Risk if Poorly Executed

      ECN Study

      Design / Engineering and Manufacturing /

      Quality

      Delayed tooling or fixture update if not clearly

      communicated

      Supplier Coordination

      Supply Chain and external suppliers

      Component shortfall or non- conformance near the trial

      date

      Part Readiness

      Operations and Quality

      Delayed or aborted trial due to missing or mismatched

      components

      Robot Installation

      Manufacturing Engineering and

      Production

      Delayed commissioning if safety and integration are not

      planned early

      Cycle Time

      Study

      Manufacturing

      Engineering (internal)

      Line unable to meet takt time

      if not found before ramp-up

      Welding Break Analysis

      Production and Maintenance

      Reduced throughput from unaddressed recurring

      interruptions

      Missing Weld Study

      Quality and

      Production /

      Manufacturing Engineering

      Recurring structural defect if root cause is not resolved

      Positional Shift

      Quality (internal)

      Fit issues downstream if drift

      is not detected early

      Inspection and

      Gauging

      Quality (internal)

      Out-of-specification parts

      reaching the customer

      Sample Dispatch /

      PPAP

      Quality, Operations and Customer

      Delayed approval and mass- production start

      /li>

    8. SWOT Assessment of the NPD Process

    Table VIII summarises the trainees SWOT-style view. It reflects a limited-duration, learning-stage exposure and should be read as an outside observation rather than a formal organisational audit.

    TABLE VIII.

    Dimension

    Observations

    Strengths

    A defined cross-functional ECN process; structured part- readiness and inspection checkpoints before trials and sample dispatch; investment in robotic work-cells; an evidence-based PPAP approach drawing on upstream

    data. B

    Weaknesses

    Some supplier information reached stakeholders informally rather than through systematic tracking; fixture or process design reviews could be triggered earlier for recurring defects; cross-training on new

    automated cells took longer than installation itself.

    Opportunities

    Shared trackers for supplier open issues; wider use of root-cause analysis for recurring quality issues; digitised

    cycle-time and positional data to speed up trend detection.

    Threats

    Rising OEM quality and documentation expectations; dependence on external suppliers for certain components; shift of risk from manual variability to equipment uptime

    and programming reliability as automation grows.

    WOT Assessment of the NPD Process as Observed

    Category

    General Purpose

    Design Records and

    ECNs

    Confirms the part is built to the latest

    approved design

    Process Flow and

    Control Plan

    Documents how the part is manufactured and

    controlled

    Dimensional Results

    Evidence that sample parts meet drawing

    tolerances

    Material / Performance

    Results

    Evidence that the part meets material and

    functional requirements

    Sample Parts and PSW

    Physical evidence and formal submission for

    customer sign-off

  5. FINDINGS, CONCLUSIONS AND SUGGESTIONS

  1. Findings

    The Belrise Industries Ltd. study of NPD activities led to seven findings. First, the need for departments to communicate with each other is essential and the coordinating role of the Operations and NPD function arises from the fact that no single department is responsible for all the dependencies. Second, engineering changes need to be well managed and have defined cut-in points and cross functional sign-off to prevent the possibility of delay or outdated revisions being used. Third, when carried out with sufficient lead time, readiness activities including part verification, layout documentation and cycle time studies increase the likelihood of a successful launch. Fourthly, automation helps in achieving efficiency and consistency under proper safety planning and when integrated with existing processes. Fifth, cycle time studies are a low cost, high value process of identifying a bottleneck and determining if a new process can meet takt time. Finally, risk reduction is greatest when the gauging, positioning analysis and missing-weld investigation is used in conjunction with root-cause analysis rather than as a means of sifting good parts from bad. Seventh, problems that were detected early were addressed with little disruption to the class.Seventh, problems that were detected early were addressed without significant disruption to the class.

    Other improvements in operation were noted. Structured ECN management mitigated the possibility of employing an outdated revision. Systematic part checks decreased the number of trials that were delayed or aborted. The robotic work-cell was envisioned to help to increase consistency and output rate of the related welding operation, and to decrease operator exposure to repetitive, physically demanding work. Utilizing the information from positional data, the quality team was able to distinguish normal variation from the emerging special cause. A root cause investigation was conducted to address a recurring problem of missing weld on a specific part. A set of standardised gauges and checklists facilitated more rapid and consistent verification of critical dimensions. The most significant issue that directly affected the ease of customer approval was disciplined PPAP compilation.

  2. Conclusions

    The study finds the success of change management, supplier coordination, part and process preparation verification, targeted automation, and disciplined quality validation and rigorous documentation are the critical factors that decide whether the new product launch goes well or if it becomes an impediment. No single activity can be a successful guarantee; it is the organized and coordinated execution of all of them, coordinated by the Operations and NPD function that makes it possible to have an efficient and reliable transition from development to stable mass production. Personally, the internship deepened the understanding of manufacturing processes, enhanced observational and analytical capabilities by experiencing actual manufacturing challenges, and reinforced the importance of effective cross-functional collaboration.

  3. Suggestions

    These are suggestions for the main stakeholder groups of ideas for learning stages, not prescriptions.

    Supply chain and procurement: Create a common, updated and formal supplier open-issues tracker to minimise the chance of missing open-issues between meetings.

    Manufacturing engineering and quality: If a defect, like a missing weld, is appearing at the same spot again, conduct a fixture / process design review proactively. If possible, investigate and explore the use of a light digital data capturing device to allow for quicker picking up of trends with cycle time and positioning-measurement data.

    Production and training: Incorporate cross training and operator familiarisation with new automated work cells into installation schedule, not on the critical path after the equipment has been commissioned.

    Reinforce to the design, engineering and NPD team that verification of the cut-in point and full distribution of an ECN should be done, especially for new engineering and interns, before considering a change as implemented on the shop floor.

    Internship coordinators: Guide and give a brief introduction about the shop-floor terminology and format of documentation in the initial few days during internships in the Operations and NPD function to minimize the orientation time.

  4. Implications of the Study

    The results have implications for a number of groups. They demonstrate that readiness is a process of coordination and early detection, not late inspection, for operations and NPD management. They demonstrate to quality and manufacturing engineering staff that conducting root cause analysis and trend review of measurement data will provide greater protection than sorting parts after the fact. For suppliers, they show the value of early communication of engineering changes and of shared tracking of open issues. The study provides a documented case on how the APQP, PPAP, ECN control and lean tools are used together on a shop floor, as a complement to classroom instruction in each of these areas.

  5. Limitations of the Study

    The observations are only for one plant, one function, one period and may not reflect other Belrise Industries plants or other periods. Each activity was limited by the length of the internship, and some activities, specifically PPAP submission and the complete commissioning of the robot, were only partially observed. Actul cycle times and defect rates, and actual supplier names are generalised or illustrative for confidentiality. The trainee also had a steep learning curve for reading drawings, reading of the ECN record, reading of gauge readings, and new terminology used on the shop floor, as well as working in a more observational than hands-on way for the most technical work.

  6. Future Scope of the Study

This report indicates some topics for future research. A longer quantitative study could be conducted to kick off from ECN to PPAP approval and ramp-up, and measure steady state production parameters that fall outside the scope of this study. Data captured in a digital format of cycle-time and position could help with statistical process control and detection of drift earlier. To test the rule-of-ten logic in this context, the cost of poor quality that could be avoided by implementing early root- cause analysis could be measured. Comparisons between plants or product families might investigate whether the coordination patterns found here are general.

ACKNOWLEDGMENT

I would like to express my sincere and heartfelt thanks to Belrise Industries Ltd., Chakan for allowing me to join them for On-the-Job Training in the Operations and New Product

Development function and to my Training Guide and also my Operations and NPD team for their guidance and being patient

[3] AIAG. (2008b). Potential failure mode and effects analysis (FMEA): Reference manual (4th ed.). Automotive Industry

with me in understanding shop-floor processes. I would also like to express my gratitude to the Quality and Manufacturing Engineering and Production departments for allowing me to stay

[4]

Action Group.

AIAG. (2010). Measurement systems analysis (MSA): Reference manual (4th ed.). Automotive Industry Action Group.

on during inspection, gauging, installation of the robot and sample dispatch. I am thankful to my faculty guide Dr. Nagesh Tarte, Head of department and faculty coordinators of Indira University for academic guidance and to family and peers for encouragement.

Disclaimer: Quantitative information including exact cycle times, defect rates and supplier names have been generalised or presented for illustrative purposes for the sake of confidentiality. Observations are based only on the limited period of time that the trainee has spent and cannot be seen as an audit of the organisation.

REFERENCES

  1. AIAG. (2006). Production part approval process (PPAP)

    (4th ed.). Automotive Industry Action Group.

  2. AIAG. (2008a). Advanced product quality planning (APQP) and control plan: Reference manual (2nd ed.). Automotive Industry Action Group.

  1. Cooper, R. G. (1990). Stage-gate systems: A new tool for managing new products. Business Horizons, 33(3), 4454.

  2. Groover, M. P. (2015). Automation, production systems, and computer-integrated manufacturing (4th ed.). Pearson.

  3. IATF. (2016). IATF 16949:2016 Quality management system requirements for automotive production and relevant service parts organizations (1st ed.). International Automotive Task Force.

  4. Ishikawa, K. (1985). What is total quality control? The Japanese way. Prentice-Hall.

  5. Juran, J. M., & Godfrey, A. B. (1999). Jurans quality handbook (5th ed.). McGraw-Hill.

  6. Montgomery, D. C. (2009). Introduction to statistical quality control (6th ed.). John Wiley & Sons.

  7. Ohno, T. (1988). Toyota production system: Beyond large- scale production. Productivity Press.

  8. Womack, J. P., & Jones, D. T. (2003). Lean thinking: Banish waste and create wealth in your corporation (Rev. ed.). Free Press.